From the Boundary of the World to the Boundary of Reason: The First Antinomy and the Development of Kant’s Critical Philosophy (2022)
An ancient cosmological debate lies behind the spatial part of the first antinomy in Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason. Against the Aristotelian conception of a finite universe, a thought experiment proposed we imagine ourselves situated on the boundary of the world: what happens if we stretch a hand beyond the boundary? This article first shows that aspects of this debate persist in the cosmological claims of Huygens, Wolff, and Crusius. With his presentation of opposing arguments in the first antinomy, Kant famously rejected both sides of the debate and asserted that we cannot meaningfully inquire into the spatial boundary of the world. I then argue that the critical-period Kant nevertheless does not simply dismiss the issue of an outer boundary of the world: he rather reconceives it as the question of the boundary of the legitimate use of our cognitive faculties. The cosmological question of the boundary of the world is transformed—from Kant’s Inaugural Dissertation through his Reflexionen of the 1770s to the first Critique—into the critical question of the boundary of reason.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Frierson, Patrick;
(2008)
Empirical Psychology, Common Sense, and Kant's Empirical Markers for Moral Responsibility
(/isis/citation/CBB000931152/)
Article
Claus Beisbart;
(2022)
What Is the Spatiotemporal Extension of the Universe? Underdetermination according to Kant’s First Antinomy and in Present-Day Cosmology
(/isis/citation/CBB854889177/)
Article
Silvia De Bianchi;
(2022)
Kant’s Functional Cosmology: Teleology, Measurement, and Symbolic Representation in the Critique of Judgment
(/isis/citation/CBB510519330/)
Book
Marco Costantini;
(2024)
Kant, i filosofi, i visionari
(/isis/citation/CBB836487229/)
Book
Fabio Minazzi;
(2021)
Epistemologia storico-evolutiva e neorealismo logico
(/isis/citation/CBB163381119/)
Book
Friedman, Michael;
(2001)
Dynamics of Reason: The 1999 Kant Lectures at Stanford University
(/isis/citation/CBB000102341/)
Article
Alexey Zhavoronkov;
(2022)
Kant's pragmatic use of reason from a sociological point of view: Third way or methodological impasse?
(/isis/citation/CBB523385239/)
Article
Rayman, Joshua;
(2014)
Crossing the Epistemological Divide: Foucault, Barthes, and Neo-Kantianism
(/isis/citation/CBB001421725/)
Article
Kelle Dhein;
(2023)
The cognitive map debate in insects: A historical perspective on what is at stake
(/isis/citation/CBB595507323/)
Article
Chen, Xiang;
(2010)
A Different Kind of Revolutionary Change: Transformation from Object to Process Concepts
(/isis/citation/CBB001021669/)
Book
Michela Massimi;
Angela Breitenbach;
(2017)
Kant and the Laws of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB352248455/)
Article
Melissa McBay Merritt;
(2015)
Varieties of Reflection in Kant's Logic
(/isis/citation/CBB489711838/)
Book
Rescher, Nicholas;
(2000)
Kant and the reach of reason: Studies in Kant's theory of rational systematization
(/isis/citation/CBB000110915/)
Article
Steigerwald, Joan;
(2003)
The Dynamics of Reason and Its Elusive Object in Kant, Fichte and Schelling
(/isis/citation/CBB000340873/)
Article
T. J. Martinson;
(2019)
Sense and Supersensibility: Kantian Aesthetics in Lamarckian Evolutionary Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB019213234/)
Article
John J. Kaag;
(2015)
The Lot of the Beautiful: Pragmatism and Aesthetic Ideals
(/isis/citation/CBB055986571/)
Article
Clinton Tolley;
(2020)
Kant on the place of cognition in the progression of our representations
(/isis/citation/CBB063404893/)
Article
Guyer, Paul;
(2008)
The Psychology of Kant's Aesthetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000931153/)
Article
Schmidt, Claudia M.;
(2008)
Kant's Transcendental and Empirical Psychology of Cognition
(/isis/citation/CBB000931151/)
Article
Marcus Willaschek;
Eric Watkins;
(2020)
Kant on cognition and knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB232801261/)
Be the first to comment!