“Consumer Terrorists”: Battles over Agricultural Antibiotics in the United States and Western Europe (2016)
Finlay, Mark R. (Author)
Marcus, Alan I. (Author)
Agricultural History
Volume: 90
Issue: 2
Pages: 146-172
This paper examines the reception and regulation of antibiotics in animal agriculture in the United States and Europe. It finds two different cultural traditions. In the United States, a libertarian ethos, aided and abetted by big agriculture, hampers effective regulation. Authoritarianism in Europe promotes active and aggressive regulation. These two thrusts have something in common: both effectively obscure science and scientific debate. Policy on the two sides of the Atlantic reflects a priori assumptions rather than thorough scientific scrutiny. We assert that there is a larger moral here. Indeed, scientism as practiced and expertise generally lack the technological competence to define an objective course. Repeated dependence on the quest for scientific objectification to resolve public issues stands as nothing more than desperate and naïve pipedreams of what science and expertise can establish; they can and do contribute precious little to the discussion. Cultural presumptions and contemporary economic imperatives have set and will continue to be the basis for “scientific” decision-making and “rational” governmental policy.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Claas Kirchhelle;
(2018)
Swann Song: Antibiotic Regulation in British Livestock Production (1953–2006)
(/isis/citation/CBB970713571/)
Book
Joris Vandendriessche;
Evert Peeters;
Kaat Wils;
(2015)
Scientists' Expertise as Performance: Between State and Society, 1860–1960
(/isis/citation/CBB826263249/)
Article
Anderson, Virginia DeJohn;
(2002)
Animals into the Wilderness: The Development of Livestock Husbandry in the Seventeenth-Century Chesapeake
(/isis/citation/CBB000202351/)
Thesis
Matz, Brendan A.;
(2011)
Crafting Heredity: The Art and Science of Livestock Breeding in the United States and Germany, 1860--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001567276/)
Article
Pierre-Luc Germain;
Luca Chiapperino;
Giuseppe Testa;
(2017)
The European politics of animal experimentation: From Victorian Britain to ‘Stop Vivisection’
(/isis/citation/CBB443117651/)
Article
Mott Greene;
(2022)
Experts, Managerialism, and Democratic Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB659481305/)
Book
Claas Kirchhelle;
(2020)
Pyrrhic progress: the history of antibiotics in Anglo-American food production
(/isis/citation/CBB025736961/)
Article
Jessica Wang;
(2020)
Agricultural expertise, race, and economic development: Small producer ideology and settler colonialism in the Territory of Hawaiʻi, 1900–1917
(/isis/citation/CBB245206254/)
Article
Timothy K. Minella;
(2016)
A Pattern for Improvement: Pattern Farms and Scientific Authority in Early Nineteenth-Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB695597850/)
Book
Marco Castellari;
(2014)
Formula e metafora: figure di scienziati nelle letterature e culture contemporanee
(/isis/citation/CBB976488878/)
Book
Elisabetta Bini;
Elisabetta Vezzosi;
(2020)
Scienziati e guerra fredda: Tra collaborazione e diritti umani
(/isis/citation/CBB957549150/)
Chapter
Elisabetta Vezzosi;
(2020)
«International inter-changes for the benefit of all mankind». Scienziati statunitensi allo Scientific Forum di Amburgo (1980)
(/isis/citation/CBB056972908/)
Thesis
Schulz, Evan Karl;
(2000)
A theory of transnational regulatory contagion and its application to agricultural biotechnology in Europe and the United States, 1970--2000
(/isis/citation/CBB001562526/)
Article
Prodöhl, Ines;
(2013)
Versatile and Cheap: A Global History of Soy in the First Half of the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001421542/)
Article
Spiekermann, Uwe;
(2011)
Redefining Food: The Standardization of Products and Production in Europe and the United States, 1880--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001033640/)
Article
Garland E. Allen;
(2017)
Mendelism and the Promise of A New Agriculture, 1900-1945
(/isis/citation/CBB500275953/)
Book
Linda M. Ambrose;
Joan M. Jensen;
(2017)
Women in Agriculture: Professionalizing Rural Life in North America and Europe, 1880-1965
(/isis/citation/CBB186986941/)
Book
Curth, Louise Hill;
(2010)
The Care of Brute Beasts: A Social and Cultural Study of Veterinary Medicine in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001020712/)
Article
Marcus B. Carrier;
(2021)
The Making of Evident Expertise: Transforming Chemical Analytical Methods into Judicial Evidence
(/isis/citation/CBB614136192/)
Article
Chiou, Wen-Tsong;
(June 2019)
What Roles Can Lay Citizens Play in the Making of Public Knowledge?
(/isis/citation/CBB197683533/)
Be the first to comment!