From Poacher to Protector of Attention: The Therapeutic Turn of Persuasive Technology and Ethics of a Smartphone Habit-breaking Application (March 2022)
Alex Beattie (Author)
Science, Technology and Human Values
Volume: 47
Issue: 2
Pages: 337-359
Edition Details: Special Issue: Shifting Attention
Language: English
This paper critically investigates the ethical perspectives and practices of individuals and organizations who make persuasive technologies (“persuasive technologists”). An organization that claims to be at the forefront of ethical persuasion is behavioral software company Boundless Mind. Yet Boundless Mind sells ostensibly oxymoronic software products: an Application Programming Interface for third-party applications that optimizes the capture of end user attention, and an application for end users on how to make third-party applications less persuasive. Drawing upon Foucault’s interpretation of ethics as an “aesthetics of existence” and the related concept of “therapeutic authority,” I argue Boundless Mind justify the “poaching” and “protecting” of user attention based on a view of the human subject as fixable and their capability to instrumentalize user subjectivity to socially desirable ends. I walkthrough Boundless Mind’s technology-habit-breaking application Space and highlight a behavioral technique administered by Space called stimulus devaluation, which enables the user to develop a transformative relationship with their technology habits and persuasive applications. I conclude the paper by arguing that a persuasive technology ethics based on fixing the user obfuscates the power of persuasive technologists by limiting the scope of ethical inquiry to the activities of the user.
...MoreArticle Rebecca Jablonsky; Tero Karppi; Nick Seaver (March 2022) Introduction: Shifting Attention. Science, Technology and Human Values (pp. 235-242).
Similar Citations
Article
Ross, Philippe;
(April 2011)
Problematizing the user in user-centered production: A new media lab meets its audiences
(/isis/citation/CBB722647017/)
Article
Elizabeth Ransom;
Caitlin Grady;
Lauren Trepanier;
Carmen Bain;
(2023)
Situated Ethics in Development: STS Insights for a Pragmatic Approach to Development Policy and Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB917944487/)
Article
Karen Dam Nielsen;
Henriette Langstrup;
(April 2018)
Tactics of material participation: How patients shape their engagement through e-health
(/isis/citation/CBB575446408/)
Article
Alexander Peine;
Vivette van Cooten;
Louis Neven;
(May 2017)
Rejuvenating Design: Bikes, Batteries, and Older Adopters in the Diffusion of E-bikes
(/isis/citation/CBB869099994/)
Article
Phillip H. Roth;
Tommaso Bruni;
(2022)
Participation, Empowerment, and Evidence in the Current Discourse on Personalized Medicine: A Critique of “Democratizing Healthcare”
(/isis/citation/CBB677774404/)
Article
Charlotte Kroløkke;
(April 2019)
Life in the cryo-kennel: The ‘exceptional’ life of frozen pet DNA
(/isis/citation/CBB617942547/)
Article
Jacqueline Burgess;
Christian M. Jones;
(2017)
“Is It Too Much to Ask That We’re Allowed to Win the Game?”: Character Attachment and Agency in the Mass Effect 3 Ending Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB787791720/)
Article
Andrew Sixsmith;
Becky R. Horst;
Dorina Simeonov;
Alex Mihailidis;
(2022)
Older People’s Use of Digital Technology During the COVID-19 Pandemic
(/isis/citation/CBB218869342/)
Article
Graham Spinardi;
S.J. Cooper-Knock;
David Rush;
(2020)
Proximal design in South African informal settlements: Users as designers and the construction of the built environment and its fire risks
(/isis/citation/CBB954481617/)
Article
Mandy de Wilde;
(November 2021)
“A Heat Pump Needs a Bit of Care”: On Maintainability and Repairing Gender–Technology Relations
(/isis/citation/CBB932272197/)
Article
Rebecca Jablonsky;
(March 2022)
Meditation Apps and the Promise of Attention by Design
(/isis/citation/CBB875998706/)
Article
Anson Au;
Matthew Chew;
(2017)
How Do You Feel? Managing Emotional Reaction, Conveyance, and Detachment on Facebook and Instagram
(/isis/citation/CBB471103837/)
Article
Carsten Ochs;
Barbara Büttner;
Jörn Lamla;
(May 2021)
Trading Social Visibility for Economic Amenability: Data-based Value Translation on a “Health and Fitness Platform”
(/isis/citation/CBB474517087/)
Article
Tomas Ariztia;
Aline Bravo;
Ignacio Nuñez;
(2023)
Baroque tools for climate action. What do we learn from a catalogue of local technologies?
(/isis/citation/CBB596078043/)
Article
Shobita Parthasarathy;
(2022)
How sanitary pads came to save the world: Knowing inclusive innovation through science and the marketplace
(/isis/citation/CBB597313885/)
Book
Whitney Phillips;
(2015)
This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things
(/isis/citation/CBB028129341/)
Article
Laurel Smith-Doerr;
Itai Vardi;
(March 2015)
Mind the Gap: Formal Ethics Policies and Chemical Scientists’ Everyday Practices in Academia and Industry
(/isis/citation/CBB114416720/)
Book
Wen-yuan Lin;
(2014)
Kanbujian de xingdong nengli: Cong xingdongzhe wangluo dao weiyi lilun 看不見的行動能力:從行動者網絡到位移理論 (Invisible Agency: A Theory of Displacement for Subalterns)
(/isis/citation/CBB888068391/)
Article
Siles, Ignacio;
(October 2011)
From online filter to web format: Articulating materiality and meaning in the early history of blogs
(/isis/citation/CBB083186559/)
Article
Dana Zarhin;
(March 2018)
“I Don’t Want to See Myself as a Disabled Person”: Continuous Positive Airway Pressure Devices and the Emergence of (Dis)ability as Subjectivity
(/isis/citation/CBB369463842/)
Be the first to comment!