Kuhn’s two accounts of rational disagreement in science: an interpretation and critique (2021)
Whereas there is much discussion about Thomas Kuhn’s notion of methodological incommensurability and many have seen his ideas as an attempt to allow for rational disagreement in science, so far no serious analysis of how exactly Kuhn aims to account for rational disagreement has been proposed. This paper provides the first in-depth analysis of Kuhn’s account of rational disagreement in science—an account that can be seen as the most prominent attempt to allow for rational disagreement in science. Three things will be shown: First, we find not one, but two accounts of rational disagreements in science in Kuhn’s writings: one stemming from methodological incommensurability and one stemming from Kuhn-underdetermination, which are not only fundamentally different—the first purports to explain how disagreeing scientists can nevertheless be rational, while the second attempts to show how rational scientists can nevertheless disagree—but appear to be incompatible with each other. Second, I will assess both accounts. Kuhn’s account from methodological incommensurability is not convincing since it cannot explain rational disagreement in science. Whereas, on the other hand, Kuhn’s account from Kuhn-underdetermination allows for rational disagreement, his argument why we should accept it is not convincing. Third, I present a tentative sketch of an alternative to Kuhn’s account that emphasizes the fallibility of epistemic justification in order to show that Kuhn’s argument founders. In sum, the paper shows that focusing not on the muchly debated consequences of methodological incommensurability, but on Kuhn’s treatment of rational disagreement gives new insight into the adequate interpretation of his thought as well as the cogency of his ideas.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
K. Brad Wray;
(2021)
Interpreting Kuhn: Critical Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB103514339/)
Book
Bird, Alexander;
(2000)
Thomas Kuhn
(/isis/citation/CBB000110749/)
Chapter
Nye, Mary Jo;
(2010)
Science and Politics in the Philosophy of Science: Popper, Kuhn, and Polanyi
(/isis/citation/CBB001023240/)
Book
Leandro Giri;
Pablo Melogno;
Hernán Miguel;
(2023)
Perspectives on Kuhn: Contemporary Approaches to the Philosophy of Thomas Kuhn
(/isis/citation/CBB414507112/)
Book
Nola, Robert;
Sankey, Howard;
(2000)
After Popper, Kuhn and Feyerabend: Recent Issues in Theories of Scientific Method
(/isis/citation/CBB000110543/)
Essay Review
Turner, Stephen;
(2012)
Habermas Meets Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001500125/)
Article
George Borg;
(2020)
On 'the application of science to science itself:' Chemistry, instruments, and the scientific labor process
(/isis/citation/CBB166777080/)
Article
Luis Fernández Moreno;
Paula Atencia Conde-Pumpido;
(2021)
Kuhn, Putnam and the Reference
(/isis/citation/CBB979754022/)
Chapter
Carrier, Martin;
(2003)
Smooth Lines in Confirmation Theory: Carnap, Hempel, and the Moderns
(/isis/citation/CBB001213687/)
Article
Caneva, Kenneth L.;
(2000)
Possible Kuhns in the history of science: Anomalies of incommensurable paradigms
(/isis/citation/CBB000110755/)
Book
Bojana Mladenović;
(2017)
Kuhn's Legacy: Epistemology, Metaphilosophy, and Pragmatism
(/isis/citation/CBB010134158/)
Book
Thomas S. Kuhn;
Bojana Mladenovic;
(2022)
The Last Writings of Thomas S. Kuhn: Incommensurability in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB418530960/)
Article
Seguin, Eve;
(2000)
Bloor, Latour, and the field
(/isis/citation/CBB000110874/)
Article
Sismondo, Sergio;
(2012)
Fifty Years of the Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Twenty-Five of Science in Action
(/isis/citation/CBB001250748/)
Article
Dear, Peter;
(2012)
Fifty years of Structure
(/isis/citation/CBB001250750/)
Book
Mauskopf, Seymour;
Schmaltz, Tad;
(2012)
Integrating History and Philosophy of Science: Problems and Prospects
(/isis/citation/CBB001500237/)
Article
Turner, Stephen;
(2012)
Whatever Happened to Knowledge?
(/isis/citation/CBB001250758/)
Essay Review
Steven William Clarke;
(2016)
Popper and His Critics Revisited
(/isis/citation/CBB453006071/)
Article
Pickering, Andrew;
(2012)
The World since Kuhn
(/isis/citation/CBB001250757/)
Book
Nickles, Thomas;
(2003)
Thomas Kuhn
(/isis/citation/CBB000201501/)
Be the first to comment!