Article ID: CBB803947711

Expanding the Social Status of “Corpse” to the Severely Comatose: Henry Beecher and the Harvard Brain Death Committee (2022)


This essay examines the development of the seminal report, “A Definition of Irreversible Coma,” by the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death in 1968. Detailed examination of original documents archived in the Henry K. Beecher Papers at Harvard’s Countway Library reveals a variety of concerns and values at play in the development of the report, along with disagreement on a few key points among Committee members. One important goal of the Committee was to render treatment removal from patients in severe coma mandatory—not merely permissible—and without need for permission or consultation with the patient’s family. Protecting and supporting organ transplantation also played a significant role in the Committee’s writings and deliberations. Multiple concepts of death and justifications for brain death can be found, most of them inconsistent with each other and offered without a clear rationale. The essay emphasizes what is perhaps the most important aspect of this period in history: this is the moment when, without clear physiologic justification, the social and legal status of “corpse” became compulsorily applied to living human bodies.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Susan E. Lederer; (2016)
“Ethics and Clinical Research” in Biographical Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB708003369/)

Article Lukas J. Meier; (2022)
The Demise of Brain Death (/isis/citation/CBB607058744/)

Article Miller, Franklin G.; (2012)
Homage to Henry Beecher (1904--1976) (/isis/citation/CBB001201290/)

Book Morra, Joanne; Robson, Mark; Marquard, Smith; (2000)
Limits of Death: Between Philosophy and Psychoanalysis (/isis/citation/CBB000102332/)

Article Rosagemma Ciliberti; Nicola Bragazzi; Anna Siri; Paolo Petralia; Alessandro Bonsignore; (2021)
The Italian legislator’s silence on physician-assisted suicide: Legal and bioethical implications (/isis/citation/CBB580737740/)

Thesis Levy, Jean Elizabeth; (2007)
Controlling the Course of Scientific Advance: The Case of Human Embryology (/isis/citation/CBB001560939/)

Article Miller, Franklin G.; (2013)
Two Philosophical Deaths: Hume and Hitchens (/isis/citation/CBB001201340/)

Book Trais Pearson; (2020)
Sovereign Necropolis: The Politics of Death in Semi-Colonial Siam (/isis/citation/CBB099369294/)

Chapter Carmel Ferragud; (2020)
Unfamiliar Faces: The Identification of Corpses in Late Medieval Valencia (/isis/citation/CBB207748185/)

Book Francesco Paolo de Ceglia; (2020)
The Body of Evidence: Corpses and Proofs in Early Modern European Medicine (/isis/citation/CBB516817724/)

Chapter Lucia De Frenza; Caterina Tisci; (2020)
Frightening Whirlpools: Drowning in France in the 18th Century (/isis/citation/CBB304540926/)

Chapter Allen Shotwell; (2020)
Dissection Techniques, Forensics and Anatomy in the 16th Century (/isis/citation/CBB490300332/)

Chapter Francesco Paolo de Ceglia; (2020)
Saving the Phenomenon: Why Corpses Bled in the Presence of Their Murderer in Early Modern Science (/isis/citation/CBB340756814/)

Chapter Francesco Paolo de Ceglia; (2020)
Corpses, Evidence and Medical Knowledge in the Late Middle Ages and the Early Modern Age (/isis/citation/CBB767610903/)

Chapter Tommaso Duranti; (2020)
Reading the Corpse in the Late Middle Ages (Bologna, Mid-13th Century–Early 16th Century) (/isis/citation/CBB629097396/)

Authors & Contributors
De Ceglia, Francesco Paolo
Miller, Franklin G.
Lucia De Frenza
Ferragud, Carmel
Kind, Luciana
Lederer, Susan Eyrich
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Early Science and Medicine: A Journal for the Study of Science, Technology and Medicine in the Pre-modern Period
História, Ciências, Saúde---Manguinhos
Medicina Historica
Cornell University Press
Manchester University Press
University of Southampton (United Kingdom)
University of Texas Medical Branch Graduate School of Biomedical Science
Medicine and law
Forensic medicine
Philosophy of medicine
Beecher, Henry Knowles
Hitchens, Christopher
Hume, David
Time Periods
20th century, late
21st century
18th century
Early modern
Great Britain
Bologna (Italy)

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment