“Giant Birds of Old”: An 1837 poem by James Dwight Dana (?) on the supposed makers of the Connecticut Valley's fossil trackways (2019)
Marché, Jordan D., II (Author)
Earth Sciences History: Journal of the History of the Earth Sciences Society
Volume: 38
Issue: 2
Pages: 276-298
An 1842 letter from Benjamin Silliman, Jr., to Edward Hitchcock contains the only known text of a poem that was reportedly composed five years earlier by an anonymous ‘tutor’ at Yale College. The poem's light-hearted verses depicted how the recently-described three-toed fossil footprints (now known to have been produced by theropod dinosaurs) were supposedly made by “giant birds of old”, as Hitchcock's recent investigation had concluded. The poem's lines offered a verbal ‘reconstruction’ of that ancient scene, along with suggesting the existence of two marsupial animals which may have borne witness to the passage of the trackmakers; one of which was plausible while the other was not. These ‘witnesses’ provide evidence that the poem's author was well informed upon contemporary geology and paleontology in a manner far beyond that of the common person. This article first reviews Hitchcock's inferences derived from the fossil evidence that the footprints had been made by multiple species of extinct birds, one of which attained enormous size, and the subsequent controversies regarding those claims that arose in America and Europe. Description by comparative anatomist Richard Owen of fossil bones of the much younger Moa or Dinornis from Recent strata in New Zealand seemingly vindicated Hitchcock's arguments and brought those disputes to a close. While the true identity of the poet remains inconclusive, internal evidence from the poem itself points to it having been composed by Yale graduate James Dwight Dana. His placement as an ‘assistant’ within the chemistry laboratory under Benjamin Silliman, Sr., at that time appears to support Silliman, Jr.'s assertion regarding the poet's identity. Probable reasons for the apparent suppression of the poem's existence and its authorship are likewise explored. The former was finally eased after Dana's return from the U.S. Exploring Expedition in 1842, but the latter was not.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Dingus, Lowell;
Norell, Mark A.;
(2010)
Barnum Brown: The Man Who Discovered Tyrannosaurus Rex
(/isis/citation/CBB001023269/)
Article
Glendening, John;
(2009)
“The World-Renowned Ichthyosaurus”: A Nineteenth-Century Problematic and Its Representations
(/isis/citation/CBB001213333/)
Book
Richard Fallon;
(2021)
Reimagining Dinosaurs in Late Victorian and Edwardian Literature: How the ‘Terrible Lizard' Became a Transatlantic Cultural Icon
(/isis/citation/CBB569188287/)
Thesis
Marlena Briane Cameron;
(2017)
Fossil Excavation, Museums, and Wyoming: American Paleontology, 1870-1915
(/isis/citation/CBB144188127/)
Thesis
Rieppel, Lukas Benjamin;
(2012)
Dinosaurs: Assembling an Icon of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001567402/)
Article
Joseph H. Hartman;
(2021)
The importance of the museum in antebellum U.S. Western Territorial exploration: Part 2. The roles of Hayden and Meek in a paradigm shift in geologic and paleontologic studies
(/isis/citation/CBB328483331/)
Article
Elizabeth D. Jones;
(2019)
Assumptions of Authority: The Story of Sue the T-Rex and Controversy Over Access to Fossils
(/isis/citation/CBB334696047/)
Book
Lukas Rieppel;
(2019)
Assembling the Dinosaur: Fossil Hunters, Tycoons, and the Making of a Spectacle
(/isis/citation/CBB932931396/)
Book
Donald R. Prothero;
(2018)
The Story of Life in 25 Fossils: Tales of Intrepid Fossil Hunters and the Wonders of Evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB293277728/)
Book
Ilja Nieuwland;
(2019)
American Dinosaur Abroad: A Cultural History of Carnegie’s Plaster Diplodocus
(/isis/citation/CBB424808631/)
Article
Lukas Rieppel;
(2015)
Prospecting for Dinosaurs on the Mining Frontier: The Value of Information in America’s Gilded Age
(/isis/citation/CBB570078874/)
Article
R. Bruce McMillan;
(2016)
C. W. Beehler's Collection of Vertebrate Fossils: A Lost Legacy
(/isis/citation/CBB008066555/)
Book
Emling, Shelley;
(2009)
The Fossil Hunter: Dinosaurs, Evolution, and the Woman Whose Discoveries Changed the World
(/isis/citation/CBB001031283/)
Book
McGowan, Christopher;
(2001)
The Dragon Seekers: How an Extraordinary Circle of Fossilists Discovered the Dinosaurs and Paved the Way for Darwin
(/isis/citation/CBB000100267/)
Book
Rudwick, Martin J. S.;
(2014)
Earth's Deep History: How It Was Discovered and Why It Matters
(/isis/citation/CBB001422030/)
Chapter
Alessandro Ottaviani;
(2022)
Monti, fossili ed “epoche” della natura in Arcadia
(/isis/citation/CBB840927043/)
Article
Archibald, J. David;
(2009)
Edward Hitchcock's Pre-Darwinian (1840) “Tree of Life”
(/isis/citation/CBB000932226/)
Book
Robert T. McMaster;
(2021)
All the Light Here Comes from Above: The Life and Legacy of Edward Hitchcock
(/isis/citation/CBB424786586/)
Article
Thomas Sharpe;
(2022)
Henri De la Beche's 1829-1830 litograph, duria antiquior
(/isis/citation/CBB971607561/)
Article
Brinkman, Paul D.;
(2005)
Henry Fairfield Osborn and Jurassic Dinosaur Reconnaissance in the San Juan Basin, Along the Colorado-Utah Border, 1893--1900
(/isis/citation/CBB000630876/)
Be the first to comment!