The ‘Stronsay Beast’: Testimony, evidence and authority in early nineteenth-century natural history (2022)
Jenkins, Bill (Author)
Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science
Volume: 77
Issue: 3
Pages: 471-494
When an unknown sea creature was washed ashore on the Orkney Islands in September 1808, the Edinburgh anatomist John Barclay declared that this was the first solid scientific evidence for the existence of the ‘great sea snake’. The testimony of witnesses along with some of its preserved body parts were examined by both the Wernerian Natural History Society in Edinburgh and the surgeon and anatomist Everard Home in London. Contradicting Barclay's opinion, Home identified the creature as a decomposing basking shark. While Barclay took the testimony of the local witnesses largely on trust and accepted their interpretation of the Beast, Home discounted it and instead asserted his own expert authority to correctly interpret the evidence. Both made use of the preserved physical remains of parts of the creature in strikingly different ways: Barclay to support the accounts of the witnesses, Home to undermine them. The debate between the two anatomists has much to tell us about the uses of evidence and testimony in early nineteenth-century natural history, but also has broader resonances for the roles of evidence and authority in science that still remain relevant today.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
A. Urry;
(2021)
Alfred Newton’s second-hand histories of extinction: Hearsay, gossip, misapprehension
(/isis/citation/CBB385478624/)
Article
Loskutova, Marina;
(2014)
Early Research on Insect Pests in the Russian Empire: Bureaucracy, Academic Community and Local Knowledge in the 1830s–1840s
(/isis/citation/CBB001202375/)
Article
Vetter, Jeremy;
(2011)
Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB001034611/)
Article
Stanislav Strekopytov;
(2018)
John Hunter's Directions for Preserving Animals
(/isis/citation/CBB180536129/)
Article
Barry Sturman;
David Garrioch;
(2023)
Amateur Science and Innovation in Fireworks in Nineteenth-Century Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB895927620/)
Article
Koji Murata;
Hisashi Hayakawa;
Mitsuru Sôma;
(2023)
A critical assessment of questionable solar eclipse memories in the Byzantine Empire from the fourth to sixth centuries CE
(/isis/citation/CBB039908405/)
Article
María José Martínez Usó;
Francisco J. Marco Castillo;
(2023)
The total eclipse of the sun of July 29, AD1478, in contemporary Spanish documents
(/isis/citation/CBB486977664/)
Article
Nenadic, Stana;
(2012)
Architect-Builders in London and Edinburgh, c. 1750--1800, and the Market for Expertise
(/isis/citation/CBB001212670/)
Article
Michel Pretalli;
(2019)
Hannibal versus Phormio: Theory and Practice in Italian Military Literature at the End of the Renaissance
(/isis/citation/CBB555691679/)
Book
Andrew J. Hogan;
(2022)
Disability Dialogues: Advocacy, Science, and Prestige in Postwar Clinical Professions
(/isis/citation/CBB207448799/)
Article
Mason, Julia M.;
(2013)
Surgical Intervention: Critiquing the Representation of Breast Cancer Surgery in US Women's Magazines
(/isis/citation/CBB001202124/)
Article
Erika Dyck;
(2021)
Doing History That Matters: Going Public and Activating Voices as a Form of Historical Activism
(/isis/citation/CBB280852277/)
Article
Alisha Rankin;
(2022)
How to 'Be Expert' in Early Modern Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB778994997/)
Thesis
David Merritt Johns;
(2019)
Good Evidence, Bad Evidence: Science, Ethics, and the Politics of Making and Unmaking Public Health Policies
(/isis/citation/CBB199543025/)
Article
Bill Jenkins;
(2016)
The Platypus in Edinburgh: Robert Jameson, Robert Knox and the Place of the Ornithorhynchus in Nature, 1821–24
(/isis/citation/CBB879747957/)
Article
Peter B. Logan;
Martin A. Sidor;
(2021)
John James Audubon's Overlooked “Great Work”: His Ornithological Biography
(/isis/citation/CBB976769881/)
Book
Allen, David Elliston;
(2001)
Naturalists and Society: The Culture of Natural History in Britain, 1700-1900
(/isis/citation/CBB000100994/)
Article
Swinney, Geoffrey N.;
(2010)
Edward Forbes (1815--1854) and the Exhibition of Natural Order in Edinburgh
(/isis/citation/CBB001031439/)
Article
Bill Jenkins;
(2020)
Race Before Darwin: Variation, Adaptation and the Natural History of Man in Post-Enlightenment Edinburgh, 1790–1835
(/isis/citation/CBB902634281/)
Article
Wendy McGlashan;
(2022)
John Kay’s The craft in danger (1817): Graphic satire and natural history in nineteenth-century Edinburgh
(/isis/citation/CBB917614120/)
Be the first to comment!