Demarcating Patriotic Science on Digital Platforms: Covid-19, Chloroquine and the Institutionalisation of Ignorance in Brazil (2022)
Fonseca, Paulo F. C. (Author)
Ribeiro, Barbara E. (Author)
Nascimento, Leonardo F. (Author)
Science as Culture
Volume: 31
Issue: 4
Pages: 530-554
As supporters of Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, the Bolsonarism movement has promoted the drug chloroquine for treating Covid-19 in Brazil, despite it being mostly rejected by mainstream health institutions as an effective treatment. This situation can be investigated through the lens of Science and Technology Studies (STS) and ignorance studies supported by methods from digital sociology. Bolsonarist discourse does not contest scientific authority tout court, but rather constructs boundaries between what supporters of the president see as legitimate and illegitimate science. This institutionalised ignorance is produced and maintained through Telegram messenger, a backbone of the multi-platform media ecosystem of Bolsonarism. It is accomplished through boundary work: the exclusion or inclusion of knowledge via two complementary practices – pejorative accusations against mainstream science and the crafting of affective bonds with the chloroquine alternative. While the former aims to invalidate knowledge held by experts opposed to the use of chloroquine, the latter focuses on mobilising trust in an alternative model of science, which we refer to as patriotic science. This model of science is demarcated from mainstream science, framed as corrupt and ill-equipped for the needs of Brazilians. This case study advances STS resources for examining the epistemic demarcation between science/non-science, relevant to other polities and publics that use such boundary work to institutionalise ignorance.
...MoreArticle Katharina T. Paul; Samantha Vanderslott; Matthias Gross (2022) Institutionalised ignorance in policy and regulation. Science as Culture (pp. 419-432).
Similar Citations
Article
Elisa Sevilla;
Ana Sevilla;
(2020)
The “Controversial Cundurango Cure”: Medical professionalization and the global circulation of drugs
Article
Haoran Chu;
Janet Z. Yang;
Sixiao Liu;
(2021)
Not My Pandemic: Solution Aversion and the Polarized Public Perception of COVID-19
Article
Y. Srinivasa Rao;
Sindhu Thomas;
(2023)
Indigenous poison healing traditions in Kerala
Book
Deborah Brunton;
(2013)
The Politics of Vaccination: Practice and Policy in England, Wales, Ireland, and Scotland, 1800-1874
Book
Jonathan M. Berman;
(2020)
Anti-vaxxers: How to Challenge a Misinformed Movement
Article
Stefano Crabu;
Ilenia Picardi;
Valentina Turrini;
(2023)
Refused-knowledge during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Mobilising Experiential Expertise for Care and Well-being
Article
Yan Huang;
Wenlin Liu;
(2022)
Promoting COVID-19 Vaccination: The Interplay of Message Framing, Psychological Uncertainty, and Public Agency as a Message Source
Article
Janet Z. Yang;
Xinxia Dong;
Zhuling Liu;
(2022)
Systematic Processing of COVID-19 Information: Relevant Channel Beliefs and Perceived Information Gathering Capacity as Moderators
Article
Philipp Schmid;
Cornelia Betsch;
(2022)
Benefits and Pitfalls of Debunking Interventions to Counter mRNA Vaccination Misinformation During the COVID-19 Pandemic
Article
Chen Zeng;
(2021)
A Relational Identity-Based Solution to Group Polarization: Can Priming Parental Identity Reduce the Partisan Gap in Attitudes Toward the COVID-19 Pandemic
Article
Michelle A. Amazeen;
Arunima Krishna;
Rob Eschmann;
(2022)
Cutting the Bunk: Comparing the Solo and Aggregate Effects of Prebunking and Debunking Covid-19 Vaccine Misinformation
Article
Nicole C. Kelp;
Jessica K. Witt;
Gayathri Sivakumar;
(2022)
To Vaccinate or Not? The Role Played by Uncertainty Communication on Public Understanding and Behavior Regarding COVID-19
Article
Marlis Stubenvoll;
(2022)
Investigating the Heterogeneity of Misperceptions: A Latent Profile Analysis of COVID-19 Beliefs and Their Consequences for Information-Seeking
Article
Sabina Mihelj;
Katherine Kondor;
Václav Štětka;
(June 2022)
Establishing Trust in Experts During a Crisis: Expert Trustworthiness and Media Use During the COVID-19 Pandemic
Article
Han Zheng;
Shaohai Jiang;
Sonny Rosenthal;
(June 2022)
Linking Online Vaccine Information Seeking to Vaccination Intention in the Context of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Article
Yanqing Sun;
(June 2022)
Verification Upon Exposure to COVID-19 Misinformation: Predictors, Outcomes, and the Mediating Role of Verification
Article
Lana, Vanessa;
(2014)
O Hospital Aristides Maltez e o controle do câncer do colo do útero no Brasil
Article
Emily Baum;
(2021)
Acupuncture Anesthesia on American Bodies: Communism, Race, and the Cold War in the Making of “Legitimate” Medical Science
Article
Porto, Marco Antonio;
Arantes Botelho Briglia Habib, Paula;
(2014)
Viva Mulher: Constructing a Cervical Cancer Control Program in Brazil
Book
Ilana Löwy;
(2024)
Viruses and Reproductive Injustice: Zika in Brazil
Be the first to comment!