IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB786602400

Astrology in the crossfire: the stormy debate after the comet of 1577 (2022)

Almási, Gábor (Author)

Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology
Volume: 79
Issue: 2
Pages: 137-163

DOI: 10.1080/00033790.2022.2030409

URI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00033790.2022.2030409

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Controversies and disputes Comets; meteors; meteorites Science and society Science and religion Republic of Letters Astronomy Astrology 17th century 16th century

The new star of 1572 and the comet of 1577 had a major impact on the ways in which astronomical research developed in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. Behind this gradual but significant change there was an extended epistemological reform which placed increasing emphasis on reason and experience and strove to exclude arguments from Scripture and authority from scientific debate. This paper argues that the humanist debate on astrology after 1577, which was initiated by highly prestigious members of a supraconfessional Republic of Letters, can be seen as an element of this process. Unlike earlier detractors of astrology, these new critics chiefly employed philosophical and scientific arguments concerning the legitimation of the entire art. By analysing a variety of accounts, this paper will reveal how great and complex the stakes in the debate over astrology were. They concerned not only the crucial problem of predestination and God’s interventionalism (hence also the possibility of miracles), but also the idea of science, the concept of the human mind, and ultimately the humanist ideal of the virtuous, rational, and responsible citizen.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB786602400/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Doris Gruber; (2020)
Frühneuzeitlicher Wissenswandel. Kometenerscheinungen in der Druckpublizistik des Heiligen Römischen Reiches (/isis/citation/CBB272470489/)

Book Anna Jerratsch; (2019)
Der Fruhneuzeitliche Kometendiskurs Im Spiegel Deutschsprachiger Flugschriften (/isis/citation/CBB833184165/)

Article Robert Alan Hatch; (2017)
Between Astrology and Copernicanism: Morin – Gassendi – Boulliau (/isis/citation/CBB971117250/)

Book Davide Arecco; (2019)
Comete, stelle e pianeti. Storia dell'astronomia nell'età di Newton (/isis/citation/CBB893770840/)

Thesis Laura E. Bland; (2016)
Unfriendly Skies: Science, Superstition, and the Great Comet of 1680 (/isis/citation/CBB968402275/)

Article Luca Nardi; (2023)
A Review of Two Italian 'Killer Meteorites’: Crema 1511 and Milan 1633–1664 (/isis/citation/CBB085680564/)

Book Thierry Belleguic; (2013)
Ordre et désordre du monde: enquête sur les météores, de la Renaissance à l'âge moderne (/isis/citation/CBB238470883/)

Article Maza, Clelia Martinez; (2007)
La defensa Católica y el uso de la astrología grecorromana como pauta de corrupción religiosa (/isis/citation/CBB000831594/)

Article Laurence Wuidar; (2009)
L'interdetto della conoscenza: segreti celesti e arcani musicali nel Cinquecento e Seicento (/isis/citation/CBB386803290/)

Book Sharpe, James; (2001)
Witchcraft in Early Modern England (/isis/citation/CBB000102145/)

Article Francisco Malta Romeiras; (2020)
Putting the Indices into Practice: Censoring Science in Early Modern Portugal (/isis/citation/CBB223674544/)

Article Ting Chen; Lingfeng Lü; (2022)
Astronomical or political: Interpretation of comets in times of crisis in Qing China (/isis/citation/CBB395595446/)

Article Carter, Christopher; (2012)
Meteors, Prodigies, and Signs: The Interpretation of the Unusual in Sixteenth-Century England (/isis/citation/CBB001200755/)

Essay Review Andrea Gualandi; (2014)
Nuove stelle, scienza e società alla vigilia della Guerra dei Trent'anni (/isis/citation/CBB223026392/)

Chapter Vittoria Feola; (2020)
Early Modern Universities and the Sciences in Context (/isis/citation/CBB492437795/)

Chapter Elena Taddei; (2020)
Princely erudition, universities and the Republic of Letters as instruments of networking: the Este, Dukes of Ferrara, Modena and Reggio, and the Holy Roman Empire (/isis/citation/CBB854513267/)

Book Vittoria Feola; (2020)
Early Modern Universities and the Sciences (/isis/citation/CBB858391595/)

Article Sylvie Taussig; (2011)
Gassendi et Campanella: dialogue de l'héliotrope et du soleil (/isis/citation/CBB502126354/)

Article Hayton, Darin; (2010)
Expertise ex Stellis: Comets, Horoscopes, and Politics in Renaissance Hungary (/isis/citation/CBB001031417/)

Book Ilaria Ampollini; (2019)
Cronaca di una cometa non annunciata. Astronomia e comunicazione della scienza nel XVIII secolo (/isis/citation/CBB495575690/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}