Paris 1676: The Discovery of the Velocity of Light and the Roles of Rømer and Cassini (2019)
It is often claimed that the 1676 discoveries at the Paris Observatory of a new irregularity in the orbit of Jupiter’s first satellite and of the velocity of light were not due to Rømer alone but that Cassini played a major role or even that Rømer took over these ideas from Cassini. These claims indirectly accuse Rømer and Cassini of dishonesty. We investigate the foundations of these allegations through an analysis of apparent contradictions in the primary, historical sources. The minutes from a meeting of the Academy on 22 August 1676 are especially important. Our analysis shows no reason to believe that Cassini took part in the discoveries, but his criticism incited Rømer to argue his case better. We conclude that the discoveries were due to Rømer alone and that the accusations against the two scientists of dishonesty are ill founded.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Bobis, Laurence;
Lequeux, James;
(2008)
Cassini, Rømer, and the Velocity of Light
(/isis/citation/CBB001034770/)
Article
Kristensen, Leif Kahl;
Pedersen, Kurt Møller;
(2012)
Roemer, Jupiter's Satellites and the Velocity of Light
(/isis/citation/CBB001230532/)
Article
Willmoth, Frances;
(2012)
Römer, Flamsteed, Cassini and the Speed of Light
(/isis/citation/CBB001230533/)
Article
Pascal Descamps;
(2015)
La découverte de Neptune: Entre triomphe et camouflet
(/isis/citation/CBB939335246/)
Article
Dijksterhuis, Fokko Jan;
(2012)
Conjunctions in Paris: Interactions between Rømer and Huygens
(/isis/citation/CBB001230534/)
Article
Christophe Schmit;
(2019)
Introduction. Entre astronomie et physique : l’activité scientifique de Philippe de La Hire à l’Observatoire de Paris
(/isis/citation/CBB345796930/)
Book
Bobis, Laurence;
Lequeux, James;
(2012)
L'Observatoire de Paris: 350 ans de science
(/isis/citation/CBB001214540/)
Article
Leonardo, Antonio Jose F.;
Martins, Decio R.;
Fiolhais, Carlos;
(2011)
Costa Lobo and the Study of the Sun in Coimbra in the First Half of the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001221508/)
Article
Aubin, David;
(2003)
The Fading Star of the Paris Observatory in the Nineteenth Century: Astronomers' Urban Culture of Circulation and Observation
(/isis/citation/CBB000470365/)
Article
Descamps, Pascal;
(2014)
La ligne méridienne de l'Observatoire de Paris : Une analyse des registres des observations de Cassini II de 1730 à 1755
(/isis/citation/CBB001551981/)
Book
Mark, Harry H.;
(2010)
c, the Speed of Light: A Tale of Scientific Blunder
(/isis/citation/CBB001023202/)
Article
Bailhache, Patrice;
(2002)
Un effet Doppler-Fizeau méconnu: Roemer et la vitesse de la lumière
(/isis/citation/CBB000770939/)
Article
Tybjerg, Karin;
(2012)
“Senses and Hands to the Same Degree as Thought”---Ole Rømer's Mechanical Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001230535/)
Article
Tybjerg, Karin;
(2012)
Cosmos and Cogwheels---The Work of Ole Rømer (1644--1710)
(/isis/citation/CBB001230531/)
Article
Thomas Widemann;
Eberhard Knobloch;
(2022)
Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB954102872/)
Article
Jean-Marie Malherbe;
(2023)
130 years of spectroheliograms at Paris-Meudon observatories (1893–2023)
(/isis/citation/CBB478845963/)
Article
Véron, Philippe;
(2003)
L'équatorial de la tour de l'est de l'Observatoire de Paris
(/isis/citation/CBB000340755/)
Article
Iannaccone, Isaia;
(2000)
Documents relatifs à l'histoire de l'astronomie chinoise et aux rapports scientifiques entre l'Europe et la Chine (XVIIe-XIXe siècles) conservés à la Bibliothèque de l'Observatoire de Paris. Première partie
(/isis/citation/CBB000111518/)
Chapter
Taton, René;
(1978)
L'Observatoire de Paris à l'époque de Roemer
(/isis/citation/CBB000026672/)
Article
Grillot, Solange;
(1987)
L'emploi des objectifs italiens à l'Observatoire de Paris à la fin du 17ème siècle
(/isis/citation/CBB000038898/)
Be the first to comment!