Article ID: CBB768765059

The First Garden City? Environment and utopianism in an Edwardian institution for the insane poor (2017)

unapi

At Kingseat Asylum near Aberdeen, in 1901–1904, asylum authorities constructed an asylum which appears to resemble Ebenezer Howard's schematic diagram of a garden city ‘ward’. Using theories of the relationship between spatial rationalities and governmentality, this paper asks whether Howard's garden city could plausibly have been a model for the Kingseat Asylum layout. The historiographical orthodoxy, which claims that late nineteenth-century asylums were little more than ‘warehouses’ to sequester the unwanted, is problematized and the existence is postulated of a distinct Scottish asylum culture which was alarmed by the tendency to asylum growth, overcrowding and disease in England and elsewhere. Garden city reformers and asylum builders faced similar problems in terms of overcrowding and disease, and were both concerned about the ‘aggregation’ of the poor and their consequent loss of individuality. By the beginning of the twentieth century, Scottish asylum builders, in particular, rejected the increasingly large monolithic style of asylum in favour of dispersed ‘village’ style settlements. Aberdeen asylum authorities may have sought to access the symbolic resonance of the garden city layout and its utopian qualities as a ‘marriage’ of town and country, health and industry, variety and uniformity. The garden city asylum also points to a spectrum of opinion relating to the therapeutic role of environment in relation to mental illness and suggests that ‘hard hereditarian’ approaches were less influential, at least in Scotland, than is sometimes claimed.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB768765059/

Similar Citations

Article Gillian Allmond; (2017)
Liberty and the individual: the colony asylum in Scotland and England (/isis/citation/CBB034575395/)

Article Jennifer Farquharson; (2018)
Health and hierarchy: soldiers, civilians and mental healthcare in Scotland, 1914–34 (/isis/citation/CBB324761166/)

Article Hutchison, Iain; (2011)
Institutionalization of Mentally-Impaired Children in Scotland, c.1855--1914 (/isis/citation/CBB001232201/)

Article Jonathan Andrews; Chris Philo; (2017)
James Frame’s The Philosophy of Insanity (1860) (/isis/citation/CBB313587958/)

Article Chris Philo; Jonathan Andrews; (2017)
Introduction: histories of asylums, insanity and psychiatry in Scotland (/isis/citation/CBB636331729/)

Article Morag Allan Campbell; (2017)
‘Noisy, restless and incoherent’: puerperal insanity at Dundee Lunatic Asylum (/isis/citation/CBB791023960/)

Article Finnegan, Diarmid A.; (2008)
“An Aid to Mental Health”: Natural History, Alienists and Therapeutics inVictorian Scotland (/isis/citation/CBB000831714/)

Article Barfoot, Michael; (2009)
The 1815 Act to Regulate Madhouses in Scotland: A Reinterpretation (/isis/citation/CBB000931183/)

Article Sharlene D Walbaum; (2019)
The invisible woman: Susan Carnegie and Montrose Lunatic Asylum (/isis/citation/CBB650430833/)

Article Cheryl McGeachan; (2017)
‘The Head Carver’: Art Extraordinary and the Small Spaces of Asylum (/isis/citation/CBB911123773/)

Article Katherine Sorrels; (2023)
The Origins of Camphill and the Legacy of the Asylum in Disability History (/isis/citation/CBB505919957/)

Book Steven Taylor; (2016)
Child Insanity in England, 1845-1907 (/isis/citation/CBB540030183/)

Book Claire E. Edington; (2019)
Beyond the Asylum: Mental Illness in French Colonial Vietnam (/isis/citation/CBB895433219/)

Authors & Contributors
Philo, Chris
Andrews, Jonathan
Allmond, Gillian
Farquharson, Jennifer
Katherine Sorrels
Campbell, Morag Allan
Concepts
Psychiatric hospitals
Mental disorders and diseases
Psychiatry
Therapeutic practice; therapy; treatment
Medicine and society
Public health
Time Periods
20th century, early
19th century
18th century
Places
Scotland
England
Germany
Glasgow (Scotland)
Norway
Italy
Institutions
Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh
Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh
National Health Service (Great Britain)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment