IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB755611640

THE MERCURY MODELS OF IBN AL-ŠĀṬIR AND COPERNICUS (2019)

Nikfahm Khubravan, Sajjad (Author)
Ragep, F. Jamil (Author)

Arabic Sciences and Philosophy
Volume: 29
Issue: 1
Pages: 1-59

URI: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/arabic-sciences-and-philosophy/article/mercury-models-of-ibn-alsatir-and-copernicus/4795AA8292986D0EA0139DB326A43879

DOI: 10.1017/S0957423918000085

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Heliocentrism Geocentrism Cosmology Astronomy Celestial mechanics Mercury (planet) 15th century 14th century Ibn al-Shāṭir, ʿAlā al-Dīn ʿAlī Ibn Ibrāhīm Copernicus, Nicolaus

Copernicus' complex Mercury model in De revolutionibus is virtually identical, geometrically, to Ibn al-Šāṭir's (ca. 1305 – ca. 1375). However, the model in his earlier Commentariolus is different and in many ways unworkable. This has led some to claim that the younger Copernicus did not understand his predecessor's model; others have maintained that Copernicus was working totally independently of Ibn al-Šāṭir. We argue that Copernicus did have Ibn al-Šāṭir's models but needed to modify them to conform to a “quasi-homocentricity” in the Commentariolus. This modification, and the move from a geocentric to heliocentric cosmology, was facilitated by the “heliocentric bias” of Ibn al-Šāṭir's models, in which the Earth was the actual center of mean motion, in contrast to Ptolemy and most Islamicate astronomers. We show that: 1) Ibn al-Šāṭir sought to reproduce Ptolemy's critical elongation at the trines(±120°), but changed the Ptolemaic values at 0, ±90, and 180°; 2) in the Commentariolus, Copernicus does not try to produce viable elongations for Mercury; and 3) by the time of writing De revolutionibus, Copernicus is in full control of the Mercury model and is able to faithfully reproduce Ptolemy's elongations at all critical points. We also argue that claims regarding “natural” solutions undermining transmission are belied by historical evidence., Le modèle complexe de Mercure dans le De revolutionibus de Copernic est virtuellement identique, géométriquement, à celui d'Ibn al-Šāṭir (ca. 1305 – ca. 1375). Cependant, le modèle, antérieur, du Commentariolus est différent et il fonctionne mal. Certains en ont déduit que le jeune Copernic n'avait pas compris le modèle de son pré- décesseur; d'autres ont affirmé que l'œuvre de Copernic était totallement indépendante d'Ibn al-Šāṭir. Nous soutenons que Copernic avait les modèles d'Ibn al-Šāṭir mais qu'il a dû les modifier pour les rendre “quasi-homocentriques” dans le Commentariolus. Cette modification et le passage d'une cosmologie géocentrique à une cosmologie héliocentrique étaient rendus aisés par le “biais héliocentrique” des modèles d'Ibn al-Šāṭir, pour qui la Terre était le centre effectif du mouvement moyen, contrairement à Ptolémée et à la plupart des astronomes islamiques. Nous montrons que : 1) Ibn al-Šāṭir a cherché à reproduire les élongations critiques à ±120° de l'apogée, mais il a changé les valeurs ptoléméennes à 0, ±90 et 180° ; 2) dans le Commentariolus, Copernic n'essaie pas de reproduire des élongations viables pour Mercure;et 3) au moment de la rédaction du De revolutionibus, Copernic contrôle pleinement le modèle de Mercure et il est capable de reproduire les élongations de Ptolémée aux points critiques. Nous soutenons aussi que les arguments concernant des solutions “naturelles” qui excluent la transmission sont niés par l’évidence historique.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB755611640/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Graney, Christopher M.; (2010)
The Telescope against Copernicus: Star Observations by Riccioli Supporting a Geocentric Universe (/isis/citation/CBB001023553/)

Book Finocchiaro, Maurice A; (2010)
Defending Copernicus and Galileo: Critical Reasoning in the Two Affairs (/isis/citation/CBB001023120/)

Book de Pace, Anna; (2009)
Niccolò Copernico e la fondazione del cosmo eliocentrico: con testo, traduzione e commentario del Libro I de Le revoluzioni celesti (/isis/citation/CBB001023278/)

Article Goddu, André; (2009)
Copernicus's Mereological Vision of the Universe (/isis/citation/CBB000932582/)

Article Ragep, F. Jamil; (2006)
Ali Qushji and Regiomontanus: Eccentric Transformations and Copernican Revolutions (/isis/citation/CBB000931423/)

Article Liritzis, Lonnis; Coucoucli, Alexandra; (2008)
Ancient Greek Heliocentric Views Hidden from Prevailing Beliefs? (/isis/citation/CBB001034764/)

Book Benson, Donald C.; (2012)
The Ballet of the Planets: On the Mathematical Elegance of Planetary Motion (/isis/citation/CBB001251288/)

Article Hutchison, Keith; (2012)
An Angel's View of Heaven: The Mystical Heliocentricity of Medieval Geocentric Cosmology (/isis/citation/CBB001230393/)

Article Shank, Michael H.; (2009)
Setting Up Copernicus? Astronomy and Natural Philosophy in Giambattista Capuano da Manfredonia's Expositio on the Sphere (/isis/citation/CBB000932581/)

Book Luís Miguel Carolino; (2023)
Geo-heliocentric controversies : the Jesuits, Tycho Brahe and the confessionalisation of science in seventeenth-century Lisbon (/isis/citation/CBB049554963/)

Book Todd Keene Timberlake; Paul Wallace; (2019)
Finding Our Place in the Solar System: The Scientific Story of the Copernican Revolution (/isis/citation/CBB931474490/)

Book Christopher M. Graney; (2017)
Mathematical Disquisitions: The Booklet of Theses Immortalized by Galileo (/isis/citation/CBB733373633/)

Article Spranzi-Zuber, Marta; (2005)
Galileo's “Dialogue on the Two Chief World Systems”: Rhetoric and Dialogue (/isis/citation/CBB000670802/)

Book Goddu, André; (2010)
Copernicus and the Aristotelian Tradition: Education, Reading, and Philosophy in Copernicus's Path to Heliocentrism (/isis/citation/CBB001020711/)

Article F. Jamil Ragep; (2016)
Ibn al-Shāṭir and Copernicus: The Uppsala Notes Revisited (/isis/citation/CBB593896461/)

Article Graney, Christopher M.; (2010)
Seeds of a Tychonic Revolution: Telescopic Observations of the Stars by Galileo Galilei and Simon Marius (/isis/citation/CBB000932746/)

Article Peter D. Usher; Enrico Massaro; (2023)
The Sixteenth-Century Empirical Disproof of Ptolemaic Geocentrism (/isis/citation/CBB042095095/)

Book Dobrzycki, Jerzy; Wlodarczyk, Jacek; Kremer, Richard Lynn; (2010)
Selected Papers on Medieval and Renaissance Astronomy (/isis/citation/CBB001023145/)

Article McMullin, Ernan; (2011)
Kepler: Moving the Earth (/isis/citation/CBB001023576/)

Article Christián C. Carman; (2018)
The First Copernican Was Copernicus: The Difference Between Pre-Copernican and Copernican Heliocentrism (/isis/citation/CBB076879380/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}