The idea that the brain is a representational organ has roots in the nineteenth century, when neurologists began drawing conclusions about what the brain represents from clinical and experimental studies. One of the earliest controversies surrounding representation in the brain was the “muscles versus movements” debate, which concerned whether the motor cortex represents complex movements or rather fractional components of movement. Prominent thinkers weighed in on each side: neurologists John Hughlings Jackson and F.M.R. Walshe in favor of complex movements, neurophysiologist Charles Sherrington and neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield in favor of movement components. This essay examines these and other brain scientists’ evolving notions of representation during the first eighty years of the muscles versus movements debate (c. 1873–1954). Although participants agreed about many of the superficial features of representation, their inferences reveal deep-seated disagreements about its inferential role. Divergent epistemological commitments stoked conflicting conceptions of what representational attributions imply and what evidence supports them.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Thesis
Bassiri, Nima Rad;
(2010)
Dislocations of the Brain: Subjectivity and Cerebral Topology from Descartes to Nineteenth-Century Neuroscience
(/isis/citation/CBB001567167/)
Article
Snyder, Peter J.;
Whitaker, Harry A.;
(2013)
Neurologic Heuristics and Artistic Whimsy: The Cerebral Cartography of Wilder Penfield
(/isis/citation/CBB001320367/)
Article
Richard Leblanc;
(2019)
The White Paper: Wilder Penfield, the Stream of Consciousness, and the Physiology of Mind
(/isis/citation/CBB650149989/)
Book
Antonio Cerasa;
Francesco Tomaiuolo;
(2019)
La scatola magica. All'origine delle neuroscienze
(/isis/citation/CBB627939325/)
Article
Vilensky, Joel A.;
Stone, James L.;
Gilman, Sid;
(2003)
Feud and Fable: The Sherrington-Horsley Polemic and the Delayed Publication
(/isis/citation/CBB000410874/)
Article
Borck, Cornelius;
(2008)
Recording the Brain at Work: The Visible, the Readable, and the Invisible in Electroencephalography
(/isis/citation/CBB000831406/)
Article
Smith, C. U. M.;
(2012)
Philosophy's Loss, Neurology's Gain: The Endeavor of John Hughlings-Jackson
(/isis/citation/CBB001201292/)
Article
Josef Hlade;
(2021)
Reconsidering “Brain mythology”
(/isis/citation/CBB117316646/)
Article
Wiesendanger, Mario;
(2011)
Postlesion Recovery of Motor and Sensory Cortex in the Early Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001034919/)
Article
Smith, Roger;
(2001)
Representations of Mind: C. S. Sherrington and Scientific Opinion, c. 1930--1950
(/isis/citation/CBB000200410/)
Article
Dow Schüll, Natusha;
Zaloom, Caitlin;
(August 2011)
The shortsighted brain: Neuroeconomics and the governance of choice in time
(/isis/citation/CBB240640662/)
Article
Dotzler, Bernhard J.;
(2009)
“...die richtige Art wissenschaftlicher Objekte...”: Ein Epilog mit Warren McCullochs Embodiments of Mind
(/isis/citation/CBB000932094/)
Book
Johannes Bruder;
(2020)
Cognitive Code: Post-Anthropocentric Intelligence and the Infrastructural Brain
(/isis/citation/CBB763244812/)
Article
Alessio Plebe;
(2018)
The Search of “Canonical” Explanations for the Cerebral Cortex
(/isis/citation/CBB473323388/)
Article
Jeoffrey Gaspard;
(2021)
“A familiar logical triplet”: on Peirce’s grammar of representation and its relation to scientific inquiry
(/isis/citation/CBB856081407/)
Book
Larry W. Swanson;
Eric Newman;
Alfonso Araque;
Janet M. Dubinsky;
(2017)
Beautiful Brain: The Drawings of Santiago Ramon y Cajal
(/isis/citation/CBB332153801/)
Article
Pendleton, Courtney;
Zaidi, Hasan A.;
Chaichana, Kaisorn L.;
Raza, Shaan M.;
Carson, Benjamin S.;
Cohen-Gadol, Aaron A.;
Quinones-Hinojosa, Alfredo;
(2012)
Harvey Cushing's Contributions to Motor Mapping: 1902--1912
(/isis/citation/CBB001211985/)
Article
Kwint, Marius;
Wingate, Richard;
(2013)
Curating the Brain
(/isis/citation/CBB001201232/)
Book
Kreft, Gerald;
(2005)
Deutsch-jüdische Geschichte und Hirnforschung: Ludwig Edingers Neurologisches Institut in Frankfurt am Main
(/isis/citation/CBB001033123/)
Book
Peiffer, Jürgen;
(2004)
Hirnforschung in Deutschland 1849 bis 1974: Briefe zur Entwicklung von Psychiatrie und Neurowissenschaften sowie zum Einfluss des politischen Umfeldes auf Wissenschafter
(/isis/citation/CBB001033126/)
Be the first to comment!