In this paper, I draw on philosophy of science to address a challenge for science communication. Empirical research indicates that some people who trust a meteorologist's report that they are in the path of a storm do not trust a climate scientist's report that we are on a path to global warming. Such selective skepticism about climate science exemplifies a more general challenge: The Challenge of Selective Uptake Laypersons who generally accept public scientific testimony nevertheless fail to accept public scientific testimony concerning select, equally well warranted, scientific hypotheses. A prominent response arising from the novel interdisciplinary science of science communication is a principle called Consensus Reporting. According to this principle, science reporters should, whenever feasible, report the scientific consensus or lack thereof for a reported scientific view. However, philosophy of science may offer a different perspective on the issue. This perspective is critical insofar as it indicates some inadequacies of Consensus Reporting. But it is also constructive insofar as it guides the development of an alternative principle, Justification Reporting, according to which science reporters should, whenever feasible, report aspects of the nature and strength of scientific justification or lack thereof for a reported scientific view. A central difference between these proposals is that Consensus Reporting appeals to the authority of the scientists whereas Justification Reporting appeals to the authority of scientific justification. As such, Justification Reporting reflects the image of science. The paper considers the philosophical and empirical motivation for Justification Reporting and its limitations. This includes prospects and problems for implementing it in a way that addresses The Challenge of Selective Uptake. From a methodological point of view, the paper illustrates how empirically informed philosophy of science may help address challenges for science communication.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Mike Zapp;
(2022)
The legitimacy of science and the populist backlash: Cross-national and longitudinal trends and determinants of attitudes toward science
(/isis/citation/CBB306282966/)
Thesis
Sonnett, John H.;
(2006)
Representing the Earth: Global Climate Issues in Popular, Political, Scientific, Business, Industry, and Environmentalist News: A New Old Sociology of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001560796/)
Book
Lee McIntyre;
(2021)
How to Talk to a Science Denier: Conversations with Flat Earthers, Climate Deniers, and Others Who Defy Reason
(/isis/citation/CBB702116961/)
Chapter
Nielsen, Kristian H.;
(2012)
Expedition “Live”: Science, Media, and Politics on the Galathea 3 Expedition, 2006--2007
(/isis/citation/CBB001210272/)
Article
Djerf-Pierre, Monika;
(2013)
Green Metacycles of Attention: Reassessing the Attention Cycles of Environmental News Reporting 1961--2010
(/isis/citation/CBB001320413/)
Article
Moser, Susanne C.;
(2010)
Communicating Climate Change: History, Challenges, Process and Future Directions
(/isis/citation/CBB001221298/)
Article
Hulme, Mike;
(2010)
Claiming and Adjudicating on Mt. Kilimanjaro's Shrinking Glaciers: Guy Callendar, Al Gore and Extended Peer Communities
(/isis/citation/CBB001034650/)
Book
Inmaculada de Melo-Martín;
Kristen Intemann;
(2018)
The Fight Against Doubt: How to Bridge the Gap Between Scientists and the Public
(/isis/citation/CBB549674958/)
Thesis
Kahle, Shannon A.;
(2010)
Visualizing the Chaotic Body in Popular Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB001567170/)
Book
Carin Berkowitz;
Bernard Lightman;
(2017)
Science Museums in Transition: Cultures of Display in Nineteenth-Century Britain and America
(/isis/citation/CBB922082803/)
Article
Kelly Krause;
(2016)
A Framework for Visual Communication at Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB025509663/)
Book
Miira B. Hill;
(2022)
The New Art of Old Public Science Communication: The Science Slam
(/isis/citation/CBB847395771/)
Article
Sara Moreno-Tarín;
Tatiana Pina;
Martí Domínguez;
(2021)
Worlds apart, drawn together: Bears, penguins and biodiversity in climate change cartoons
(/isis/citation/CBB022827263/)
Article
Siemsen, Hayo;
(2010)
The Mach-Planck Debate Revisited: Democratization of Science or Elite Knowledge?
(/isis/citation/CBB001034670/)
Article
Jan Domaradzki;
(2023)
From evil demiurge to caring hero: images of geneticists in the movies
(/isis/citation/CBB948371310/)
Book
Phillip Thurtle;
(2018)
Biology in the Grid: Graphic Design and the Envisioning of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB037497817/)
Article
Jana Bruggmann;
(2017)
Der Weltraum im Zeitalter seiner technischen Reproduzierbarkeit. Das wissenschaftliche Theater der Berliner Urania, 1889–1905
(/isis/citation/CBB447176672/)
Thesis
Kessler, Elizabeth A.;
(2006)
Spacescapes: Romantic Aesthetics and the Hubble Space Telescope Images
(/isis/citation/CBB001561649/)
Book
Andrew Jewett;
(2020)
Science under Fire: Challenges to Scientific Authority in Modern America
(/isis/citation/CBB653749085/)
Article
Esther M. van Dijk;
(2013)
Relevant Features of Science: Values in Conservation Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB368775251/)
Be the first to comment!