Poincaré on the Foundations of Arithmetic and Geometry. Part 1: Against “Dependence-Hierarchy” Interpretations (2016)
The main goal of part 1 is to challenge the widely held view that Poincaré orders the sciences in a hierarchy of dependence, such that all others presuppose arithmetic. Commentators have suggested that the intuition that grounds the use of induction in arithmetic also underlies the conception of a continuum, that the consistency of geometrical axioms must be proved through arithmetical induction, and that arithmetical induction licenses the supposition that certain operations form a group. I criticize each of these readings. More fully, I argue that the justification Poincaré offers for the use of the group notion in geometry appears to extend to set-theoretic notions that would suffice to put arithmetic on a logical foundation, thus undermining his own case for the necessity of intuition in arithmetic. In part 2, I offer an interpretation of intuition’s role on which it justifies the use of group-theoretic, but not set-theoretic, notions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Yemima Ben-Menahem;
(2016)
Poincaré’s Impact on Twentieth-Century Philosophy of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB415413095/)
Chapter
João Príncipe;
(2014)
Henri Poincaré: The Status of Mechanical Explanations and the Foundations of Statistical Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB035763250/)
Chapter
Robert DiSalle;
(2014)
Poincaré on the Construction of Space-Time
(/isis/citation/CBB279934786/)
Chapter
Gerhard Heinzmann;
(2016)
Kant et l'intuition épistémique
(/isis/citation/CBB981942154/)
Book
Poincaré, Henri;
Gould, Stephen Jay;
(2001)
Value of Science: Essential Writings of Henri Poincaré
(/isis/citation/CBB000102174/)
Chapter
Gerhard Heinzmann;
(2014)
Does the French Connection (Poincaré, Lautman) Provide Some Insights Facing the Thesis That Meta-mathematics Is an Exception to the Slogan That Mathematics Concerns Structures?
(/isis/citation/CBB713441109/)
Chapter
Isabel Serra;
(2014)
Henri Poincaré: A Scientist Inspired by His Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB874804009/)
Chapter
Augusto J. Franco Oliveira;
(2014)
Poincaré and the Principles of the Calculus
(/isis/citation/CBB092613565/)
Book
María de Paz;
Robert DiSalle;
(2014)
Poincaré, Philosopher of Science: Problems and Perspectives
(/isis/citation/CBB926312391/)
Chapter
Janet Folina;
(2014)
Poincaré and the Invention of Convention
(/isis/citation/CBB627819901/)
Chapter
Laurent Rollet;
(2014)
Portrait of Henri Poincaré as a Young Philosopher: The Formative Years (1860–1873)
(/isis/citation/CBB614686489/)
Chapter
Antonio A. P. Videira;
(2014)
Poincaré, Indifferent Hypotheses and Metaphysics
(/isis/citation/CBB846876938/)
Chapter
María Paz;
(2014)
The Third Way Epistemology: A Re-characterization of Poincaré’s Conventionalism
(/isis/citation/CBB858791402/)
Chapter
Reinhard Kahle;
(2014)
Poincaré in Göttingen
(/isis/citation/CBB935280110/)
Book
Bour, Pierre Edouard;
Rebuschi, Manuel;
Rollet, Laurent;
(2010)
Construction: Festschrift for Gerhard Heinzmann
(/isis/citation/CBB001032083/)
Article
Lizhen Ji;
Chang Wang;
(2020)
Poincaré’s stated motivations for topology
(/isis/citation/CBB272091949/)
Chapter
Folina, Janet;
(2006)
Poincaré's Circularity Arguments for Mathematical Intuition
(/isis/citation/CBB000741574/)
Chapter
Jeremy Gray;
(2015)
Henri Poincaré and Hermann Weyl on the Foundations of Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB501271170/)
Chapter
Bouriau, Christophe;
(2009)
Vaihinger and Poincaré: An Original Pragmatism?
(/isis/citation/CBB001032109/)
Book
Poincaré, Henri;
(2002)
Scientific Opportunism (L'opportunisme scientifique): An Anthology
(/isis/citation/CBB000201917/)
Be the first to comment!