The death of the cortical column? Patchwork structure and conceptual retirement in neuroscientific practice (2021)
In 1981, David Hubel and Torsten Wiesel received the Nobel Prize for their research on cortical columns—vertical bands of neurons with similar functional properties. This success led to the view that “cortical column” refers to the basic building block of the mammalian neocortex. Since the 1990s, however, critics questioned this building block picture of “cortical column” and debated whether this concept is useless and should be replaced with successor concepts. This paper inquires which experimental results after 1981 challenged the building block picture and whether these challenges warrant the elimination “cortical column” from neuroscientific discourse. I argue that the proliferation of experimental techniques led to a patchwork of locally adapted uses of the column concept. Each use refers to a different kind of cortical structure, rather than a neocortical building block. Once we acknowledge this diverse-kinds picture of “cortical column”, the elimination of column concept becomes unnecessary. Rather, I suggest that “cortical column” has reached conceptual retirement: although it cannot be used to identify a neocortical building block, column research is still useful as a guide and cautionary tale for ongoing research. At the same time, neuroscientists should search for alternative concepts when studying the functional architecture of the neocortex.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Hubel, David H.;
Wiesel, Torsten N.;
(2005)
Brain and Visual Perception: The Story of a 25-Year Collaboration
(/isis/citation/CBB000641544/)
Article
Eling, Paul;
(2013)
Neuroanniversary 2013
(/isis/citation/CBB001320616/)
Article
Chvátal, Alexandr;
(2014)
Jiří Procháska (1749--1820): Part 1: A Significant Czech Anatomist, Physiologist and Neuroscientist of the Eighteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001551834/)
Book
Elwick, James;
(2007)
Styles of Reasoning in the British Life Sciences: Shared Assumptions, 1820--1858
(/isis/citation/CBB000773747/)
Book
Robinson, Joseph D.;
(2001)
Mechanisms of Synaptic Transmission: Bridging the Gap (1890-1990)
(/isis/citation/CBB000102087/)
Article
Walther, Christian;
(2002)
Hippocampal Terminology: Concepts, Misconceptions, Origins
(/isis/citation/CBB000300183/)
Article
Chátal, Alexandr;
(2014)
Jiří Procháska (1749--1820): Part 2: “De structura nervorum”---Studies on a Structure of the Nervous System
(/isis/citation/CBB001551842/)
Article
De Leo, A.;
(2008)
Enrico Sereni: Research on the Nervous System of Cephalopods
(/isis/citation/CBB000831387/)
Book
Karl S. Matlin;
(2022)
Crossing the Boundaries of Life: Günter Blobel and the Origins of Molecular Cell Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB562282037/)
Book
Mathias Grote;
(2019)
Membranes to Molecular Machines: Active Matter and the Remaking of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB578630199/)
Article
Chao Gu;
(2023)
The co-production of normal science: A social history of high-temperature superconductivity research in China (1987–2008)
(/isis/citation/CBB866398727/)
Thesis
Soliman, William Atef;
(2006)
An Examination of Past and Present Influences on University Chemistry Education
(/isis/citation/CBB001561000/)
Article
Yan, Yiwei;
Luo, Guihuan;
(2011)
The International Impact of the Chinese Journal of Physiology as Seen from Citation Counts Found in the Science Citation Index
(/isis/citation/CBB001210055/)
Chapter
Oki, Sayaka;
(2019)
‘Innovation’ as an Adaptation of ‘Progress’: Revisiting the Epistemological and Historical Contexts of These Terms
(/isis/citation/CBB666813698/)
Article
Ulrich E. Stegmann;
(2016)
‘Genetic Coding’ Reconsidered: An Analysis of Actual Usage
(/isis/citation/CBB331291543/)
Article
Williams, R. B.;
(2014)
The Birth, Death and Resurrection of the “Geneticologists”
(/isis/citation/CBB001202226/)
Article
Knoblauch, Hubert;
(2012)
The Decline of Clinical Dissections and the “Culture of Death” 1
(/isis/citation/CBB001252153/)
Book
Charlotte Nassim;
(2018)
Lessons from the Lobster: Eve Marder's Work in Neuroscience
(/isis/citation/CBB505419382/)
Article
Huber, Lara;
(2011)
LONI & Co: Die epistemische Spezifität digitaler Wissensräume in der kognitiven Neurowissenschaft
(/isis/citation/CBB001220458/)
Article
Wickliffe C. Abraham;
Laurence B. Geffen;
Elspeth M. McLachlan;
Linda J. Richards;
John A. P. Rostas;
(2022)
A brief history of the Australasian Neuroscience Society
(/isis/citation/CBB646541490/)
Be the first to comment!