Like Hannah Decker, I too deplore the destructive battle of psychosocial and biological reductionisms that has bedeviled psychiatry. When I started my psychiatric training almost 50 years ago, the prevailing model for understanding mental disorders was broadly bio/psycho/social in the grand tradition of Pinel and Freud, brought to and adapted in America by Adolph Meyer. When psychiatry is practiced well, it integrates insights from all the different ways of understanding human nature. Unfortunately, the mental health field has since degenerated into a civil war between the biomedical and psychosocial models with little room for compromise or finding middle ground. The inflexible biological reductionists assume that genes are destiny and that there is a pill for every problem: they take a “mindless” position. The inflexible psychosocial reductionists assume that mental health problems all arise from unpleasant experience: They take a “brainless” position. I have spent a good deal of frustrating time trying to open the minds of extremists at both ends, though rarely making much headway. In my view, however, and where I differ from Decker, the reductionisms do not sort so neatly into alternating historical periods. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)(journal abstract)
...More
Article
Smith, Matthew;
(2008)
Psychiatry Limited: Hyperactivity and the Evolution of American Psychiatry, 1957--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB000930679/)
Book
Anne Harrington;
(2019)
Mind Fixers: Psychiatry's Troubled Search for the Biology of Mental Illness
(/isis/citation/CBB265847305/)
Book
Schechter, Kate;
(2014)
Illusions of a Future: Psychoanalysis and the Biopolitics of Desire
(/isis/citation/CBB001551577/)
Thesis
Rector, Claudia A.;
(2010)
Whose Story Is It Anyway? Constructing the Stories and Pathology of Madness/Mental Illness in the Contemporary U.S.
(/isis/citation/CBB001567168/)
Book
Anneli Jefferson;
(2022)
Are Mental Disorders Brain Disorders?
(/isis/citation/CBB121431741/)
Article
Jessica Tran The;
(2021)
Freud, Griesinger and Foville: the influence of the nineteenth-century psychiatric tradition in the Freudian concept of delusion as an ‘attempt at recovery’
(/isis/citation/CBB932833490/)
Article
Bartolucci, Chiara;
Lombardo, Giovanni Pietro;
(2016)
Il metodo clinico-differenziale di Enrico Morselli tra psichiatria e psicologia
(/isis/citation/CBB966451901/)
Article
Aaron Lahl;
Patrick Henze;
(2020)
Developing Homosexuality: Fritz Morgenthaler, Junction Points and Psychoanalytic Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB304045330/)
Article
Hannah S. Decker;
(2016)
Cyclical Swings: The Bête Noire of Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB171698648/)
Article
Sonia Bellavia;
(2019)
Otto Rank and Hermann Bahr Amidst Theater and Psychoanalysis in Freud's Vienna
(/isis/citation/CBB682143936/)
Article
Kauders, Anthony D.;
(2013)
Truth, Truthfulness, and Psychoanalysis: The Reception of Freud in Wilhelmine Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB001212922/)
Book
Tauber, Alfred I.;
(2010)
Freud, the Reluctant Philosopher
(/isis/citation/CBB001232184/)
Book
Lakoff, Andrew;
(2005)
Pharmaceutical Reason: Knowledge and Value in Global Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB000775225/)
Article
Henckes, Nicolas;
(2011)
Reshaping Chronicity: Neuroleptics and Changing Meanings of Therapy in French Psychiatry, 1950--1975
(/isis/citation/CBB001221533/)
Book
Michael Escamilla;
(2016)
Bleuler, Jung, and the Creation of the Schizophrenias
(/isis/citation/CBB832704528/)
Book
Kandel, Eric R;
(2012)
The Age of Insight: The Quest to Understand the Unconscious in Art, Mind, and Brain, from Vienna 1900 to the Present
(/isis/citation/CBB001201847/)
Article
Daniel Mason;
Honor Hsin;
(2018)
‘A more perfect arrangement of plants’: the botanical model in psychiatric nosology, 1676 to the present day
(/isis/citation/CBB222714448/)
Book
Missa, Jean-Noël;
(2006)
Naissance de la psychiatrie biologique: histoire des traitements des maladies mentales au XXe siècle
(/isis/citation/CBB000772828/)
Article
Mills, John A.;
(2010)
Hallucinogens as Hard Science: The Adrenochrome Hypothesis for the Biogenesis of Schizophrenia
(/isis/citation/CBB001033694/)
Book
Jonathan Y. Tsou;
(2021)
Philosophy of Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB148276873/)
Be the first to comment!