Citizen Science Beyond Invited Participation: Nineteenth Century Amateur Naturalists, Epistemic Autonomy, and Big Data Approaches Avant La Lettre (2019)
Mahr, Dana (Author)
Dickel, Sascha (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 41
Issue: 4
Pages: 41
Dominant forms of contemporary big-data based digital citizen science do not question the institutional divide between qualified experts and lay-persons. In our paper, we turn to the historical case of a large-scale amateur project on biogeographical birdwatching in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century to show that networked amateur research (that produces a large set of data) can operate in a more autonomous mode. This mode depends on certain cultural values, the constitution of specific knowledge objects, and the design of self-governed infrastructures. We conclude by arguing that the contemporary quest for autonomous citizen science is part of a broader discourse on the autonomy of scientific research in general. Just as the actors in our historical case positioned themselves against the elitism of gentlemen scientists, avant-garde groups of the twenty first century like biohackers and civic tech enthusiasts position themselves against the system of professional science—while “digital citizen science” remains to oscillate between claims for autonomy and realities of heteronomy, constantly reaffirming the classic lay-expert divide.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Martin Rohde;
(2019)
Local knowledge and amateur participation. Shevchenko Scientific Society, 1892–1914
(/isis/citation/CBB769100915/)
Article
Baker, R. A.;
(2007)
In Search of a Naturalist -- Natural History in Warrington from 1870 to 1910 and the Records and Collections of Linnaeus Greening (1855--1927)
(/isis/citation/CBB000774082/)
Article
Russell McGregor;
(2022)
J. A. Leach’s Australian Bird Book: At the interface of science and recreation
(/isis/citation/CBB681830473/)
Article
Etienne S. Benson;
(2017)
A Centrifuge of Calculation: Managing Data and Enthusiasm in Early Twentieth-Century Bird Banding
(/isis/citation/CBB999485139/)
Article
Roman Gilmintinov;
(2019)
“We can and we must”: The scientificity of trade-union history-writing in the Soviet Union in the 1920s
(/isis/citation/CBB397639123/)
Article
Robin M. Sellers;
Stephen Hewitt;
(2020)
Carlisle Museum's Natural History Record Bureau, 1902–1912: Britain's first local environmental records centre
(/isis/citation/CBB867547820/)
Thesis
Matthew Hayden Anthony;
(2020)
‘Surgical and Rigorous (Yet Always Fun)’: Science, Sport, and Community in American Birding, 1950-1980
(/isis/citation/CBB839353373/)
Multimedia Object
Candela Marini;
Kerr, Ashley Elizabeth;
(2020)
Ashley E. Kerr, “Sex, Skulls, and Citizens: Gender and Racial Science in Argentina (1860-1910)” (Vanderbilt UP, 2020)
(/isis/citation/CBB932736455/)
Article
Alexander I. Parry;
(2023)
Delivering Bacteriology to the American Homemaker: Correspondence Education, Kitchen Experiments, and Public Health, 1890–1930
(/isis/citation/CBB239832240/)
Article
Jason Lustig;
(2019)
‘Mere Chips from His Workshop’: Gotthard Deutsch’s Monumental Card Index of Jewish History
(/isis/citation/CBB923387079/)
Book
Aya H. Kimura;
Abby Kinchy;
(2019)
Science by the People: Participation, Power, and the Politics of Environmental Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB605020733/)
Book
Tobias Scheidegger;
(2017)
"Petite Science": Außeruniversitäre Naturforschung in der Schweiz um 1900
(/isis/citation/CBB493764349/)
Article
Stefano Giovanardi;
Gabriele Catanzaro;
Giangiacomo Gandolfi;
Gianluca Masi;
(2018)
E Lucevan Le Stelle: Engaging the Public of Rome in a Cultural Repossession of the Urban Sky
(/isis/citation/CBB444510701/)
Article
Karen Kovaka;
(2021)
Evaluating Community Science
(/isis/citation/CBB988749229/)
Thesis
Jonathan Isaac Cluck;
(2015)
Parasite Labs: Laboratory Protocols of Do-It-Yourself Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB277458520/)
Article
Laura Miralles;
Eva Garcia-Vazquez;
Eduardo Dopico;
(2021)
Game-based learning for engaging citizens in biopollution control
(/isis/citation/CBB727121914/)
Article
Veronica della Dora;
(2023)
From the Radio Shack to the Cosmos: Listening to Sputnik during the International Geophysical Year (1957–1958)
(/isis/citation/CBB770612333/)
Article
Julia M Wells;
(2020)
Quinine, Whisky, and Epsom Salts: Amateur Medical Treatment in the White Settler Communities of British East and South-Central Africa, 1890–1939
(/isis/citation/CBB204814791/)
Article
Hochadel, Oliver;
(2011)
Watching Exotic Animals Next Door: “Scientific” Observations at the Zoo (ca. 1870--1910)
(/isis/citation/CBB001034614/)
Article
Loskutova, M. V.;
(2011)
Amateurs and Professionals: Science in a Russian Province from the Second Half of the 19th Century to the Beginning of the 20th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001211387/)
Be the first to comment!