Prophets of Plenty: How Scientists Ignored Natural Complexity and Overpromised Sustainable Fisheries, 1863-Present (2023)
Van Neste, Aaron (Author)
Oreskes, Naomi (Advisor)
Harvard University
Oreskes, Naomi
Physical Details: 736
Language: English
In this dissertation I argue that fisheries science overpromised and under-delivered large sustainable catches. Fisheries scientists’ presumption of plenitude encouraged them to ignore important aspects of fish ecology like population fluctuations and species interactions. Along with challenges acquiring reliable population data, these ecological factors generated inherent uncertainty and posed barriers to large sustainable catches. By ignoring these ecological factors and assuming abundance when confronted with uncertainty, scientists systematically set catches high enough to incur substantial risk of fishery and ecosystem collapse. This presumption of plenitude emerged from the field’s purpose as a technoscientific method of maximizing sustained catch for benefit of the fishing industry and fish consumers, and despite advances in science and policy, has remained an anchoring concept for fisheries science in ways that put marine ecosystems at continued risk of collapse.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Patrick Bresnihan;
(2016)
Transforming the Fisheries: Neoliberalism, Nature, and the Commons
(/isis/citation/CBB658820199/)
Book
Finley, Carmel;
(2011)
All The Fish in The Sea: Maximum Sustainable Yield and the Failure of Fisheries Management
(/isis/citation/CBB001221114/)
Article
Hébert, Karen;
(2010)
In Pursuit of Singular Salmon: Paradoxes of Sustainability and the Quality Commodity
(/isis/citation/CBB001034648/)
Article
Colin Pooley;
(August 2021)
Walking spaces: Changing pedestrian practices in Britain since c. 1850
(/isis/citation/CBB532227056/)
Article
Daniel Newman;
(June 2017)
Automobiles and Socioeconomic Sustainability: Do We Need a Mobility Bill of Rights?
(/isis/citation/CBB317242429/)
Article
Efrain O'Neill-Carrillo;
Emmanuel Mercado;
Oscar Luhring;
Isaac Jordan;
Agustin Irizarry-Rivera;
(September 2019)
Community Energy Projects in the Caribbean: Advancing Socio-Economic Development and Energy Transitions
(/isis/citation/CBB741220720/)
Article
Katie Meehan;
Nicole L. Klenk;
Fabián Mendez;
(September 2018)
The Geopolitics of Climate Knowledge Mobilization: Transdisciplinary Research at the Science–Policy Interface(s) in the Americas
(/isis/citation/CBB779548042/)
Book
Melinda Harm Benson;
Robin Kundis Craig;
(2017)
The End of Sustainability: Resilience and the Future of Environmental Governance in the Anthropocene
(/isis/citation/CBB796537319/)
Article
Mohammad Habibian;
(Winter 2011)
Critical Issues and Sustainability Challenges for a Large Metropolitan Water-Wastewater Facility
(/isis/citation/CBB689881696/)
Book
Alfonso Lucifredi;
(2024)
Troppi. Conversazione sulla sovrappopolazione umana e sul futuro del pianeta
(/isis/citation/CBB706298942/)
Book
Malin, Stephanie A.;
(2015)
The price of nuclear power: uranium communities and environmental justice
(/isis/citation/CBB674066950/)
Article
Thomas Pettersson;
Johan Jansson;
Urban Lindgren;
(2023)
A barrier to sustainable transports? Path dependence and the Swedish tax deduction for commuting
(/isis/citation/CBB374251171/)
Book
Carmel Finley;
(2017)
All the Boats on the Ocean: How Government Subsidies Led to Global Overfishing
(/isis/citation/CBB479199142/)
Article
Taylor, Vanessa;
Chappells, Heather;
Medd, Will;
Trentmann, Frank;
(2009)
Drought Is Normal: The Socio-Technical Evolution of Drought and Water Demand in England and Wales, 1893--2006
(/isis/citation/CBB001034156/)
Book
Craig Thomas;
(2018)
Sustainability and the American Naturalist Tradition: Revisiting Henry David Thoreau, Aldo Leopold, Rachel Carson, and Edward O. Wilson
(/isis/citation/CBB119284544/)
Book
Sagarin, Rafe;
Pauchard, Aníbal;
(2012)
Observation and Ecology: Broadening the Scope of Science to Understand a Complex World
(/isis/citation/CBB001421416/)
Book
MacDowell, Laurel Sefton;
(2012)
An Environmental History of Canada
(/isis/citation/CBB001422385/)
Article
Perru, Olivier;
(2011)
Le mutualisme biologique, concepts et modèles
(/isis/citation/CBB001250033/)
Article
Stokland, Håkon B.;
(2015)
Field Studies in Absentia: Counting and Monitoring from a Distance as Technologies of Government in Norwegian Wolf Management (1960s--2010s)
(/isis/citation/CBB001422098/)
Article
Poonam Pandey;
Govert Valkenburg;
Annapurna Mamidipudi;
Wiebe E. Bijker;
(2021)
“All We Want, Is to Get Rid of the Straw”: How Biofuel Policies Need to Be Multiple
(/isis/citation/CBB841746332/)
Be the first to comment!