Can Science and Religion Meet Over Their Subject-Matter? Some Thoughts on Thirteenth and Fourteenth-Century Discussions (2016)
As is well known, natural science and religion were not considered natural enemies in the later Middle Ages, but no conflict between the two seems even conceivable unless they have some common ground in their subject-matters. Drawing on the work of Thomas Aquinas and John Duns Scotus, amongst others, this paper considers how natural science and religion were related in the scholastic thought of the late thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries, and asks whether science can ever make contributions to religious knowledge. I consider whether natural science and theology can ever meet over their subject-matter, and whether science can encroach on religious matters. I argue that science cannot make contributions to knowledge concerning infinite beings or their effects, for finite effects do not require infinite causes. I discuss the philosophical dispute over the eternity of the world and whether it can be demonstrated that the world had a temporal beginning. I argue that only insofar as religions make empirical claims about the natural world do science and religion share a subject-matter. I look at arguments for the necessity of supernatural revelation from the insufficiency of Aristotelian science, and for the central importance of metaphysics to theology in scholastic thought.
...MoreBook Jack P. Cunningham; Mark Hocknull (2016) Robert Grosseteste and the Pursuit of Religious and Scientific Learning in the Middle Ages.
Similar Citations
Book
Vendemiati, Aldo;
(2011)
San Tommaso e la legge naturale
(/isis/citation/CBB001252977/)
Article
Smoller, Laura Ackerman;
(2007)
Astrology and the Sibyls: John of Legnano's De adventu Christi and the Natural Theology of the Later Middle Ages
(/isis/citation/CBB000850275/)
Book
Maria Sorokina;
(2021)
Les sphères, les astres et les théologiens: L’influence céleste entre science et foi dans les commentaires des Sentences (v. 1220 - v. 1340)
(/isis/citation/CBB416019954/)
Chapter
Tachau, Katherine H.;
(2006)
Seeing as Action and Passion in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB001020161/)
Book
Schinagl, Elisabeth;
(2001)
Naturkunde-Exempla in lateinischen Predigtsammlungen des 13. und 14. Jahrhunderts
(/isis/citation/CBB000640624/)
Article
Michelina Di Cesare;
(2019)
A Vademecum for a Missionary: Turin, Biblioteca Nazionale Universitaria, ms. E. V. 8
(/isis/citation/CBB191196438/)
Article
Giralt, Sebastià;
(2013)
The Legend of Arnau de Vilanova, from the Middle Ages to the Early Modern Times
(/isis/citation/CBB001420839/)
Book
Graziella Federici Vescovini;
(2020)
Pietro d'Abano tra storia e leggenda
(/isis/citation/CBB011405949/)
Article
Crisciani, Chiara;
(2006)
Tra Dio, intelletto ed esperienza: aspetti del secreto nell'alchimia latina (secoli XIII-XIV)
(/isis/citation/CBB001020530/)
Chapter
Cattaneo, Angelo;
(2009)
Cosmographie et prédication médiévale et renaissante
(/isis/citation/CBB001220755/)
Article
Leicht, Reimund;
(2013)
Miracles for the Sake of the Master of Reason Hillel. Ben Samuel of Verona's Legendary Account of the Maimonidean Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB001420843/)
Book
Federici-Vescovini, Graziella;
(2008)
Medioevo magico: la magia tra religione e scienza nei secoli XIII e XIV
(/isis/citation/CBB001020218/)
Chapter
Gallarino, Marco;
(2008)
Il ruolo cosmogonico della rovina angelica nel pensiero di Dante
(/isis/citation/CBB001020549/)
Book
Crocker, Robert;
(2001)
Religion, Reason, and Nature in Early Modern Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB000500886/)
Book
Alexandrescu, Vlad;
Theis, Robert;
(2010)
Nature et surnaturel: Philosophies de la nature et métaphysique aux XVIe--XVIIIe siècles
(/isis/citation/CBB001023213/)
Chapter
Bekkum, Wout J. van;
(2005)
Medieval Jewish Approaches to Natural Law. The Rationalism of Saadya Gaon
(/isis/citation/CBB001020092/)
Chapter
Yael Kedar;
(2016)
Laying the Foundation for the Nomological Image of Nature: From Corporeity in Robert Grosseteste to Species in Roger Bacon
(/isis/citation/CBB290031289/)
Article
Yael Kedar;
Giora Hon;
(2017)
Roger Bacon (c. 1220–1292) and his System of Laws of Nature: Classification, Hierarchy and Significance
(/isis/citation/CBB146502814/)
Article
Eardley, Peter S.;
(2013)
Conscience and the Foundations of Morality in Ockham's Metaethics
(/isis/citation/CBB001450273/)
Chapter
Calvo, Emilia;
(2008)
Mīqāt in Ibn Bāṣo's al-Risāla fī l-Ṣafīḥa al-Mujayyaba Dhāt al-Awtār (Treatise on the Plate of Sines)
(/isis/citation/CBB001022260/)
Be the first to comment!