The Song of the Science Mermaid: A Philosophical Trilogue on the Osteological Paradox (2021)
Morrone, Alessandra (Author)
Zorzato, Lisa (Author)
Acta Baltica historiae et philosophiae scientiarum
Volume: 9
Issue: 1
Pages: 27-50
As a modern academic Ulysses, the historical scientist is enticed by numerous plausible scientific theories that can explain the historical data in search of the truth. However, the predicament of her work is to inevitably crash onto the rocks and cliffs of uncertainty. The problem discussed in this paper is that several scientific models can be suitable to account for the same empirical observations. The risk of falling into speculation is looming, and exceedingly dangerous in science. This is also the case in archaeological sciences, such as bioarchaeology. A bioarchaeologist frequently encounters traces of disease in ancient skeletons, and pertinent patterns may often result from equally probable different causes. This is a methodological issue commonly encountered in the interpretation of pathological patterns in human remains, and constitutes part of the problem known in bioarchaeology as the osteological paradox. During an informal trilogue, three characters discuss the osteological paradox, and attempt to define it in philosophical terms. The aim of this work is to present the problems of scientists with the philosophical approach to the debate between scientific realism and antirealism, focusing in particular on the so-called problem of underdetermination. Our original approach is to apply the distinction between ‘how-possibly’ models and ‘how-actually’ models by Alisa Bokulich to archaeological issues, integrating various fields of science with a multidisciplinary and omnivorous approach. The trilogue ends providing the historical scientist with reasons and means to believe in her ability to conceive of true and reliable scientific models to interpret the historical past.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Clark Spencer Larsen;
Fabian Crespo;
(2022)
Paleosyndemics: A Bioarchaeological and Biosocial Approach to Study Infectious Diseases in the Past
(/isis/citation/CBB022705043/)
Book
Sophie A. De Beaune;
Alessandro Guidi;
Oscar Moro Abadia;
Massimo Tarantini;
(2021)
New Advances in the History of Archaeology: Proceedings of the XVIII Uispp World Congress 4-9 June 2018, Paris, France Sessions Organised by the ... of the XVIII Uispp World Congress, 16)
(/isis/citation/CBB473070502/)
Article
Wylie, Alison;
(1999)
Rethinking Unity as a “Working Hypothesis” for Philosophy of Science: How Archaeologists Exploit the Disunities of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB000110822/)
Article
David Merritt;
(2021)
Cosmological Realism
(/isis/citation/CBB244895079/)
Article
Dietrich, Michael R.;
Skipper, Robert A., Jr.;
(2007)
Manipulating Underdetermination in Scientific Controversy: The Case of the Molecular Clock
(/isis/citation/CBB000830784/)
Article
Eli I. Lichtenstein;
(2021)
(Mis)Understanding scientific disagreement: Success versus pursuit-worthiness in theory choice
(/isis/citation/CBB459964165/)
Article
K. Brad Wray;
(2021)
Kuhn and the Contemporary Realism/Antirealism Debates
(/isis/citation/CBB645916934/)
Article
Laurynas Adomaitis;
(2019)
Equivalence of hypotheses and Galilean censure in Leibniz: A conspiracy or a way to moderate censure?
(/isis/citation/CBB683885385/)
Article
Cornelis Menke;
(2018)
The Whewell-Mill Debate on Predictions, from Mill's Point of View
(/isis/citation/CBB045518739/)
Article
Dmitri Levitin;
(2021)
Newton on the Rules of Philosophizing and Hypotheses: New Evidence, New Conclusions
(/isis/citation/CBB194940336/)
Book
Sommer, Marianne;
(2007)
Bones and Ochre: The Curious Afterlife of the Red Lady of Paviland
(/isis/citation/CBB000774284/)
Thesis
Bernofsky, K S;
(cited 2010)
Respiratory Health in the Past: A Bioarchaeological Study of Chronic Maxillary Sinusitis and Rib Periostitis from the Iron Age to the Post Medieval Period in Southern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001567244/)
Article
Sébastien Plutniak;
Camille Noûs;
(2020)
De l'usage des science studies dans les controverses scientifiques : Une illustration archéologique (suivi de : Georges Laplace, “Autorité et tradition en taxinomie”
(/isis/citation/CBB402301089/)
Book
Domenico Carro;
(2021)
Quadriremi vs. Vesuvio. L'operazione navale di soccorso condotta da Plinio nel 79 D.C.
(/isis/citation/CBB212703608/)
Chapter
Giuseppe D'Acunto;
Antonio Calandriello;
(2022)
New digital prototypes for the narration of archaeological data
(/isis/citation/CBB663107852/)
Chapter
Fantina Madricardo;
Antonio Petrizzo;
Federica Foglini;
(2022)
High resolution seafloor mapping for underwater archaeology in the Venice Lagoon
(/isis/citation/CBB859665435/)
Article
Goodrum, Matthew R.;
(2012)
The Idea of Human Prehistory: The Natural Sciences, the Human Sciences, and the Problem of Human Origins in Victorian Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB001210310/)
Article
Kyle Harper;
(2020)
Germs, genomes, and global history in the time of COVID-19
(/isis/citation/CBB422578756/)
Chapter
Irene Guarnieri;
Antonio Petrizzo;
Daphnie Galvez;
Davide Tagliapietra;
Fantina Madricardo;
(2022)
Benthic habitat mapping and underwater archaeological structures in the northen Venice Lagoon tidal channels
(/isis/citation/CBB519632909/)
Book
Luca Zamparo;
Monica Salvadori;
Elisa Bernard;
Monica Baggio;
(2019)
Anthropology of Forgery: A Multidisciplinary Approach to the Study of Archaeological Fakes
(/isis/citation/CBB719395081/)
Be the first to comment!