Michael Wiitala (Author)
Apeiron: Journal for Ancient Philosophy and Science
Volume: 51
Issue: 2
Pages: 171-200
There are only two places in which Plato explicitly offers a critique of the sort of theory of forms presented in the Phaedo and Republic: at the beginning of the Parmenides and in the argument against the Friends of the Forms in the Sophist. An accurate account of the argument against the Friends, therefore, is crucial to a proper understanding of Plato’s metaphysics. How the argument against the Friends ought to be construed and what it aims to accomplish, however, are matters of considerable controversy. My aim in this article is twofold. First, I show that the two readings of the argument against the Friends that dominate the contemporary literature – the “Cambridge Change” reading and the “Becoming-is-Being” reading – lack sufficient textual support. Second, I offer an alternative reading of the argument against the Friends that better explains both the text of 248a4–249d5 and the role the argument plays within the Stranger’s wider project of demonstrating that non-being is. My thesis is that the Stranger’s argument against the Friends seeks to demonstrate that the forms must be both at rest and moved, where “moved” (kineisthai) has the sense of “affected.” To participate in a form is to be affected by that form. I argue that since, according to the Stranger, every form participates in some other forms (see 251d5–253a2), every form is “moved” in the sense that it is affected by the forms in which it participates. Likewise, I argue that every form is at rest in the sense that its unique nature remains unaffected by the other forms in which it participates.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Martinez, Joel A.;
(2011)
Rethinking Plato's Conception of Knowledge: The Non-Philosopher and the Forms
(/isis/citation/CBB001250018/)
Book
Theokritos Kouremenos;
(2019)
Plato's Forms, Mathematics and Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB619986511/)
Article
Reynolds, Joshua J.;
(2008)
How Is the Third Kind in Plato's Timaeus a Receptacle?
(/isis/citation/CBB001211434/)
Book
Ward, Ann;
(2009)
Matter and Form: From Natural Science to Political Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001201150/)
Article
Franklin, Lee;
(2011)
Particular and Universal: Hypothesis in Plato's Divided Line
(/isis/citation/CBB001250023/)
Article
Reshotko, Naomi;
(2014)
Plato on the Ordinary Person and the Forms
(/isis/citation/CBB001214198/)
Chapter
Sorabji, Richard;
(2002)
Latitude of Forms in Ancient Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB000301295/)
Article
Otto, K. Darcy;
(2009)
The Logic of the First Horn of the Dilemma of Participation
(/isis/citation/CBB001211438/)
Article
Anna Motta;
(2018)
The Philosophy of Artistic Creation: Phidias, the Ideas, and Cicero
(/isis/citation/CBB664182005/)
Chapter
Al-Maini, Douglas;
(2009)
The Polis Philosophers
(/isis/citation/CBB001201151/)
Thesis
Kirby, Jeremy;
(2005)
Material Migration and Aristotelian Metaphysics
(/isis/citation/CBB001561670/)
Chapter
Younesie, Mostafa;
(2009)
Understanding Aristotle's Politics through Form and Matter
(/isis/citation/CBB001201154/)
Article
Douglas R. Campbell;
(2022)
The Soul’s Tomb: Plato on the Body as the Cause of Psychic Disorders
(/isis/citation/CBB299986839/)
Article
Shigeru Yonezawa;
(2018)
Socratic Euporia and Aporia in the Lysis
(/isis/citation/CBB664054592/)
Article
Jacqueline Tusi;
(2020)
Between Rhetoric and Sophistry: The Puzzling Case of Plato’s Gorgias
(/isis/citation/CBB184991584/)
Article
C. G. Healow;
(2021)
Extreme and Modest Conventionalism in Plato’s Cratylus
(/isis/citation/CBB207532051/)
Book
Lloyd P. Gerson;
(2013)
From Plato to Platonism
(/isis/citation/CBB685278391/)
Book
Elaine Landry;
(2023)
Plato Was Not a Mathematical Platonist
(/isis/citation/CBB087575082/)
Article
Wolfsdorf, David;
(2011-12)
Plato's Conception of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001231746/)
Article
Miriam Newton Byrd;
(2007)
Dialectic and Plato's Method of Hypothesis
(/isis/citation/CBB348254274/)
Be the first to comment!