Prediction and control sufficient for reliable medical and other interventions are prominent aims of modeling in systems biology. The short-term attainment of these goals has played a strong role in projecting the importance and value of the field. In this paper I identify the standard models must meet to achieve these objectives as predictive robustness—predictive reliability over large domains. Drawing on the results of an ethnographic investigation and various studies in the systems biology literature, I explore four current obstacles to achieving predictive robustness; data constraints, parameter uncertainty, collaborative constraints and system-scale requirements. I use a case study and the commentary of systems biologists themselves to show that current practices in the field, rather than pursuing these goals, frequently use models heuristically to investigate and build understanding of biological systems that do not meet standards of predictive robustness but are nonetheless effective uses of computation. A more heuristic conception of modeling allows us to interpret current practices as ways that manage these obstacles more effectively, particularly collaborative constraints, such that modelers can in the long-run at least work towards prediction and control.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Michael Fry;
(2018)
Predictive Hypotheses Are Ineffectual in Resolving Complex Biochemical Systems
Article
Miles MacLeod;
Nancy J. Nersessian;
(2015)
Modeling systems-level dynamics: Understanding without mechanistic explanation in integrative systems biology
Article
Janina Wellmann;
(2018)
Model and Movement: Studying Cell Movement in Early Morphogenesis, 1900 to the Present
Book
Sara Green;
(2016)
Philosophy of Systems Biology: Perspectives from Scientists and Philosophers
Article
Miles MacLeod;
Nancy J. Nersessian;
(2018)
Modeling Complexity: Cognitive Constraints and Computational Model-Building in Integrative Systems Biology
Article
Wei Fang;
(2024)
Design principles as minimal models
Article
Yoshinari Yoshida;
(2023)
Joint representation: Modeling a phenomenon with multiple biological systems
Article
Mahony, Martin;
(2014)
The Predictive State: Science, Territory and the Future of the Indian Climate
Article
Nikos Giatrakos;
Nikos Katzouris;
Antonios Deligiannakis;
Alexander Artikis;
Minos Garofalakis;
George Paliouras;
Holger Arndt;
Raffaele Grasso;
Ralf Klinkenberg;
Miguel Ponce De Leon;
Gian Gaetano Tartaglia;
Alfonso Valencia;
Dimitrios Zissis;
(June 2019)
Interactive Extreme-Scale Analytics: Towards Battling Cancer
Article
Remington J. Moll;
Daniel Steel;
Robert A. Montgomery;
(2016)
AIC and the challenge of complexity: A case study from ecology
Article
Gonzalo L. Recio;
(2021)
On the Use of Tables as Heuristic Tools in Ptolemaic Astronomy
Article
Parker, Wendy S.;
(2014)
Simulation and Understanding in the Study of Weather and Climate
Article
Greene, Mott T.;
(2006)
Looking for a General for Some Modern Major Models
Book
Petraitis, Peter Steven;
(2013)
Multiple Stable States in Natural Ecosystems
Article
Oliver Buchholz;
Thomas Grote;
(2023)
Predicting and explaining with machine learning models: Social science as a touchstone
Book
Ann Johnson;
Johannes Lenhard;
(2024)
Cultures of Prediction: How Engineering and Science Evolve with Mathematical Tools
Book
Konstantinos Chatzis;
(2023)
Forecasting Travel in Urban America: The Socio-Technical Life of an Engineering Modeling World
Chapter
Bhushan Patwardhan;
Gururaj Mutalik;
Girish Tillu;
(2015)
Systems Biology and Holistic Concepts
Article
Fridolin Gross;
Nina Kranke;
Robert Meunier;
(2019)
Pluralization Through Epistemic Competition: Scientific Change in Times of Data-Intensive Biology
Article
Michael Fry;
(2020)
Ontologically Simple Theories Do Not Indicate the True Nature of Complex Biological Systems: Three Test Cases
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences
Endeavour: Review of the Progress of Science
IEEE Technology and Society Magazine
Be the first to comment!