Article ID: CBB642902232

Catapults Still Aren’t Atomic Bombs: Effectiveness and Determinism in Premodern Military Technology (December 2019)

unapi

DeVries, Kelly R. (Author)


Vulcan
Volume: 7
Issue: 1
Pages: 34-44


Publication Date: December 2019
Edition Details: Special issue on technological determinism and war.
Language: English

In 1997 War and History published my article, “Catapults Are Not Atomic Bombs: Towards a Redefinition of ‘Effectiveness’ in Premodern Military Technology.” The title was hyperbolic as the article discussed neither catapults nor atomic bombs, but that hyperbole was to serve a purpose: to have military historians, primarily historians of military technology rethink their notions of military technological determinism, especially in interpreting premodern military history. In that article I used three examples: the chariot, the longbow, and gunpowder weaponry, suggesting that the use of these technologies by modern historians as determining catastrophe, invincibility, and revolution, respectively, was overstating their effects on history. After 22 years I was asked to revisit my original thoughts and here use the various chroniclers’ descriptions at the battle of Crécy (1346) and the function of the English longbows (and longbowmen) to explore how the premodern world thought about technology in war. Ultimately, I reaffirm the importance of humans over technology in any military situation, even if the technologies are either characteristic or central to any particular engagement.

...More
Includes Series Articles

Article Brown, Gates M. (December 2019) Technology’s Unrealistic Promise: The US Army in the 1950s and Technological Determinism. Vulcan (pp. 62-80). unapi

Included in

Article Goodman, Seymour E. (December 2019) Deploying Technological Innovation in “Real Time”: Union and Confederate Ironclads. Vulcan (pp. 81-110). unapi

Article Roland, Alex (December 2019) Is Military Technology Deterministic?. Vulcan (pp. 19-33). unapi

Article Zimmerman, David (December 2019) Neither Catapults nor Atomic Bombs: Technological Determinism and Military History from a Post-Industrial Revolution Perspective. Vulcan (pp. 45-61). unapi

Article Walton, Steven A. (December 2019) Technological Determinism(s) and the Study of War. Vulcan (pp. 4-18). unapi

Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB642902232/

Similar Citations

Article Roland, Alex; (December 2019)
Is Military Technology Deterministic? (/isis/citation/CBB761922629/)

Article Walton, Steven A.; (December 2019)
Technological Determinism(s) and the Study of War (/isis/citation/CBB447906454/)

Article Brown, Gates M.; (December 2019)
Technology’s Unrealistic Promise: The US Army in the 1950s and Technological Determinism (/isis/citation/CBB875270366/)

Article Goodman, Seymour E.; (December 2019)
Deploying Technological Innovation in “Real Time”: Union and Confederate Ironclads (/isis/citation/CBB715470633/)

Chapter Dagmar Schaefer; (2017)
Science in the Pre-Modern East (/isis/citation/CBB803417657/)

Article B. N. Narahari Achar; (2016)
Revisiting the Calendar Tradition of Ancient India (/isis/citation/CBB142531428/)

Article Rogers, Clifford J.; (2011)
The Development of the Longbow in Late Medieval England and “Technological Determinism” (/isis/citation/CBB001230846/)

Article Dipak Jadhav; Anupam Jain; (2016)
Combinatorics as Found in the Gommatasāra of Nemicandra (/isis/citation/CBB771147028/)

Chapter Mark Elvin; (2010)
Introductions (/isis/citation/CBB791817002/)

Article P. Ram Manohar; (2016)
Medical Genetics in Classical Ayurvedic Texts: A Critical Review (/isis/citation/CBB810371497/)

Chapter Mark Elvin; (2010)
Personal Luck: Why Premodern China—Probably— Did Not Develop Probalistic Thinking (/isis/citation/CBB612844900/)

Book Jan Hendryk de Boer; Marian Füssel; Maximillian Schuh; (2018)
Universitäre Gelehrtenkultur vom 13.–16. Jahrhundert: Ein interdisziplinäres Quellen- und Methodenhandbuch (/isis/citation/CBB620356132/)

Article Thomas J. Misa; (2019)
Dominance of the Digital (1990–2016) (/isis/citation/CBB686040323/)

Article Long, Pamela O.; (2010)
The Craft of Premodern European History of Technology: Past and Future Practice (/isis/citation/CBB001230627/)

Book Diane E. Bailey; Paul M. Leonardi; (2015)
Technology choices: Why occupations differ in their embrace of new technology (/isis/citation/CBB321994922/)

Authors & Contributors
Elvin, Mark
Schaefer, Dagmar
Anupam Jain
Schuh, Maximillian
Gerhard Dohrn-Van Rossum
Bailey, Diane E.
Concepts
Technological determinism
Military technology
Technological innovation
India, civilization and culture
Social construction; constructivism
Classification
Time Periods
Premodern
21st century
Medieval
20th century, late
20th century
Renaissance
Places
Europe
China
Levant and Near East
England
Mediterranean region
East Asia
Institutions
United States. Army
Society for the History of Technology
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment