IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB642902232

Catapults Still Aren’t Atomic Bombs: Effectiveness and Determinism in Premodern Military Technology (December 2019)

DeVries, Kelly R. (Author)

Vulcan
Volume: 7
Issue: 1
Pages: 34-44

ISSN: 2213-459X; 2213-4603

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/22134603-00701004

Publication Date: December 2019
Edition Details: Special issue on technological determinism and war.
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

In 1997 War and History published my article, “Catapults Are Not Atomic Bombs: Towards a Redefinition of ‘Effectiveness’ in Premodern Military Technology.” The title was hyperbolic as the article discussed neither catapults nor atomic bombs, but that hyperbole was to serve a purpose: to have military historians, primarily historians of military technology rethink their notions of military technological determinism, especially in interpreting premodern military history. In that article I used three examples: the chariot, the longbow, and gunpowder weaponry, suggesting that the use of these technologies by modern historians as determining catastrophe, invincibility, and revolution, respectively, was overstating their effects on history. After 22 years I was asked to revisit my original thoughts and here use the various chroniclers’ descriptions at the battle of Crécy (1346) and the function of the English longbows (and longbowmen) to explore how the premodern world thought about technology in war. Ultimately, I reaffirm the importance of humans over technology in any military situation, even if the technologies are either characteristic or central to any particular engagement.

...More

Includes Series Articles

Article Brown, Gates M. (December 2019) Technology’s Unrealistic Promise: The US Army in the 1950s and Technological Determinism. Vulcan (pp. 62-80). unapi

Included in

Article Goodman, Seymour E. (December 2019) Deploying Technological Innovation in “Real Time”: Union and Confederate Ironclads. Vulcan (pp. 81-110). unapi

Article Roland, Alex (December 2019) Is Military Technology Deterministic?. Vulcan (pp. 19-33). unapi

Article Zimmerman, David (December 2019) Neither Catapults nor Atomic Bombs: Technological Determinism and Military History from a Post-Industrial Revolution Perspective. Vulcan (pp. 45-61). unapi

Article Walton, Steven A. (December 2019) Technological Determinism(s) and the Study of War. Vulcan (pp. 4-18). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB642902232/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Roland, Alex; (December 2019)
Is Military Technology Deterministic? (/isis/citation/CBB761922629/)

Article Walton, Steven A.; (December 2019)
Technological Determinism(s) and the Study of War (/isis/citation/CBB447906454/)

Article Zimmerman, David; (December 2019)
Neither Catapults nor Atomic Bombs: Technological Determinism and Military History from a Post-Industrial Revolution Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB176871982/)

Article Goodman, Seymour E.; (December 2019)
Deploying Technological Innovation in “Real Time”: Union and Confederate Ironclads (/isis/citation/CBB715470633/)

Article Brown, Gates M.; (December 2019)
Technology’s Unrealistic Promise: The US Army in the 1950s and Technological Determinism (/isis/citation/CBB875270366/)

Chapter Dagmar Schaefer; (2017)
Science in the Pre-Modern East (/isis/citation/CBB803417657/)

Article Rogers, Clifford J.; (2011)
The Development of the Longbow in Late Medieval England and “Technological Determinism” (/isis/citation/CBB001230846/)

Article Sally Wyatt; (March 2017)
Making Policies for Open Data: Experiencing the Technological Imperative in the Policy World (Special Issue Commentary) (/isis/citation/CBB070435927/)

Article B. N. Narahari Achar; (2016)
Revisiting the Calendar Tradition of Ancient India (/isis/citation/CBB142531428/)

Article Gerhard Dohrn-Van Rossum; (2019)
Uhrmacher als Prototypen technischer Experten in der europäischen Vormoderne: das Zusammenwirken technischer Kompetenzen bei den Ingenieuren der Renaissance (Watchmakers as prototypes of technical experts in the European pre-modern era: the interaction of technical skills among Renaissance engineers) (/isis/citation/CBB052698974/)

Book Timothy James LeCain; (2017)
The Matter of History: How Things Create the Past (/isis/citation/CBB520455776/)

Article Daniel Neyland; (January 2016)
Bearing Account-able Witness to the Ethical Algorithmic System (/isis/citation/CBB408589504/)

Book König, Wolfgang; (2010)
Technikgeschichte (/isis/citation/CBB001420998/)

Article Thomas Turnbull; (2021)
Energy, history, and the humanities: against a new determinism (/isis/citation/CBB868406334/)

Book Ben Epstein; (2018)
The Only Constant Is Change: Technology, Political Communication, and Innovation Over Time (/isis/citation/CBB473931649/)

Article Evan Selinger; Darrin Durant; (2022)
Amazon’s Ring: Surveillance as a Slippery Slope Service (/isis/citation/CBB181826170/)

Article Sébastien Plutniak; (2020)
The effects of publishing processes on scientific thought: Typography and typology in prehistoric archaeology (1950s–1990s (/isis/citation/CBB452865118/)

Article Roland, Alex; (2010)
Was the Nuclear Arms Race Deterministic? (/isis/citation/CBB000954242/)

Article P. Ram Manohar; (2016)
Medical Genetics in Classical Ayurvedic Texts: A Critical Review (/isis/citation/CBB810371497/)

Article Dipak Jadhav; Anupam Jain; (2016)
Combinatorics as Found in the Gommatasāra of Nemicandra (/isis/citation/CBB771147028/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}