Digital Humanities as the Historian’s Trojan Horse: Response to Commentary in the Special Section on Digital History (2018)
The commentaries by Baldwin (2018), Green (2018), and Porter (2018) on the 2 articles (Burman, 2018; Flis & Van Eck, 2018) in this special section provide a unique perspective on digital humanities approaches to history of psychology. Each of the commentators approached the topic through their own lens—Melinda Baldwin as a historian of scientific journals, Christopher Green as a pioneer in digital history of psychology, and Ted Porter as a historian of quantification. In my response, I tried to reply to the 3 comments by critically discussing 4 themes the special section has raised: the relationship between digital history and conventional history, the perspective that takes databases as both sources for historians and objects in history, the relationship between “thick descriptions” and “thin” digital ones, and finally, the role of digital history as a type of a “trading creole” between scientists working in quantified disciplines like scientific psychology and less quantified ones like history. I think the commentators have rightly observed some pitfalls in the uncritical application of digital history. On the other hand, in my response, I argue that the careful use of digital methods, where the user stays in communication with nondigital historians, opens new perspectives for historians of science, historians of psychology, and psychologists themselves. Digital methods are not there to supplant historicist work but to add to it and translate it to new audiences. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2018 APA, all rights reserved) (Source: journal abstract)
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Theodore M. Porter;
(2018)
Digital Humanism
(/isis/citation/CBB751955814/)
Article
Melinda Baldwin;
(2018)
A Perspective from the History of Scientific Journals
(/isis/citation/CBB030888393/)
Chapter
Stephen P. Weldon;
(2015)
Historians and Their Data
(/isis/citation/CBB944568735/)
Article
Anu Masso;
Maris Männiste;
Andra Siibak;
(2020)
‘End of Theory’ in the Era of Big Data: Methodological Practices and Challenges in Social Media Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB632756299/)
Book
Zalc, Claire;
Claire Lemercier;
(2019)
Quantitative methods in the humanities: an introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB438948586/)
Article
Jessica Pykett;
Mark Paterson;
(2022)
Stressing the ‘body electric’: History and psychology of the techno-ecologies of work stress
(/isis/citation/CBB933468112/)
Thesis
Jaimie Murdock;
(2019)
Topic Modeling the Reading and Writing Behavior of Information Foragers
(/isis/citation/CBB117865546/)
Article
Abraham Gibson;
Manfred D. Laubichler;
Jane Maienschein;
(2019)
Introduction to Focus: Computational History and Philosophy of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB323182392/)
Article
Zelle, Carsten;
(2013)
Empiricism and the “Reasonable Physicians” of the Early Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB001213585/)
Book
Jim Thatcher;
Andrew Shears;
Josef Eckert;
(2018)
Thinking Big Data in Geography: New Regimes, New Research
(/isis/citation/CBB720972061/)
Article
Patrick Egan (Pádraig Mac Aodhgáin);
(2021)
Insider or outsider? Exploring some digital challenges in ethnomusicology
(/isis/citation/CBB448654630/)
Article
Jacy L. Young;
(2020)
Thinking in Multitudes: Questionnaires and Composite Cases in Early American Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB385770594/)
Book
Colin Koopman;
(2019)
How We Became Our Data: A Genealogy of the Informational Person
(/isis/citation/CBB981384434/)
Article
Green, Christopher D.;
Feinerer, Ingo;
Burman, Jeremy T.;
(2014)
Beyond the Schools of Psychology 2: A Digital Analysis of Psychological Review, 1904--1923
(/isis/citation/CBB001420018/)
Article
Włodzimierz Gogołek;
(2017)
Refining Big Data
(/isis/citation/CBB158654943/)
Article
María Elissa Torres Carrasco;
(2022)
Neoconservative camouflage: The datafication of abortion debates in Ecuador
(/isis/citation/CBB507888120/)
Article
Fridolin Gross;
Nina Kranke;
Robert Meunier;
(2019)
Pluralization Through Epistemic Competition: Scientific Change in Times of Data-Intensive Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB374064986/)
Book
Silvia Casini;
(2021)
Giving Bodies Back to Data: Image Makers, Bricolage, and Reinvention in Magnetic Resonance Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB935991554/)
Book
Germaine Halegoua;
(2020)
Smart Cities
(/isis/citation/CBB219487083/)
Book
Daniel Kreiss;
(2016)
Prototype politics: Technology-intensive campaigning and the data of democracy
(/isis/citation/CBB572327913/)
Be the first to comment!