Leith, David (Author)
Technai, An International Journal for Ancient Science and Technology
Volume: 10
Pages: 69-89
Pliny the Elder’s evaluation of Asclepiades in his "Natural History" is one of the most commonly cited accounts of the Greek physician’s career and medical system. What Pliny says about Asclepiades’ approach to therapy in particular has had a huge impact on modern assessments, contributing directly to the picture of his pleasant forms of treatment, his use of five common remedies, as well as his alleged medical use of hypocaust-heated baths. Yet the evidence provided by more detailed and substantial accounts of Asclepiades’ therapeutics seems to contradict Pliny’s claims on numerous points. By comparing Celsus’ "De medicina," which Pliny used as a source, this paper argues that Pliny can be seen to be manipulating the information he read in highly misleading and selective ways, and accordingly that competing and contradictory accounts should be given more weight. This allows us to build up a much more accurate impression of Asclepiades’ therapeutics, which, we find, was not particularly pleasant at all, was not restricted in any meaningful way to five common remedies, and had no use for hypocaust-heated baths.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Ambra Serangeli;
(2022)
Asclepiade di Bitinia, Celio Aureliano e l'etica medica
(/isis/citation/CBB752238506/)
Article
Frederic Le Blay;
(2017)
La controverse de Galien contre Asclépiade et les Méthodiques: défendre l'utilité du médecin
(/isis/citation/CBB892048259/)
Article
Fabio Stok;
(2019)
Quando Asclepiade arrivò a Roma?
(/isis/citation/CBB067567897/)
Article
Chiara Thumiger;
(2019)
Asclepiades on Phrenitis and the Problem of Consistency (Caelius Aurelianus, Ac.Dis. 1.1, 14-15)
(/isis/citation/CBB325597394/)
Article
Ambra Serangeli;
(2019)
The Anti-teleologism of Asclepiades and Epicurus in Galen’s de usu partium
(/isis/citation/CBB933621108/)
Article
Daniele Monacchini;
(2012)
Plinio: alcune sostanze medicinali da minerali e pietre preziose
(/isis/citation/CBB869872384/)
Article
Livia Radici;
(2018)
Saliva, porpore e vino in Plinio
(/isis/citation/CBB089021241/)
Article
Jacques Jouanna;
(2017)
Hippocrate et la Polémique
(/isis/citation/CBB765483263/)
Article
Daniela Manetti;
(2019)
Un passo da Sul regime sano di Ateneo in Oribasio Coll. Libri inc. 39 (CMG VI 2.2, P. 138, 18 SS.)
(/isis/citation/CBB385407583/)
Article
Sabrina Grimaudo;
(2019)
Onkoi atomici? Ancora sulle particelle di Asclepiade di Bitinia
(/isis/citation/CBB627131071/)
Article
Philippe Mudry;
(2017)
La question des maladies nouvelles. Enquête médicale et sociétale dans le monde antique
(/isis/citation/CBB563238977/)
Article
Daniela Cavallo;
(2020)
"Trini colores, candidus primo, mox rubens, maturis niger" (Nat. 15, 97). Alberi, colori, medicina: Suggestioni dai libri 15 e 23 della Naturalis Historia di Plinio il Vecchio
(/isis/citation/CBB358631200/)
Article
Serena Buzzi;
(2019)
Farmaci tossici e rimedi contro i veleni nelle Eclogae dello Ps. Oribasio
(/isis/citation/CBB871879609/)
Book
Galen;
Vito Lorusso;
(2018)
Metodo terapeutico: Libri I-II
(/isis/citation/CBB008925942/)
Book
Francesco Lopez;
(2016)
Democede di Crotone e Udjahorresnet di Saïs: medici primari alla corte achemenide di Dario il Grande
(/isis/citation/CBB110188086/)
Article
Piergiorgio Parroni;
Eleonora Parroni;
(2012)
Celso, 2, 2-6 e Ippocrate: semeiotica di ieri e medicina di oggi
(/isis/citation/CBB439357004/)
Article
Philippe Mudry;
(2012)
Entre usage et raison. Remarques sur la médecine de Scribonius Largus
(/isis/citation/CBB949810007/)
Chapter
María Paz de Hoz;
(2014)
Lucian's Podagra, Asclepius and Galen. The Popularisation of Medicine in the Second Century AD
(/isis/citation/CBB170283387/)
Article
Jochen Althoff;
(2019)
Schriften und Schreiben in den ps.-hippokratischen Briefen, Reden und Dekreten
(/isis/citation/CBB538453863/)
Book
Isabella Andorlini;
Nicola Reggiani;
(2017)
Πολλὰ ἰατρῶν ἐστι συγγράμματα. Scritti sui papiri e la medicina antica
(/isis/citation/CBB888387770/)
Be the first to comment!