Article ID: CBB628337795

History as Science: The Fifteenth-Century Debate in Arabic and Persian (2017)


In the fifteenth century, scholars writing in Arabic and Persian debated the nature of historical inquiry and its place among the sciences. While the motivations and perspectives of the various scholars differed, the terms and parameters of the debate remained remarkably fixed and focused, even as it unfolded across a vast geographic space between Herat, Cairo, and Constantinople. This article examines the contours of this debate and the relationships between five historians working on these issues. Although the scholars who considered these questions frequently arrived at different conclusions, they all firmly agreed, in contrast to previous doubt regarding the status of history, that historical inquiry did indeed constitute a distinct science requiring its own particular method. Accordingly, the debate and its conclusions helped cement the place of history within the broader pantheon of the sciences as conceived by scholars in the Ottoman Empire from the sixteenth century onwards.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Giuseppina Ferriello; Romano Gatto; (2019)
Apollonius Mechanicus. Isfizārī's Persian Version of the Treatise On the Pulleys and Two Other Anonymous Persian Texts (/isis/citation/CBB878116297/) unapi

Article Sonja Brentjes; (2019)
Mathematical Commentaries in Arabic and Persian – Purposes, Forms, and Styles (/isis/citation/CBB154959746/) unapi

Article Martin Gansten; (2018)
Origins of the Tājika System of Astrological Aspects and Dignities (/isis/citation/CBB585200620/) unapi

Book Karen C. Pinto; (2016)
Medieval Islamic Maps: An Exploration (/isis/citation/CBB692641053/) unapi

Article Bernard R. Goldstein; José Chabás; (2015)
Three Tables for the Daily Positions of the Moon in a Fifteenth-Century Hebrew Manuscript (/isis/citation/CBB573887033/) unapi

Article Sonja Brentjes; (2019)
MS Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, codex arab. 2697 and its Properties (/isis/citation/CBB635794308/) unapi

Article Marie-Laure Monfort; (2020)
La paraphrase d'une traduction arabo-latine du De aere, aquis, locis publiée par Jacques Bogard (/isis/citation/CBB925543561/) unapi

Article Matteo Martelli; (2017)
Translating Ancient Alchemy: Fragments of Graeco-Egyptian Alchemy in Arabic Compendia (/isis/citation/CBB877431174/) unapi

Book Lucia Raggetti; (2021)
Un coniglio nel turbante. Intrattenimento e inganno nella scienza arabo-islamica (/isis/citation/CBB200403706/) unapi

Book French, Sara L.; Etheridge, Kay; (2007)
Origins of Science Learning: Essays on Culture and Knowledge in Early Modern Europe (/isis/citation/CBB000830144/) unapi

Chapter Maria Pia Donato; (2012)
Anatomia, autopsia, sectio: problemi di fonti e di metodo (/isis/citation/CBB267957700/) unapi

Book Maxwell-Stuart, P. G.; (2011)
Witch Beliefs and Witch Trials in the Middle Ages: Documents and Readings (/isis/citation/CBB001200665/) unapi

Book Koslofsky, Craig; (2011)
Evening's Empire: A History of the Night in Early Modern Europe (/isis/citation/CBB001201831/) unapi

Article C. Philipp E. Nothaft; (2017)
Zaccaria Lilio and the Shape of the Earth: A Brief Response to Allegro’s “Flat Earth Science” (/isis/citation/CBB359152397/) unapi

Book Angelo Cattaneo; Francisco Contente Domingues; (2018)
Shores of Vespucci: A Historical Research of Amerigo Vespucci's Life and Contexts (/isis/citation/CBB640429234/) unapi

Article Svanberg, Ingvar; Cios, Stanislaw; (2014)
Petrus Magni and the History of Fresh-Water Aquaculture in the Later Middle Ages (/isis/citation/CBB001321127/) unapi

Article Robin, Diana; (2013)
Women on the Move: Trends in Anglophone Studies of Women in the Italian Renaissance (/isis/citation/CBB001320631/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
Brentjes, Sonja
Lévy, Tony
French, Sara L.
Etheridge, Kay
Seitz, Jonathan
Maxwell-Stuart, Peter G.
Micrologus: Nature, Sciences and Medieval Societies
Arabic Sciences and Philosophy
I Tatti Studies: Essays in the Renaissance
Archives of Natural History
Historia Mathematica
History of Science
Edwin Mellen Press
Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
Cambridge University Press
Editrice Bibliografica
Peter Lang
Arabic language
Science and culture
Science and religion
Persian language
Magni, Petrus
Strumieński, Olbrycht
Dubravius, Jan
Vespucci, Amerigo
Rhine River
15th century
16th century
17th century
14th century

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment