The “General Problem Solver” Does Not Exist: Mortimer Taube and the Art of AI Criticism (January-March 2021)
Shunryu Colin Garvey (Author)
IEEE Annals of the History of Computing
Volume: 43
Issue: 1
Pages: 60-73
This article reconfigures the history of artificial intelligence (AI) and its accompanying tradition of criticism by excavating the work of Mortimer Taube, a pioneer in information and library sciences, whose magnum opus, Computers and Common Sense: The Myth of Thinking Machines (1961), has been mostly forgotten. To convey the essence of his distinctive critique, the article focuses on Taube's attack on the general problem solver (GPS), the second major AI program. After examining his analysis of the social construction of this and other “thinking machines,” it concludes that, despite technical changes in AI, much of Taube's criticism remains relevant today. Moreover, his status as an “information processing” insider who criticized AI on behalf of the public good challenges the boundaries and focus of most critiques of AI from the past half-century. In sum, Taube's work offers an alternative model from which contemporary AI workers and critics can learn much.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Colin Garvey;
(March 2018)
Broken Promises & Empty Threats: The Evolution of AI in the USA, 1956–1996
(/isis/citation/CBB517134330/)
Article
Devin Kennedy;
Gerardo Con Diaz;
(April-June 2021)
Computing Capitalisms—Part 2
(/isis/citation/CBB378297576/)
Article
Nathan Ensmenger;
(October 2018)
The Environmental History of Computing
(/isis/citation/CBB959146795/)
Article
Heyck, Hunter;
(2008)
Defining the Computer: Herbert Simon and the Bureaucratic Mind--Part 1
(/isis/citation/CBB000850263/)
Thesis
Kum Hee Choy;
(2021)
Neuro Symbolic Artificial Intelligence Pioneer to Overcome the Limits of Machine Learn
(/isis/citation/CBB355588382/)
Book
Taina Bucher;
(2018)
If ... then: algorithmic power and politics
(/isis/citation/CBB014118736/)
Article
Yost, Jeffrey R.;
(2016)
Computer Security, Part 2 -- Editor's Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB453922047/)
Book
Luc Olivier;
E Marshall Wilder;
(2020)
The microchip revolution: A brief history
(/isis/citation/CBB701316898/)
Article
Janet Abbate;
(October 2018)
Code Switch: Alternative Visions of Computer Expertise as Empowerment from the 1960s to the 2010s
(/isis/citation/CBB903684763/)
Thesis
Stephanie Aleen Dick;
(2015)
After Math (Re)configuring Minds, Proof, and Computing in the Postwar United States
(/isis/citation/CBB626730167/)
Thesis
Evan Donahue;
(2021)
Android Linguistics: How Machines Do Things with Words
(/isis/citation/CBB971642341/)
Book
Hagengruber, Ruth;
Riss, Uwe V.;
(2014)
Philosophy, Computing and Information Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001422489/)
Article
Honghong Tinn;
(October 2018)
Modeling Computers and Computer Models: Manufacturing Economic-Planning Projects in Cold War Taiwan, 1959–1968
(/isis/citation/CBB062296277/)
Article
Theodora Vardouli;
David Theodore;
(April-June 2021)
Walking Instead of Working: Space Allocation, Automatic Architecture, and the Abstraction of Hospital Labor
(/isis/citation/CBB134939420/)
Article
Guy C. Fedorkow;
(January-March 2021)
Recovering Software for the Whirlwind Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB869829437/)
Article
Janet Toland;
(April-June 2021)
Consortium Computing and Time Slicing in the Banking Sector: Databank Systems Ltd New Zealand
(/isis/citation/CBB565212269/)
Article
Rudolf Seising;
(2023)
KI – Kapriolende Intelligenz – Kapriolende Information (AI - Capricious Intelligence - Capricious Information)
(/isis/citation/CBB928523961/)
Chapter
Babintseva, Ekaterina Igorevna;
(2022)
Engineering the Lay Mind: Lev Landa's Algo-Heuristic Theory and Artificial Intelligence
(/isis/citation/CBB540785696/)
Article
Moa Carlsson;
(April 2022)
Computing views, remodeling environments
(/isis/citation/CBB726932342/)
Chapter
Nicoletta Sabadini;
Filippo Schiavio;
(2016)
Da Turing all'ipercomputazione: un approccio algebrico all'interazione tra sistemi aperti
(/isis/citation/CBB968632247/)
Be the first to comment!