The Biomedicalization of Social Egg Freezing: A Comparative Analysis of European and American Professional Ethics Opinions and US News and Popular Media (September 2018)
Bhatia, Rajani (Author)
Campo-Engelstein, Lisa (Author)
Science, Technology and Human Values
Volume: 43
Issue: 5
Pages: 864-887
In 2012, two major professional societies representing Europe and the United States released influential statements that would propel a commercial market for social egg freezing (SEF), in which women bank their oocytes for later use in order to avoid compromised fertility that comes with age. While the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) condoned SEF based on reproductive autonomy and justice, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) discouraged SEF based on insufficient data and concerns about false hope. In this article, we map the contexts and discursive moves by which the biomedicalization of SEF proceeded since 2012. We compare professional bioethical arguments that made the case to approve SEF in Europe with news and popular media discourse that formed and shaped the commercial marketization of SEF in the United States despite the recommendation of the ASRM. While a statist pronatalist perspective informed the former, a distinctly private labor market recruitment strategy utilizing a Lean In efficiency model of feminism buttressed the latter.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sleeboom-Faulkner, Margaret;
Kumar Patra, Prasanna;
(October 2011)
Experimental stem cell therapy: Biohierarchies and bionetworking in Japan and India
(/isis/citation/CBB894423626/)
Book
O'Neill, Onora;
(2002)
Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics
(/isis/citation/CBB000771273/)
Article
Smart, Andrew;
Martin, Paul;
(2006)
The Promise of Pharmacogenetics: Assessing the Prospects for Disease and Patient Stratification
(/isis/citation/CBB000770743/)
Article
Strasser, Bruno J.;
(2011)
The Experimenter's Museum: GenBank, Natural History, and the Moral Economies of Biomedicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001022861/)
Article
Hedgecoe, Adam M.;
(2006)
Context, Ethics and Pharmacogenetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000770742/)
Article
Martyn Pickersgill;
(August 2019)
Access, accountability, and the proliferation of psychological therapy: On the introduction of the IAPT initiative and the transformation of mental healthcare
(/isis/citation/CBB273628370/)
Article
Bronwyn Parry;
(January 2018)
The Social Life of “Scaffolds” Examining Human Rights in Regenerative Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB220784562/)
Book
Ana Barahona;
(2022)
Handbook of the Historiography of Latin American Studies on the Life Sciences and Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB503638807/)
Article
Anne Kerr;
Tineke Broer;
Emily Ross;
Sarah Cunningham Burley;
(August 2019)
Polygenic risk-stratified screening for cancer: Responsibilization in public health genomics
(/isis/citation/CBB774833590/)
Article
Shirley Sun;
Ann Hui Ching;
(2021)
Social Systems Matter: Precision Medicine, Public Health, and the Medical Model
(/isis/citation/CBB879164513/)
Article
Chia-Ling Wu;
Jung-Ok Ha;
Azumi Tsuge;
(March 2020)
Data Reporting as Care Infrastructure: Assembling ART Registries in Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB772486717/)
Article
Anna Molas;
Laura Perler;
(2020)
Selecting women, taming bodies? Body ontologies in egg donation practices in Spain
(/isis/citation/CBB375247286/)
Article
Brian Salter;
Yinhua Zhou;
Saheli Datta;
Charlotte Salter;
(September 2016)
Bioinformatics and the Politics of Innovation in the Life Sciences: Science and the State in the United Kingdom, China, and India
(/isis/citation/CBB590127808/)
Thesis
Hurlbut, James Benjamin;
(2010)
Experiments in Democracy: The Science, Politics and Ethics of Human Embryo Research in the United States, 1978--2007
(/isis/citation/CBB001561039/)
Book
Ploeg, Irma van der;
(2002)
Prosthetic Bodies: The Construction of the Fetus and the Couple as Patients in Reproductive Technologies
(/isis/citation/CBB000302033/)
Article
Machado, Carlos José Saldanha;
Filipecki, Ana Tereza Pinto;
Teixeira, Márcia de Oliveira;
Klein, Helena Espellet;
(2010)
A regulação do uso de animais no Brasil do século XX e o processo de formação do atual regime aplicado à pesquisa biomédica
(/isis/citation/CBB001420444/)
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2013)
Human Being @ Risk: Enhancement, Technology, and the Evaluation of Vulnerability Transformations
(/isis/citation/CBB944837263/)
Book
Tim Lewens;
(2015)
The Biological Foundations of Bioethics
(/isis/citation/CBB452000216/)
Book
Lester D. Friedman;
Therese Jones;
Delese Wear;
(2014)
Health Humanities Reader
(/isis/citation/CBB432677381/)
Article
Sarah Franklin;
(2019)
Developmental Landmarks and the Warnock Report: A Sociological Account of Biological Translation
(/isis/citation/CBB966472875/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Science, Technology and Human Values
East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An International Journal
Tapuya: Latin American Science, Technology and Society
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Be the first to comment!