In late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Germany, the integration of product-evaluating certificates and reports (Gutachten) into advertisements triggered repeated condemnations of “advertisement-Gutachten” (Reklamegutachten), and scientists and science administrators introduced various restrictions to prevent the appearance of such documents. At the same time, the provision of Gutachten to private individuals and firms seemed crucial to the success of many private and public laboratories. Some chemical and other professionals, moreover, argued that the authoring and use of Reklamegutachten could represent a “scientific” and, therefore, ethical practice. By examining the contested history of the advertisement-Gutachten, this article reveals how a previously tolerated knowledge service lost its legitimacy in a particular place and period of time, and highlights the challenges of eliminating this practice or restoring its legitimacy afterward. The article also explores how professional scientists’ approaches to maintaining a reputation for integrity in the face of commercial and competitive pressures related to the better-known efforts of professionals in other fields, particularly the medical. I emphasize that, in determining whether a Gutachten qualified as scientific, the nature and transparency of the underlying research process was only one of the criteria that were considered, and often not the most significant yardstick. At the same time, however, ideas about the personal and professional/institutional integrity of providers of Gutachten were inextricably connected with assessments of the honesty and objectivity of their research.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Thoms, Ulrike;
(2013)
Standardizing Selling. Pharmaceutical Marketing, the Pharmaceutical Company and the Marketing Expert (1900--1980)
(/isis/citation/CBB001320755/)
Article
Ott, Daniel;
(2014)
Producing a Past: McCormick Harvester and Producer Populists in the 1890s
(/isis/citation/CBB001320831/)
Article
Bonah, Christian;
(2013)
“The Strophanthin Question”: Early Scientific Marketing of Cardiac Drugs in Two National Markets (France and Germany, 1900--1930).
(/isis/citation/CBB001320753/)
Book
Jones, Claire;
(2013)
The Medical Trade Catalogue in Britain, 1870--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001202367/)
Book
Goschler, Constantin;
(2000)
Wissenschaft und Öffentlichkeit in Berlin, 1870-1930
(/isis/citation/CBB000110622/)
Article
Gaudillière, Jean-Paul;
(2013)
From Propaganda to Scientific Marketing: Schering, Cortisone, and the Construction of Drug Markets
(/isis/citation/CBB001320756/)
Article
Reuben Message;
(2019)
“The Disadvantages of a Defective Education”: Identity, Experiment and Persuasion in the Natural History of the Salmon and Parr Controversy, C. 1825–1850
(/isis/citation/CBB163742684/)
Book
Waits, Robert K.;
(2013)
The Medical Electricians: George A. Scott and His Victorian Cohorts in Quackery
(/isis/citation/CBB001551885/)
Article
Ganaway, Bryan;
(2008-9)
Engineers or Artists? Toys, Class and Technology in Wilhelmine Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB001032585/)
Book
Wigelsworth, Jeffrey R.;
(2010)
Selling Science in the Age of Newton: Advertising and the Commoditization of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001021580/)
Book
Blaszczyk, Regina Lee;
(2009)
American Consumer Society, 1865--2005: From Hearth to HDTV
(/isis/citation/CBB001201132/)
Article
Fincham, Jack E.;
(2010)
Marketing of Patent Medicines in the Nineteenth Century via a Corkscrew Medicine Spoon
(/isis/citation/CBB001000209/)
Book
Dunne, Matthew W.;
(2013)
A Cold War State of Mind: Brainwashing and Postwar American Society
(/isis/citation/CBB001202369/)
Thesis
Hansen, Andrew Christopher;
(2002)
Countenancing Science: Studies in the Public Image and Cultural Ascendence of the Victorian Scientist
(/isis/citation/CBB001562494/)
Article
Kidd, Ian James;
(2014)
Was Sir William Crookes Epistemically Virtuous?
(/isis/citation/CBB001421656/)
Book
Sakurai, Ayako;
(2013)
Science and Societies in Frankfurt am Main
(/isis/citation/CBB001451366/)
Article
Dodds, Rachel E.;
Tseëlon, Efrat;
Weitkamp, Emma L. C.;
(2008)
Making Sense of Scientific Claims in Advertising. A Study of Scientifically Aware Consumers
(/isis/citation/CBB000831219/)
Article
Sara Spike;
(2020)
Mayflowers and Sleeping Johnnies: Nature-Study, Local Knowledge, and A. H. MacKay’s Phenological Research in Rural Nova Scotia, 1892-1925
(/isis/citation/CBB173073577/)
Article
González-Silva, Matiana;
Herran, Néstor;
(2009)
Ideology, Elitism and Social Commitment: Alternative Images of Science in Two fin de siècle Barcelona Newspapers
(/isis/citation/CBB000932326/)
Book
Lavine, Matthew;
(2013)
The First Atomic Age: Scientists, Radiations, and the American Public, 1895--1945
(/isis/citation/CBB001213740/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Scientia Canadensis: Journal of the History of Canadian Science, Technology, and Medicine
Science in Context
Public Understanding of Science
Pharmacy in History
Be the first to comment!