Article ID: CBB619372597

Lead Poisoning in France around 1840: Managing Proofs and Uncertainties in Laboratories, Courtrooms, and Workplaces (2021)

unapi

This article reviews one of the most famous cases of lead poisoning in France, the Ponchon affair, which occurred in 1843 during a crucial period for French toxicology. The trial attracted public attention and inflamed controversy among medical and legal experts. The debate involved toxicological methods and their reliability, and gave rise to more general questions about the value of expert evidence, the way it was presented in court, and its relationship to other forms of legal evidence. I begin with a general overview of lead poisoning and toxicological research on lead compounds around 1840. I then discuss different toxicological proofs employed for detecting or preventing lead poisoning and examine as well growing uncertainties about them. A review of several trials related to lead poisoning in workplaces around 1840 introduces the Ponchon affair. Here I present the experts involved in the trial and describe their strategies for presenting and managing proofs and uncertainties. Finally, I summarise the controversy aroused by the trial in medical and legal communities as it relates to the value of jury trials in cases of poisoning, the risks of using too much chemistry in judicial inquiries, and the different proposals for managing uncertainties and disagreements among experts.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB619372597/

Similar Citations

Article E. Claire Cage; (2019)
Child Sexual Abuse and Medical Expertise in Nineteenth-Century France (/isis/citation/CBB516319186/)

Book José Ramón Bertomeu Sánchez; (2019)
¿Entre el fiscal y el verdugo?: Mateu Orfila i Rotger (1787-1853) y la toxicología del siglo XIX (/isis/citation/CBB107113642/)

Article Dan Degerman; (2019)
‘Am I mad?’: the Windham case and Victorian resistance to psychiatry (/isis/citation/CBB373188237/)

Article David Rosner; (2017)
Trying Times: The Courts, the Historian, and the Contentious Struggle to Define Disease (/isis/citation/CBB735952192/)

Article Sheldon Krimsky; (November 2015)
An Illusory Consensus behind GMO Health Assessment (/isis/citation/CBB119149138/)

Book Ryosuke Yokoe; (2023)
Alcohol and Liver Cirrhosis in Twentieth-Century Britain (/isis/citation/CBB493941528/)

Book Emsley, John; (2008)
Molecules of Murder: Criminal Molecules and Classic Cases (/isis/citation/CBB001021072/)

Article Tweedale, Geoffrey; McCulloch, Jock; (2004)
Chrysophiles versus Chrysophobes: The White Asbestos Controversy, 1950s--2004 (/isis/citation/CBB000470999/)

Article Douglas H. L. Brown; David R. Green; Kathleen McIlvenna; Nicola Shelton; (2020)
The beating heart of the system: The health of postal workers in Victorian London (/isis/citation/CBB167112892/)

Book Heather Wolffram; (2018)
Forensic Psychology in Germany: Witnessing Crime, 1880-1939 (/isis/citation/CBB886091707/)

Chapter Morantz-Sanchez, Regina; (2009)
Female Patient Agency and the 1892 Trial of Dr. Mary Dixon Jones in Late Nineteenth-Century Brooklyn (/isis/citation/CBB001031388/)

Book Alissa Cordner; (2016)
Toxic Safety: Flame Retardants, Chemical Controversies, and Environmental Health (/isis/citation/CBB367225101/)

Book Burney, Ian; (2006)
Poison, Detection, and the Victorian Imagination (/isis/citation/CBB000772050/)

Book George E. Smith; Raghav Seth; (2020)
Brownian Motion and Molecular Reality (/isis/citation/CBB800777900/)

Article Christen, Arden G.; Christen, Joan A.; (2003)
The 1850 Webster/Parkman Trial: Dr. Keep's Forensic Evidence (/isis/citation/CBB000932356/)

Authors & Contributors
Degerman, Dan
Marcus B. Carrier
Berry, Chelsea
Ryosuke Yokoe
McIlvenna, Kathleen
Cordner, Alissa
Concepts
Trials (law)
Medicine and law
Poisoning
Controversies and disputes
Expertise
Toxicology
Time Periods
19th century
21st century
20th century, early
20th century, late
20th century
18th century
Places
United States
France
Germany
England
Boston (Massachusetts, U.S.)
London (England)
Institutions
Harvard University
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment