IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB614136192

The Making of Evident Expertise: Transforming Chemical Analytical Methods into Judicial Evidence (2021)

Marcus B. Carrier (Author)

NTM: Zeitschrift für Geschichte der Naturwissenschaften, Technik und Medizin
Volume: 29
Issue: 3
Pages: 261-284

URI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00048-021-00306-7

DOI: 10.1007/s00048-021-00306-7

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Expertise Expert testimony Visual representation; visual communication Poisoning Authority of science Forensic sciences Trials (law) 19th century

This article investigates the question of how forensic toxicologists established the credibility of chemical analytical methods in poisoning lawsuits in the nineteenth century. After encountering the problem of laypersons in court, forensic toxicologists attempted to find strategies to make their evidence compelling to an untrained audience. Three of these strategies are discussed here: redundancy, standard methods, and intuitive comprehensibility. Whereas redundancy was not very practical and legally prescribed standard methods were not very popular with most forensic toxicologists, intuitive comprehensibility proved effective and popular. This strategy relied on employing methods which did not require chemical knowledge to be understandable. The methods aimed to generate a visual aid and to be obvious in their results. Two forms of this strategy are discussed here: the presentation of the actual material and explicit comparison. I argue that this shift towards presenting forensic toxicology expertise as evident represents an important step in the history of forensic expertise.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB614136192/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Mar Cuenca-Lorente; (2017)
Poisons, Trials and Experts: Pere Mata I Fontanet (1811–1877) and Spanish Nineteenth-Century Toxicology (/isis/citation/CBB713181362/)

Book Emsley, John; (2008)
Molecules of Murder: Criminal Molecules and Classic Cases (/isis/citation/CBB001021072/)

Book José Ramón Bertomeu Sánchez; (2019)
¿Entre el fiscal y el verdugo?: Mateu Orfila i Rotger (1787-1853) y la toxicología del siglo XIX (/isis/citation/CBB107113642/)

Article Federico Brandmayr; (May 2017)
How Social Scientists Make Causal Claims in Court: Evidence from the L’Aquila Trial (/isis/citation/CBB603433424/)

Book Alexa Geisthövel; Volker Hess; (2017)
Medizinisches Gutachten: Geschichte einer neuzeitlichen Praxis (/isis/citation/CBB228276706/)

Book Haber, Carole; (2013)
The Trials of Laura Fair: Sex, Murder, and Insanity in the Victorian West (/isis/citation/CBB001420198/)

Article Watson, Katherine D.; (2006)
Medical and Chemical Expertise in English Trials for Criminal Poisoning, 1750--1914 (/isis/citation/CBB000773961/)

Article Dan Degerman; (2019)
‘Am I mad?’: the Windham case and Victorian resistance to psychiatry (/isis/citation/CBB373188237/)

Thesis Chelsea L. Berry; (2019)
Poisoned Relations: Medicine, Sorcery, and Poison Trials in the Contested Atlantic, 1680-1850 (/isis/citation/CBB410055828/)

Book Buckingham, John; (2008)
Bitter Nemesis: The Intimate History of Strychnine (/isis/citation/CBB001021070/)

Article José Ramón Bertomeu Sánchez; (2021)
Lead Poisoning in France around 1840: Managing Proofs and Uncertainties in Laboratories, Courtrooms, and Workplaces (/isis/citation/CBB619372597/)

Article E. Claire Cage; (2019)
Child Sexual Abuse and Medical Expertise in Nineteenth-Century France (/isis/citation/CBB516319186/)

Article Bertomeu-Sánchez, José Ramón; (2013)
Managing Uncertainty in the Academy and the Courtroom: Normal Arsenic and Nineteenth-Century Toxicology (/isis/citation/CBB001320189/)

Book Joris Vandendriessche; Evert Peeters; Kaat Wils; (2015)
Scientists' Expertise as Performance: Between State and Society, 1860–1960 (/isis/citation/CBB826263249/)

Article Winter, Alison; (2007)
A Forensics of the Mind (/isis/citation/CBB000772263/)

Book Timo Bolt; Jacomien Gijzeman; Joost Vijselaar; (2019)
Ter observatie opgenomen. Pieter Baan Centrum 1949-2019 [Admitted for observation: Pieter Baan Center 1949-2019] (/isis/citation/CBB526540851/)

Article STEFAN WULF; (2020)
„Schlagt das Hitlerei zu Brei.“: Politische Strafsachen, Psychopathie und verminderte Zurechnungsfähigkeit im Spiegel psychiatrischer Gutachten Albrecht Langelüddekes, 1937–1945 (/isis/citation/CBB882055559/)

Article Stuart Kirsch; (2022)
Scientific Ghostwriting in the Amazon? The Role of Experts in the Lawsuit against Chevron in Ecuador (/isis/citation/CBB754705265/)

Article Ingrid G. Farreras; (2019)
The professionalization of psychologists as court personnel: Consequences of the first institutional commitment law for the “feebleminded” (/isis/citation/CBB969643572/)

Article M'charek, Amade; Hagendijk, Rob; Vries, Wiebe de; (2013)
Equal before the Law: On the Machinery of Sameness in Forensic DNA Practice (/isis/citation/CBB001320664/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}