Between Instinct and Intelligence: Harnessing Police Dog Agency in Early Twentieth-Century Paris (2016)
Pearson, Chris (Author)
Comparative Studies in Society and History
Volume: 58
Issue: 2
Pages: 463-490
This article analyzes the introduction of police dogs in early twentieth-century Paris, which formed part of the transnational extension of police powers and their specialization. Within a context of widespread fears of crime and new and contested understandings of animal psychology, police officers, journalists, and canophiles promoted the dogs as inexpensive yet effective agents who could help the police contain the threat posed by criminals. This article responds to a growing number of studies on nonhuman agency by examining how humans in a particular place and time conceptualized and harnessed animal abilities. I argue that while nonhuman agency is an illuminating and important analytical tool, there is a danger that it might become monolithic and static. With these concerns in mind, I show how examining historical actors' conceptualizations of animal abilities takes us closer to the historical stakes and complexities of mobilizing purposeful and capable animals, and provides a better understanding of the constraints within which animals act. Attitudes toward police dogs were entwined with broader discussions of human and animal intelligence. Concerns that dogs' abilities and intelligence were contingent and potentially reversible qualities resembled contemporary biomedical fears that base instincts, desires, and impulses could overwhelm human intelligence and morality, resulting in individual and collective degeneration. To many, it seemed that police dogs' intelligence had not tamed their aggressive instincts, and these worries partly explain the demise of the first wave of police dogs in Paris after World War I.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Pearson, Chris;
(2013)
Dogs, History, and Agency
(/isis/citation/CBB001202107/)
Article
Chris Pearson;
(2019)
Combating Canine ‘Visiting Cards’: Public Hygiene and the Management of Dog Mess in Paris since the 1920s
(/isis/citation/CBB153798613/)
Book
Essig, Mark Regan;
(2003)
Edison and the Electric Chair: A Story of Light and Death
(/isis/citation/CBB000450004/)
Chapter
Daston, Lorraine;
(2005)
Intelligences: Angelic, Animal, Human
(/isis/citation/CBB000772878/)
Book
Fudge, Erica;
(2006)
Brutal Reasoning: Animals, Rationality, and Humanity in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB000742134/)
Book
Mary R. Tahan;
(2019)
Roald Amundsen’s Sled Dogs: The Sledge Dogs Who Helped Discover the South Pole
(/isis/citation/CBB315812764/)
Book
Jessica Wang;
(2019)
Mad Dogs and Other New Yorkers: Rabies, Medicine, and Society in an American Metropolis, 1840–1920
(/isis/citation/CBB967635848/)
Book
Ann-Janine Morey;
(2014)
Picturing Dogs, Seeing Ourselves: Vintage American Photographs
(/isis/citation/CBB818895674/)
Article
Pettit, Michael;
(2010)
The Problem of Raccoon Intelligence in Behaviourist America
(/isis/citation/CBB001023005/)
Article
Andrea Graus;
(2021)
Child prodigies in Paris in the belle époque: Between child stars and psychological subjects
(/isis/citation/CBB328653193/)
Article
Marion Thomas;
(2016)
Between biomedical and psychological experiments: The unexpected connections between the Pasteur Institutes and the study of animal mind in the second quarter of twentieth-century France
(/isis/citation/CBB003898443/)
Article
Daniel Gethmann;
(2020)
Levels of communication: The talking horse experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB085423128/)
Thesis
Elizabeth A. McNeill;
(2022)
Speaking of Animals: Animal Psychology between Experimental Science and Imagination (1840-1920)
(/isis/citation/CBB890315766/)
Thesis
Booth, Kelvin Jay;
(2007)
Animal Mind, Human Mind: George H. Mead, Animality and the Evolution of Embodied Cognition
(/isis/citation/CBB001561432/)
Article
Rémy, Catherine;
(2014)
“Men Seeking Monkey-Glands”: The Controversial Xenotransplantations of Doctor Voronoff, 1910--30
(/isis/citation/CBB001201418/)
Thesis
Brantz, Ingeborg-Dorothee;
(2003)
Slaughter in the City: The Establishment of Public Abattoirs in Paris and Berlin, 1780--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001560603/)
Article
Pemberton, Neil;
(2013)
The Bloodhound's Nose Knows? Dogs and Detection in Anglo-American Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB001213635/)
Book
Quinlan, Andrea;
(2017)
The Technoscientific Witness of Rape: Contentious Histories of Law, Feminism, and Forensic Science
(/isis/citation/CBB899827260/)
Article
Robert G. W. Kirk;
Edmund Ramsden;
(2021)
"Havens of mercy”: health, medical research, and the governance of the movement of dogs in twentieth-century America
(/isis/citation/CBB713465624/)
Book
Richard C. Francis;
(2016)
Domesticated: Evolution in a Man-Made World
(/isis/citation/CBB452049535/)
Be the first to comment!