The problem of epistemic jurisdiction in global governance: The case of sustainability standards for biofuels (February 2017)
Winickoff, David E (Author)
Matthieu Mondou (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 47
Issue: 1
Pages: 7-32
While there is ample scholarly work on regulatory science within the state, or single-sited global institutions, there is less on its operation within complex modes of global governance that are decentered, overlapping, multi-sectorial and multi-leveled. Using a co-productionist framework, this study identifies ‘epistemic jurisdiction’ – the power to produce or warrant technical knowledge for a given political community, topical arena or geographical territory – as a central problem for regulatory science in complex governance. We explore these dynamics in the arena of global sustainability standards for biofuels. We select three institutional fora as sites of inquiry: the European Union’s Renewable Energy Directive, the Roundtable on Sustainable Biomaterials, and the International Organization for Standardization. These cases allow us to analyze how the co-production of sustainability science responds to problems of epistemic jurisdiction in the global regulatory order. First, different problems of epistemic jurisdiction beset different standard-setting bodies, and these problems shape both the content of regulatory science and the procedures designed to make it authoritative. Second, in order to produce global regulatory science, technical bodies must manage an array of conflicting imperatives – including scientific virtue, due process and the need to recruit adoptees to perpetuate the standard. At different levels of governance, standard drafters struggle to balance loyalties to country, to company or constituency and to the larger project of internationalization. Confronted with these sometimes conflicting pressures, actors across the standards system quite self-consciously maneuver to build or retain authority for their forum through a combination of scientific adjustment and political negotiation. Third, the evidentiary demands of regulatory science in global administrative spaces are deeply affected by 1) a market for standards, in which firms and states can choose the cheapest sustainability certification, and 2) the international trade regime, in which the long shadow of WTO law exerts a powerful disciplining function.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sarah Mittlefehldt;
(October 2018)
Wood Waste and Race: The Industrialization of Biomass Energy Technologies and Environmental Justice
(/isis/citation/CBB645664021/)
Article
Poonam Pandey;
Govert Valkenburg;
Annapurna Mamidipudi;
Wiebe E. Bijker;
(2021)
“All We Want, Is to Get Rid of the Straw”: How Biofuel Policies Need to Be Multiple
(/isis/citation/CBB841746332/)
Article
Ximo Guillem-Llobat;
(2019)
Following Hydrogen Cyanide in the Valencian Country (1907-1933): Risk, Accidents and Standards in Fumigation
(/isis/citation/CBB080728308/)
Article
Deutsch, Donald R.;
(2013)
The SQL StandarD: How it Happened
(/isis/citation/CBB001320347/)
Article
Cambrosio, Alberto;
Keating, Peter;
Schlich, Thomas;
Weisz, George;
(2009)
Biomedical Conventions and Regulatory Objectivity: A Few Introductory Remarks
(/isis/citation/CBB000953577/)
Book
Obach, Brian K.;
(2015)
Organic Struggle: The Movement for Sustainable Agriculture in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB747820136/)
Article
Xaq Frohlich;
(April 2017)
The informational turn in food politics: The US FDA’s nutrition label as information infrastructure
(/isis/citation/CBB818928934/)
Article
Anderson, Stuart;
(2008)
From “Bespoke” to “Off-the-Peg”: Community Pharmacists and the Retailing of Medicines in Great Britain 1900 to 1970
(/isis/citation/CBB000932017/)
Article
Krebs, Stefan;
(2012)
Standardizing Car Sound---Integrating Europe? International Traffic Noise Abatement and the Emergence of a European Car Identity, 1950--1975
(/isis/citation/CBB001210227/)
Article
Hüntelmann, Axel C.;
(2008)
The Dynamics of Wertbestimmung
(/isis/citation/CBB000831748/)
Thesis
Downer, John Richard;
(2006)
The Burden of Proof: Regulating Reliability in Civil Aviation
(/isis/citation/CBB001561438/)
Article
Schettino, Edvige;
(2004)
L'Italia e la Convenzione del metro: negoziazioni tecniche, scientifiche, legislative
(/isis/citation/CBB000630834/)
Chapter
Rutty, Christopher J.;
(2008)
Canadian Vaccine Research, Production and International Regulation: Connaught Laboratories and Smallpox Vaccines, 1962--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB000760345/)
Article
McElvenny, James;
(2013)
International Language and the Everyday: Contact and Collaboration Between C.K. Ogden, Rudolf Carnap and Otto Neurath
(/isis/citation/CBB001320857/)
Article
Lobachev, Sergey;
(2013)
Inspecting Hospitals in the Russian Empire: Dr. John Harry's Account, 1805--1806
(/isis/citation/CBB001213550/)
Article
Moguen-Toursel, Marine;
(2007)
Emergence and Transfer of Vehicle Safety Standards: Why We Still Do Not Have Global Standards
(/isis/citation/CBB001211718/)
Article
Gachelin, Gabriel;
(2007)
The Designing of Anti-Diphtheria Serotherapy at the Institut Pasteur (1888--1900): The Role of a Supranational Network of Microbiologists
(/isis/citation/CBB000820145/)
Article
Dubinko, Yu. S.;
Kuskov, V. D.;
Mordvinov, B. G.;
Novikova, E. L.;
Panteleev, V. M.;
(2012)
The Global Navigation Satellite System (GLONASS): Episodes from the History of Its Design and Development
(/isis/citation/CBB001211416/)
Article
Lagendijk, Vincent;
(2011)
“An Experience Forgotten Today”: Examining Two Rounds of European Electricity Liberalization
(/isis/citation/CBB001210209/)
Article
Montefrio, Marvin Joseph F.;
(2012)
Privileged Biofuels, Marginalized Indigenous Peoples: The Coevolution of Biofuels Development in the Tropics
(/isis/citation/CBB001210553/)
Be the first to comment!