Meier, Lukas J. (Author)
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Volume: 73
Issue: 2
Pages: 487-508
Fifty years have passed since brain death was first proposed as a criterion of death. Its advocates believe that with the destruction of the brain, integrated functioning ceases irreversibly, somatic unity dissolves, and the organism turns into a corpse. In this article, I put forward two objections against this assertion. First, I draw parallels between brain death and other pathological conditions and argue that whenever one regards the absence or the artificial replacement of a certain function in these pathological conditions as compatible with organismic unity, then one equally ought to tolerate that function’s loss or replacement in brain death. Second, I show that the neurological criterion faces an additional problem that is only coming to light as life-supporting technology improves: the growing sophistication of the latter gives rise to a dangerous decoupling of the actual performance of a vital function from the retention of neurological control over it. Half a century after its introduction, the neurological criterion is facing the same fate as its cardiopulmonary predecessor.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Michael Nair-Collins;
(2022)
Expanding the Social Status of “Corpse” to the Severely Comatose: Henry Beecher and the Harvard Brain Death Committee
(/isis/citation/CBB803947711/)
Article
Chiara Carboni;
Rik Wehrens;
Romke van der Veen;
Antoinette de Bont;
(2023)
Eye for an AI: More-than-seeing, fauxtomation, and the enactment of uncertain data in digital pathology
(/isis/citation/CBB216179221/)
Book
Andrew S. Lea;
(2023)
Digitizing Diagnosis: Medicine, Minds, and Machines in Twentieth-Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB292062397/)
Article
Matherne, Samantha;
(2014)
The Kantian Roots of Merleau-Ponty's Account of Pathology
(/isis/citation/CBB001201142/)
Chapter
LUIS E. ECHARTE;
(2016)
After Medicine: The Cosmetic Pull of Neuroscience
(/isis/citation/CBB945023207/)
Article
Andrieu, Bernard;
(2007)
De la maturopathie á la neuropathologie développementale: La recherche sur les fœtus prématurés au laboratoire de recherches néonatales de la Clinique Baudelocque á Paris entre 1947 et 1967
(/isis/citation/CBB000850291/)
Article
Hoeyer, Klaus L.;
Jensen, Anja M. B.;
(August 2013)
Transgressive ethics: Professional work ethics as a perspective on ‘aggressive organ harvesting’
(/isis/citation/CBB490167143/)
Article
D. Alan Shewmon;
Noriko Salamon;
(2021)
The Extraordinary Case of Jahi McMath
(/isis/citation/CBB127888205/)
Article
Sky Edith Gross;
Shai Lavi;
Hagai Boas;
(2019)
Medicine, Technology, and Religion Reconsidered: The Case of Brain Death Definition in Israel
(/isis/citation/CBB228629534/)
Book
Germana Pareti;
(2000)
Il cancro dell’imperatore. Dalla teoria cellulare alle ipotesi oncogenetiche
(/isis/citation/CBB427618137/)
Article
Susan E. Lederer;
(2016)
“Ethics and Clinical Research” in Biographical Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB708003369/)
Article
David Ribes;
Jessica Beth Polk;
(2015)
Organizing for Ontological Change: The Kernel of an Aids Research Infrastructure
(/isis/citation/CBB617006565/)
Book
Bondarew, Veronica;
Seligman, Peter;
(2012)
The Cochlear Story
(/isis/citation/CBB001210647/)
Article
November, Joseph A.;
(2011)
Early Biomedical Computing and the Roots of Evidence-Based Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001231715/)
Book
Jacqueline H. Wolf;
(2018)
Cesarean Section: An American History of Risk, Technology, and Consequence
(/isis/citation/CBB215312555/)
Book
Altenstetter, Christa;
(2014)
Medical Technology in Japan: The Politics of Regulation
(/isis/citation/CBB001422095/)
Book
Emma Bedor Hiland;
(2021)
Therapy Tech: The Digital Transformation of Mental Healthcare
(/isis/citation/CBB444822952/)
Chapter
Cartwright, Lisa;
Alač, Morana;
(2008)
Imagination, Multimodalität und verkörperte Interaktion. Eine Erörterung von Klang und Bewegung in zwei Fallstudien der Magnetresonanztomografie in Labor und Klinik
(/isis/citation/CBB001024356/)
Article
Simon, Linda;
(2014)
Battling the “Invincible Predator”: Alzheimer's Disease as Metaphor
(/isis/citation/CBB001202130/)
Book
Shelley McKellar;
(2018)
Artificial Hearts: The Allure and Ambivalence of a Controversial Medical Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB433691060/)
Be the first to comment!