Article ID: CBB601333866

Do no harm: Phanostrate’s midwifery practice (2020)

unapi

The funerary stele of Phanostrate is the earliest known monument commemorating a woman who was a midwife (maia) and physician (iatros); it dates to the mid-fourth century b.c. In this paper, I examine Phanostrate’s assertion that she ‘caused pain to no-one’ in the context of medical ethics found in the Hippocratic Corpus. This statement is reminiscent of one of the clauses of the Hippocratic Oath, where the student of medicine swears to keep patients from ‘harm and injustice’. It also brings to mind the famous ‘do no harm’ principle, which is expressed in the Hippocratic Epidemics. The phrasing of Phanostrate’s stele, however, is somewhat unusual. She claims that she has been lupēra, painful to no-one. The adjective lupēros is not used frequently in the Hippocratic Corpus, but it does appear in the opening section of On Winds, where the author states that the art of medicine can be painful to those who practice it. I reflect on the nature of the ‘pain’ that medicine and its practitioners could cause and alleviate. I ask whether Phanostrate might have been responding to some of the principles outlined in the Oath, where the use of abortive pessaries is famously proscribed. I also present another inscription, from the sanctuary of Asclepius on the slope of the Athenian Acropolis, ig ii3 4.700, which might also be honouring Phanostrate.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB601333866/

Similar Citations

Article Amneris Roselli; (2020)
The Hippocratic treatise On the Physician: form and content (/isis/citation/CBB860301836/)

Book Giulia Ecca; (2018)
Etica medica sulle orme di Ippocrate (/isis/citation/CBB171639816/)

Article Pilar Pérez Cañizares; (2020)
The aphoristic sentences in the Hippocratic treatise On Affections (/isis/citation/CBB524307655/)

Book Tommaso Raiola; (2018)
Sabini medici eiusque discipulorum fragmenta (/isis/citation/CBB143301999/)

Article Robin Lane Fox; Andrew Meadows; (2020)
Dates and measures: history and some Hippocratic texts (/isis/citation/CBB845868682/)

Article Maria Börno; Sean Coughlin; (2020)
Galen on bad style (kakozēlía): Hippocratic exegesis in Galen and some predecessors (/isis/citation/CBB077692673/)

Article Irene Calà; (2019)
Nuovi frammenti di Andrea di Caristo (/isis/citation/CBB733558234/)

Article Vivian Nutton; (2020)
The Epidemics: organising information on communal diseases (/isis/citation/CBB221976383/)

Article Taro Mimura; (2016)
Ḥunayn ibn Isḥāq and the text of the Hippocratic Aphorisms (/isis/citation/CBB358909690/)

Article Anna Maria Ieraci Bio; (2023)
Un nuovo frammento greco del commento di Giovanni Alessandrino in Hippocr. Epid. VI nel Vat. gr. 300 (/isis/citation/CBB029247089/)

Article Antoine Pietrobelli; (2020)
Un manuscript perdu de Galien retrouvé à Cracovie (/isis/citation/CBB900251252/)

Article Anna Maria Urso; (2020)
Spigolature soranee (/isis/citation/CBB967437630/)

Article Vito Lorusso; (2016)
Due anecdota galenici nel Parisinus suppl. gr. 634 e appunti sul Parisinus gr. 1849 (/isis/citation/CBB778638404/)

Article Elizabeth Craik; (2019)
A note on colour terms in Hippocratic texts (/isis/citation/CBB972480888/)

Authors & Contributors
Ecca, Giulia
Jouanna, Jacques
Lorusso, Vito
Pietrobelli, Antoine
Raiola, Tommaso
Börno, Maria
Concepts
Medicine
Linguistics; philology
Ecdotics; source study (methodology)
Hippocratic medicine
Manuscripts
Greek language
Time Periods
Ancient
Medieval
Places
Byzantium
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment