“Stahl Was Often Closer to the Truth”: Kant’s Second Thoughts on Animism, Monadology, and Hylozoism (2021)
In the Dreams of a Spirit-Seer, Elucidated by Dreams of Metaphysics (1766), Kant remarks that Stahl, with his admission of immaterial forces for the explanation of organisms, was “closer to the truth than Hoffmann and Boerhaave, to name but a few,” although the latter adopted a “more philosophical method.” This puzzling statement is very significant for the understanding of Kant’s reception of animism, as it documents Kant’s reaction to the issues raised by the Leibniz-Stahl controversy and his striking preference for Stahl’s nonmechanistic account of organisms. Kant agrees with Stahl that organisms suggest the existence of immaterial thinking beings, but at the same time, the example of this speculative hypothesis leads him to question the explanatory power of metaphysical hypotheses in natural philosophy in general, as well as the possibility of empirically distinguishing among different hypotheses, such as monadology, materialism, and hylozoism. After the analysis of Kant’s skeptical conclusions in the Dreams of a Spirit-Seer, I discuss how this earlier connection of medicine, life sciences, and metaphysics leaves traces in Kant’s later work, by analyzing Kant’s discussion of Samuel Sömmering’s claim that matter “can be animated” in On the Organ of the Soul (1796) and the preliminary drafts for this essay.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Jonathan L. Shaheen;
(2021)
The Life of the Thrice Sensitive, Rational and Wise Animate Matter: Cavendish’s Animism
(/isis/citation/CBB509215550/)
Article
Francesco Paolo de Ceglia;
(2021)
Matter Is Not Enough: Georg Ernst Stahl, Friedrich Hoffmann, and the Issue of Animism
(/isis/citation/CBB256166445/)
Book
Blank, Andreas;
(2010)
Biomedical Ontology and the Metaphysics of Composite Substances, 1540--1670
(/isis/citation/CBB001210218/)
Book
Buzaglo, Meir;
(2002)
Solomon Maimon: Monism, Skepticism, and Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB000201316/)
Book
Löw, Reinhard;
(1980)
Philosophie des Lebendigen: Der Begriff des Organischen bei Kant, sein Grund und seine Aktualität
(/isis/citation/CBB000006070/)
Chapter
Zammito, John;
(2006)
Kant's Early Views on Epigenesis: The Role of Maupertuis
(/isis/citation/CBB000771983/)
Article
Makkreel, Rudolf A.;
(1985)
The feeling of life: Some Kantian sources of life-philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB000031180/)
Book
Ina Goy;
(2014)
Kant's Theory of Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB256212882/)
Article
John H. Zammito;
(2016)
Epigenesis in Kant: Recent Reconsiderations
(/isis/citation/CBB404962128/)
Article
Polka, Brayton;
(2011)
The Metaphysics of Thinking Necessary Existence: Kant and the Ontological Argument
(/isis/citation/CBB001252144/)
Book
Guyer, Paul;
(2006)
The Cambridge Companion to Kant and Modern Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001035165/)
Book
Kant, Immanuel;
Friedman, Michael;
(2004)
Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science
(/isis/citation/CBB000770173/)
Article
Michela Massimi;
(2021)
Points of view: Kant on perspectival knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB347989642/)
Article
Berg, Hein van den;
(2013)
The Wolffian Roots of Kant's Teleology
(/isis/citation/CBB001320551/)
Article
Massimi, Michela;
(2011)
Kant's Dynamical Theory of Matter in 1755, and Its Debt to Speculative Newtonian Experimentalism
(/isis/citation/CBB001230565/)
Article
Malzkorn, Wolfgang;
(1998)
Kant über die Teilbarkeit der Materie
(/isis/citation/CBB000081900/)
Chapter
Buroker, Jill Vance;
(1974)
Kant, the dynamical tradition, and the role of matter in explanation
(/isis/citation/CBB000025646/)
Book
Friedman, Michael;
(2013)
Kant's Construction of Nature: A Reading of the Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001450196/)
Article
Smith, Sheldon;
(2013)
Kant's Picture of Monads in the Physical Monadology
(/isis/citation/CBB001211303/)
Book
Catherine Wilson;
(2022)
Kant and the Naturalistic Turn of 18th Century Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB775333088/)
Be the first to comment!