Though well established in mammals, the cognitive map hypothesis has engendered a decades-long, ongoing debate in insect navigation studies involving many of the field's most prominent researchers. In this paper, I situate the debate within the broader context of 20th century animal behavior research and argue that the debate persists because competing research groups are guided by different constellations of epistemic aims, theoretical commitments, preferred animal subjects, and investigative practices. The expanded history of the cognitive map provided in this paper shows that more is at stake in the cognitive map debate than the truth value of propositions characterizing insect cognition. What is at stake is the future direction of an extraordinarily productive tradition of insect navigation research stretching back to Karl von Frisch. Disciplinary labels like ethology, comparative psychology, and behaviorism became less relevant at the turn of the 21st century, but as I show, the different ways of knowing animals associated with these disciplines continue to motivate debates about animal cognition. This examination of scientific disagreement surrounding the cognitive map hypothesis also has significant consequences for philosophers' use of cognitive map research as a case study.
...MoreArticle Rüdiger Wehner; Thierry Hoinville; Holk Cruse (2023) On the ‘cognitive map debate’ in insect navigation. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (pp. 87-89).
Similar Citations
Article
Rüdiger Wehner;
Thierry Hoinville;
Holk Cruse;
(2023)
On the ‘cognitive map debate’ in insect navigation
(/isis/citation/CBB569805014/)
Book
Nicolas Langlitz;
(2020)
Chimpanzee Culture Wars
(/isis/citation/CBB054916365/)
Article
Downes, Stephen M.;
(1999)
Can scientific development and children's cognitive development be the same process?
(/isis/citation/CBB000110767/)
Article
Sackur, Jérôme;
(2009)
L'introspection en psychologie expérimentale
(/isis/citation/CBB000954545/)
Book
Slater, Lauren;
(2004)
Opening Skinner's Box: Great Psychological Experiments of the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000550399/)
Thesis
Feest, Uljana;
(2003)
Operationalism, Experimentation, and Concept Formation
(/isis/citation/CBB001561972/)
Article
Katja Guenther;
(2017)
Monkeys, Mirrors, and Me: Gordon Gallup and the Study of Self-Recognition
(/isis/citation/CBB045415018/)
Book
Burkhardt, Richard W., Jr.;
(2005)
Patterns of Behavior: Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen, and the Founding of Ethology
(/isis/citation/CBB000550823/)
Article
Marga Vicedo;
(2023)
Epistemological discipline in animal behavior studies: Konrad Lorenz and Daniel Lehrman on intuition and empathy
(/isis/citation/CBB596910880/)
Chapter
Burkhardt, Richard W., Jr.;
(2011)
Ethology's Traveling Facts
(/isis/citation/CBB001000230/)
Article
Anna Klassen;
(2021)
Methodological Signatures in Early Ethology: The Problem of Animal Subjectivity
(/isis/citation/CBB504631735/)
Article
Erika Lorraine Milam;
(2022)
Landscapes of Time: Building Long-Term Perspectives in Animal Behavior
(/isis/citation/CBB785867437/)
Book
Celentano, Marco;
(2011)
Konrad Lorenz e l'etologia contemporanea: l'eredità problematica di uno scienziato inattuale
(/isis/citation/CBB001252728/)
Article
Sophia Gräfe;
Cora Stuhrmann;
(2022)
Histories of Ethology: Methods, Sites, and Dynamics of an Unbound Discipline
(/isis/citation/CBB985454871/)
Article
Brad Bolman;
(2022)
Critical Periods in Science and the Science of Critical Periods: Canine Behavior in America
(/isis/citation/CBB307853900/)
Book
Vicedo, Marga;
(2013)
The Nature and Nurture of Love: From Imprinting to Attachment in Cold War America
(/isis/citation/CBB001213142/)
Book
Kruuk, Hans;
(2003)
Niko's Nature: The Life of Niko Tinbergen and His Science of Animal Behaviour
(/isis/citation/CBB000501254/)
Article
Munz, Tania;
(2011)
“My Goose Child Martina”
(/isis/citation/CBB001220835/)
Article
Marga Vicedo;
(2023)
Beyond the Instinct Debate: Daniel Lehrman’s Contributions to Animal Behavior Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB449441088/)
Article
Kelle Dhein;
(2021)
Karl von Frisch and the Discipline of Ethology
(/isis/citation/CBB438578727/)
Be the first to comment!