Lampert, Timm (Author)
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume: 25
Issue: 2
Pages: 389-400
Newton claims to have proven the heterogeneity of light through his experimentum crucis. However, Olaf Müller has worked out in detail Goethe’s idea that one could likewise prove the heterogeneity of darkness by inverting Newton’s famous experiment. Müller concludes that this invalidates Newton’s claim of proof. Yet this conclusion only holds if the heterogeneity of light and the heterogeneity of darkness is logically incompatible. This paper shows that this is not the case. Instead, in Quine’s terms, we have two logically compatible theories based on mutually irreducible theoretical terms. From a Quinean point of view, this does no harm to the provability of the corresponding statements.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Olaf L. Mueller;
(2016)
Prismatic Equivalence – A New Case of Underdetermination: Goethe vs. Newton on the Prism Experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB847582954/)
Article
Marcum, James A.;
(2009)
The Nature of Light and Color: Goethe's “Der Versuch als Vermittler” versus Newton's Experimentum Crucis
(/isis/citation/CBB000932276/)
Article
Gage, John;
(2008)
Signs of Disharmony: Newton's Opticks and the Artists
(/isis/citation/CBB000831782/)
Article
Ben-Chaim, Michael;
(2001)
The discovery of natural goods: Newton's vocation as an “experimental philosopher”
(/isis/citation/CBB000100556/)
Article
Zemplén, Gábor Á.;
Demeter, Tamás;
(2010)
Being Charitable to Scientific Controversies: On the Demonstrativity of Newton's Experimentum Crucis
(/isis/citation/CBB001221445/)
Article
Steinle, Friedrich;
(2002)
“Das Nächste ans Nächste reihen”: Goethe, Newton und das Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB000200402/)
Chapter
Steinle, Friedrich;
(2005)
“Das Nächste ans Nächste reihen”: Goethe, Newton und das Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB001033928/)
Chapter
Knuutila, Simo;
Kukkonen, Taneli;
(2011)
Thought Experiments and Indirect Proofs in Averroes, Aquinas, and Buridan
(/isis/citation/CBB001321020/)
Chapter
Hon, Giora;
(2009)
Error: The Long Neglect, the One-Sided View, and a Typology
(/isis/citation/CBB001020625/)
Article
B. Cameron Reed;
(2020)
Walther Bothe's Graphite: Physics, Impurities, and Blame in the German Nuclear Program
(/isis/citation/CBB340773011/)
Chapter
Geordie McComb;
(2012)
Thought Experiment, Definition, and Literary Fiction
(/isis/citation/CBB935102391/)
Chapter
James Robert Brown;
(2012)
What Do We See in a Thought Experiment?
(/isis/citation/CBB888317009/)
Thesis
Kassenbrock, Brian W.;
(2009)
Novalis and the Two Cultures: The Chiasmic Discourse of Mathematics, Philosophy and Poetics
(/isis/citation/CBB001562853/)
Chapter
David Davies;
(2012)
Can Philosophical Thought Experiments Be ‘Screened’?
(/isis/citation/CBB334225094/)
Chapter
Vrishali Subramanian;
Sanjay Chandrasekharan;
Nancy J. Nersessian;
(2012)
Computational Modeling: Is This the End of Thought Experiments in Science?
(/isis/citation/CBB739614030/)
Chapter
Richard T. W. Arthur;
(2012)
Can Thought Experiments Be Resolved by Experiment? The Case of Aristotle’s Wheel
(/isis/citation/CBB597559409/)
Chapter
Julian Reiss;
(2012)
Genealogical Thought Experiments in Economics
(/isis/citation/CBB482966499/)
Chapter
W. Ford Doolittle;
(2012)
Craig Venter’s New Life: the Realization of Some Thought Experiments in Biological Ontology
(/isis/citation/CBB307106698/)
Chapter
Marco Buzzoni;
(2012)
Thought Experiments from a Kantian Point of View
(/isis/citation/CBB794939617/)
Article
Hopp, Walter;
(2014)
Experiments in Thought
(/isis/citation/CBB001421040/)
Be the first to comment!