Ontology and values anchor indigenous and grey nomenclatures: a case study in lichen naming practices among the Samí, Sherpa, Scots, and Okanagan (2020)
Ethnobotanical research provides ample justification for comparing diverse biological nomenclatures and exploring ways that retain alternative naming practices. However, how (and whether) comparison of nomenclatures is possible remains a subject of discussion. The comparison of diverse nomenclatural practices introduces a suite of epistemic and ontological difficulties and considerations. Different nomenclatures may depend on whether the communities using them rely on formalized naming conventions; cultural or spiritual valuations; or worldviews. Because of this, some argue that the different naming practices may not be comparable if the ontological commitments employed differ. Comparisons between different nomenclatures cannot assume that either the naming practices or the object to which these names are intended to apply identifies some universally agreed upon object of interest. Investigating this suite of philosophical problems, I explore the role grey nomenclatures play in classification. ‘Grey nomenclatures’ are defined as those that employ names that are either intentionally or accidently non-Linnaean. The classification of the lichen thallus (a symbiont) has been classified outside the Linnaean system by botanists relying on the International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants (ICN). But, I argue, the use of grey names is not isolated and does not occur exclusively within institutionalized naming practices. I suggest, ‘grey names’ also aptly describe nomenclatures employed by indigenous communities such as the Samí of Northern Finmark, the Sherpa of Nepal, and the Okanagan First Nations. I pay particular attention to how naming practices are employed in these communities; what ontological commitments they hold; for what purposes are these names used; and what anchors the community's nomenclatural practices. Exploring the history of lichen naming and early ethnolichenological research, I then investigate the stakes that must be considered for any attempt to preserve, retain, integrate, or compare the knowledge contained in both academically formalized grey names and indigenous nomenclatures in a way that preserves their source-specific informational content.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sauer, Hans;
Krischke, Ulrike;
(2004)
Die altenglischen Pflanzennamen aus linguistischer und lexikographischer Sicht
(/isis/citation/CBB000501341/)
Article
Merlin Sheldrake;
(June 2020)
The ‘enigma’ of Richard Schultes, Amazonian hallucinogenic plants, and the limits of ethnobotany
(/isis/citation/CBB961943288/)
Article
Nancy J Turner;
(2018)
Learning New Medicines: Exchanging Medicinal Plant Knowledge amongst Northwestern North American Indigenous and Settler Communities
(/isis/citation/CBB592368681/)
Article
Whitmer, Kelly Joan;
(2013)
What's in a Name? Place, Peoples and Plants in the Danish-Halle Mission, c. 1710--1740
(/isis/citation/CBB001320282/)
Article
Köhler, Piotr;
(2015)
Józef Rostafiński's Ethnobotanical Enquiry of 1883 Concerning Polish Vernacular Names and Uses of Plants
(/isis/citation/CBB001500445/)
Article
Palsson, Gisli;
(2014)
Personal Names: Embodiment, Differentiation, Exclusion, and Belonging
(/isis/citation/CBB001421208/)
Article
Charu Singh;
(2022)
Science in the vernacular? Translation, terminology and lexicography in the Hindi Scientific Glossary (1906)
(/isis/citation/CBB456838082/)
Article
Benjafield, John G.;
(2012)
The Long Past and Short History of the Vocabulary of Anglophone Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB001220679/)
Article
Powell, Alexander;
O'Malley, Maureen A.;
Müller-Wille, Staffan;
Calvert, Jane;
Dupré, John;
(2007)
Disciplinary Baptisms: A Comparison of the Naming Stories of Genetics, Molecular Biology, Genomics and Systems Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000831324/)
Book
Fortuine, Robert;
(2001)
Words of Medicine: Sources, Meanings, and Delights
(/isis/citation/CBB000102047/)
Article
Russo, Ruth;
(2002)
A Natural History of “Agonist”
(/isis/citation/CBB000300975/)
Article
Winance, Myriam;
(2008)
La notion de handicap et ses transformations à travers les classifications internationales du handicap de l'OMS, 1980 et 2001
(/isis/citation/CBB000931739/)
Article
Perdicoyianni-Paléologou, Hélène;
(2009)
The Vocabulary of Madness from Homer to Hippocrates. Part 2: The Verbal Group of [Greek transliteration begin]bakxeuw[Greek transliteration end] and the Noun [Greek transliteration begin]lussa[Greek transliteration end]
(/isis/citation/CBB000932530/)
Article
Schatzberg, Eric;
(2006)
Technik Comes to America: Changing Meanings of Technology before 1930
(/isis/citation/CBB000670774/)
Article
Proctor, Robert N.;
(2007)
“-Logos”, “-Ismos”, and “-Ikos”: The Political Iconicity of Denominative Suffixes in Science (or, Phonesthemic Tints and Taints in the Coining of Science Domain Names)
(/isis/citation/CBB000772258/)
Article
Perdicoyianni-Paléologou, Hélène;
(2009)
The Vocabulary of Madness from Homer to Hippocrates. Part 1: The Verbal Group of [Greek transliteration begin]mainoma[Greek transliteration end]
(/isis/citation/CBB000932523/)
Book
Allison Margaret Bigelow;
(2020)
Mining Language: Racial Thinking, Indigenous Knowledge, and Colonial Metallurgy in the Early Modern Iberian World
(/isis/citation/CBB877754784/)
Article
Joel Vargas-Domínguez;
(2017)
The "Problematic" Otomi: Metabolism, Nutrition, and the Classification of Indigenous Populations in Mexico in the 1930's
(/isis/citation/CBB628667368/)
Article
Chris Meyns;
(2020)
‘Data’ in the Royal Society's Philosophical Transactions, 1665–1886
(/isis/citation/CBB598614888/)
Article
Behrent, Michael C.;
(2013)
Foucault and Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB001211946/)
Be the first to comment!