IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB588946781

Inferring Alignments I: Exploring the Accuracy and Precision of Two Statistical Approaches (2017)

Silva, Fabio (Author)

Journal of Skyscape Archaeology
Volume: 3
Issue: 1
Pages: 93-111

URI: https://journals.equinoxpub.com/index.php/JSA/article/view/31958

DOI: 10.1558/jsa.31958

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Using computer simulations, this paper explores and quantifies the accuracy and precision of two approaches to the statistical inference of the most likely targets of a set of structural orientations. It discusses the curvigram method (also known as kernel density estimation or summed probability distribution) in wide currency in archaeoastronomy, and introduces the largely unutilised maximum likelihood (ML) method, which has popularity in other academic fields. An analysis of both methods’ accuracy and precision is done, using a scenario with a single target, and the resulting equations can be used to estimate the minimum number of surveyed structures required to ensure a high-precision statistical inference. Two fundamental observations emerge: firstly, that although both approaches are quite accurate, the ML approach is considerably more precise than the curvigram approach; and secondly, that underestimating measurement uncertainty severely undermines the precision of the curvigram method. Finally, the implications of these observations for past, present and future archaeoastronomical research are discussed.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB588946781/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Marcello Ranieri; (2014)
Digging the Archives: The Orientation of Greek Temples and their Diagonals (/isis/citation/CBB705238526/)

Article Liz Henty; (2015)
Continuity or Change? A Microscopic Scale Analysis of Monuments and Ritual in Aberdeenshire (/isis/citation/CBB346775076/)

Article Frank J. Ventura; (2017)
Beyond Orientations and Intentions Towards Motivation and Meaning: An Enduring Challenge and a Possible Response (/isis/citation/CBB303335111/)

Article Penka Maglova; Alexey Stoev; Mina Spasova; (2016)
Late Chalcolithic Solar-Chthonic Rock-Cut Structures For Time Measuring In The Eastern Rhodopes, Bulgaria (/isis/citation/CBB950981478/)

Article M. Incerti; G. Lavoratti; S. Iurilli; (2016)
Survey, Archaeoastronomy And Communication: The Mausoleum Of Theodoric In Ravenna (Italy) (/isis/citation/CBB461391255/)

Article A. Orlando; M.T. Magro; M. S. Scaravilli; (2016)
The Oriented Altars Of Rocca Pizzicata And The Rocky Sites Of Alcantara Valley (/isis/citation/CBB874979851/)

Book Giulio Magli; (2009)
Mysteries and Discoveries of Archaeoastronomy: From Giza to Easter Island (/isis/citation/CBB495553518/)

Article Jeffrey Ryan Vadala; Susan Milbrath; (2016)
Using Virtual Reality to Understand Astronomical Knowledge and Historical Landscapes at Preclassic Cerros, Belize (/isis/citation/CBB087892399/)

Article V. R. Tiede; (2016)
Ara Pacis Avgvstae: An Astro-Archaeological Analysis (/isis/citation/CBB294902373/)

Article N. Lanciano; P. Virgili; (2016)
The Urban Set of the Pantheon and the Mausoleum of Augustus in Rome, Between Architectural and Astronomical Symbolism (/isis/citation/CBB066682267/)

Article Cecilia Dal Zovo; A. César González-García; (2018)
The 'Path of the Spirits': A Preliminary Approach to North-West/South-East Oriented Rows of Cairns in the Altai Mountains, Mongolia (/isis/citation/CBB471372055/)

Article Georg Zotti; (2014)
Towards Serious Gaming for Archaeoastronomical Simulation (/isis/citation/CBB392311962/)

Article Anne Teather; Andrew Chamberlain; Mike Parker Pearson; (2019)
The Chalk Drums from Folkton and Lavant: Measuring Devices from the Time of Stonehenge (/isis/citation/CBB041422172/)

Article Luís Tirapicos; (2019)
Bibliographical Evolutions: From Archaeoastronomy to Astronomy in Culture (/isis/citation/CBB348446734/)

Article Xu, Fengxian; He, Nu; (2011)
A New Explanation on the Origination of the Idea of 1 cun for 1000 li for the Variation Rate of the Sun's Shadow (/isis/citation/CBB001210025/)

Article J. McKim Malville; (2015)
Chimney Rock and the Ontology of Skyscapes: How Astronomy, Trade, and Pilgrimage Transformed Chimney Rock (/isis/citation/CBB727067312/)

Article Duane W. Hamacher; Robert S. Fuller; Trevor M. Leaman; David Bosun; (2020)
Solstice and solar position observations in Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander traditions (/isis/citation/CBB816013968/)

Article Vance R. Tiede; (2018)
ΒΩΜΟΣ ΔΩΔΕΚΑ ΘΕΩΝ / Altar of the Twelve Gods: An Astro-Archaeological Analysis (/isis/citation/CBB443640155/)

Article Dimitris Sinachopoulos; (2019)
A further application of Google Earth in studying the orientation of ancient Greek monument (/isis/citation/CBB440032726/)

Article Georg Zotti; Florian Schaukowitsch; Michael Wimmer; (2018)
Beyond 3D Models: Simulation of Temporally Evolving Models in Stellarium (/isis/citation/CBB991117441/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}