Article ID: CBB581465929

Pluralizing Darwin: Making Counter-Factual History of Science Significant (2021)

unapi

In the wake of recent attempts at alternate history (Bowler 2013), this paper suggests several avenues for a pluralistic approach to Charles Darwin and his role in the history of evolutionary theory. We examine in what sense Darwin could be described as a major driver of theoretical change in the history of biology. First, this paper examines how Darwin influenced the future of biological science: not merely by stating the fact of evolution or by bringing evidence for it; but by discovering natural selection, and giving it pre-eminence over any other mechanism for evolution; and also by proposing a masterful and quite unique synthesis of many scientific fields. Contrasting Darwin’s views with those of A.R. Wallace, I conclude that “natural selection” is clearly an original contribution, that it had no forerunners or co-discoverers, and could barely have appeared after Darwin conceived of it. This specificity of Darwin’s contribution is an invitation to be strongly presentist (Loison 2016) and to adopt only weak counter-factuals. In contrast, there are possible ways to use strong counter-factuals as attempts to “pluralize” the history of biological theory: i.e. imagine new possible avenues for the development of evolutionary biology. The idea that evolution was a theory “in the air” suggests that evolutionary theory could have developed in a world without Darwin, especially if we accept to delete not only “Darwin” but “England”. France and Germany are examined as possible countries where evolutionary ideas would have thrived even with no contribution from the English scientists. Finally, the paper suggests another counter-factual hypothesis: deleting not Darwin and his Origin but the Darwin Industry itself. This may allow us to read the Origin of Species with fresh eyes and to discover Darwin’s life-long interest in variation and its laws, as many of his early readers did.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB581465929/

Similar Citations

Article Brink-Roby, Heather; (2009)
Natural Representation: Diagram and Text in Darwin's On the Origin of Species (/isis/citation/CBB001030093/)

Book Donohue, Kathleen; (2011)
Darwin's Finches: Readings in the Evolution of a Scientific Paradigm (/isis/citation/CBB001033158/)

Article Beer, Gillian; (2009)
Darwin and the Uses of Extinction (/isis/citation/CBB001030096/)

Article Curtis N. Johnson; (2019)
Charles Darwin, Richard Owen, and Natural Selection: A Question of Priority (/isis/citation/CBB684893999/)

Chapter Rupke, Nicolaas; (2010)
Darwin's Choice (/isis/citation/CBB001020301/)

Book Gardiner, Brian; Milner, Richard; Morris, Mary; (2008)
Survival of the Fittest: A Special Issue of the Linnean Celebrating the 150th Anniversary of the Darwin-Wallace Theory of Evolution (/isis/citation/CBB001035140/)

Book Creath, Richard; Maienschein, Jane; (2000)
Biology and epistemology (/isis/citation/CBB000110573/)

Book Stott, Rebecca; (2003)
Darwin and the Barnacle (/isis/citation/CBB000320242/)

Chapter Engels, Eve-Marie; (2009)
Charles Darwins geheimnisvolle Revolution (/isis/citation/CBB001023713/)

Book Ruse, Michael; Travis, Joseph; (2009)
Evolution: The First Four Billion Years (/isis/citation/CBB001232307/)

Article Kathryn Tabb; (2016)
Darwin at Orchis Bank: Selection after the Origin (/isis/citation/CBB704610076/)

Thesis Eugene, Earnshaw-Whyte.; (2012)
Modeling Evolution (/isis/citation/CBB001567349/)

Article Rolf Löther; (2010)
„Kampf ums Dasein― vor, bei und nach Darwin (/isis/citation/CBB489891365/)

Article J. H. van Hateren; (2014)
Intrinsic estimates of fitness affect the causal structure of evolutionary change (/isis/citation/CBB316372448/)

Article Lawson, Anton E.; (2009)
On the Hypothetico-Deductive Nature of Science---Darwin's Finches (/isis/citation/CBB001032859/)

Article Gildenhuys, Peter; (2004)
Darwin, Herschel, and the Role of Analogy in Darwin's Origin (/isis/citation/CBB000501625/)

Article Burnett, D. Graham; (2009)
Savage Selection: Analogy and Elision in On the Origin of Species (/isis/citation/CBB000932659/)

Article Richards, Robert J.; (2012)
Darwin's Principles of Divergence and Natural Selection: Why Fodor Was Almost Right (/isis/citation/CBB001221609/)

Article Deichmann, Ute; (2010)
Gemmules and Elements: On Darwin's and Mendel's Concepts and Methods in Heredity (/isis/citation/CBB001230066/)

Article Ian Hesketh; (2021)
Narratives of Charles Darwin Down Under (/isis/citation/CBB437714128/)

Authors & Contributors
Hateren, J. H. van
Eugene, Earnshaw-Whyte
Travis, Joseph
Tabb, Kathryn
Stott, Rebecca
Ruse, Michael
Concepts
Evolution
Natural selection
Biology
Darwinism
Philosophy of biology
Methodology of science; scientific method
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
18th century
Places
Great Britain
Blue Mountains (New South Wales)
Tasmania (Australia)
New South Wales (Australia)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment