Too Much to Tell: Narrative Styles of the First Descriptions of the Natural World of the Indies (2017)
Leitão, Henrique (Author)
Sánchez, Antonio (Author)
History of Science
Volume: 55
Issue: 2
Pages: 167-186
Describing a Mundus Novus was a very singular task in the sixteenth century. It was an effort shaped by a permanent inherent tension between novelty and normality, between the immense variety of new facts (some extraordinary) and the demand of credibility. How did these inner strains affect the narrative style of the first descriptions of the natural world of ‘the Indies’? How were the first European observers of the nature of America able to simultaneously transmit the idea of immensity and regularity (mundus), and that of novelty (novus)? How did they attempt to describe new worlds knowing that there was a lot – perhaps too much – to tell? This paper focuses not on the much-discussed epistemological issues related to those questions, but on their narrative and stylistic consequences. We argue that the first Europeans meeting the new realities of the Americas or India had to meet new challenges, and these translated into texts with specific characteristics. Thus, their first descriptions are essentially different from the texts about the natural world that were written before or after the ‘discovery’. We show that they adopted very specific discursive approaches, and were deeply influenced by the credibility strategies of the medical profession in which they had been trained.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Júlio Manuel Rodrigues Costa;
(2017)
Una firma autógrafa de Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo, antiguos poseedores y circulación de un ejemplar “De la Natural Historia de las Indias”
(/isis/citation/CBB797035586/)
Article
Paden, Jeremy;
(2007)
The Iguana and the Barrel of Mud: Memory, Natural History, and Hermeneutics in Oviedo's Sumario de la natural historia de las Indias
(/isis/citation/CBB001030972/)
Book
Mauricio Nieto Olarte;
(2013)
Las máquinas del imperio y el reino de Dios: reflexiones sobre ciencia, tecnología y religión en el mundo atlántico del siglo XVI
(/isis/citation/CBB487566602/)
Article
Antonella Romano;
(2019)
Iberian Missionaries in God’s Vineyard: Enlarging Humankind and Encompassing the Globe in the Renaissance
(/isis/citation/CBB494244460/)
Book
Christine Petto;
(2015)
Mapping and Charting in Early Modern England and France: Power, Patronage, and Production
(/isis/citation/CBB153352848/)
Article
Heidi Hausse;
(2014)
European Theories and Local Therapies: Mordexi and Galenism in the East Indies, 1500-1700
(/isis/citation/CBB818458940/)
Book
Cordero del Campillo, Miguel;
(2001)
Crónicas de Indias: Ganadería, Medicina y Veterinaria
(/isis/citation/CBB000410625/)
Book
Acosta, Cristóbal;
(2000)
Tractado de las drogas, y medicinas de las Indias Orientales, con sus plantas debuxadas al biuo por Christoual Acosta ... En el qual se verifica mucho de lo que escriuio el doctor Garcia de Orta ...
(/isis/citation/CBB000501012/)
Book
Caitlin Rosenthal;
(2018)
Accounting for Slavery: Masters and Management
(/isis/citation/CBB930905007/)
Thesis
Bhimull, Chandra D.;
(2007)
Empire in the Air: Speed, Perception, and Airline Travel in the Atlantic World
(/isis/citation/CBB001560723/)
Chapter
Torny, Didier;
(2013)
Managing an Everlastingly Polluted World: Food Policies and Community Health Actions in the French West Indies
(/isis/citation/CBB001420175/)
Article
Ottmar Ette;
(2017)
Texte-île et écriture archipélique: Isle de Cube, Antilles en général d’Alexander von Humboldt
(/isis/citation/CBB283436335/)
Article
Carey, Mark;
(2011)
Inventing Caribbean Climates: How Science, Medicine, and Tourism Changed Tropical Weather from Deadly to Healthy
(/isis/citation/CBB001034577/)
Article
Mulich, Jeppe;
(2013)
Microregionalism and Intercolonial Relations: The Case of the Danish West Indies, 1730--1830
(/isis/citation/CBB001421522/)
Chapter
Kenneth G. Kelly;
(2019)
Building a Better Village? Transformations in French West Indian Slave Village Architecture from the Ancien Régime to Emancipation
(/isis/citation/CBB123181616/)
Thesis
Hill, Michael R.;
(2013)
Temperateness, Temperance, and the Tropics: Climate and Morality in the English Atlantic World, 1555-1705
(/isis/citation/CBB001567479/)
Article
Goddard, Robert;
(2001)
The Fall of the Bardados Planter Class: An Interpretation of the 1980s Crisis in the Barbados Sugar Industry
(/isis/citation/CBB000102072/)
Thesis
Luthfi Adam;
(2020)
Cultivating Power: Buitenzorg Botanic Garden and Empire-Building in the Netherlands East Indies, 1745-1917
(/isis/citation/CBB491950509/)
Article
Claire Edington;
Hans Pols;
(2016)
Building Psychiatric Expertise across Southeast Asia: Study Trips, Site Visits, and Therapeutic Labor in French Indochina and the Dutch East Indies, 1898–1937
(/isis/citation/CBB623646766/)
Article
John A. Edgington;
(2022)
Three botanical watercolours by Richard Bradley (c.1688–1732) including of coffee and cinnamon
(/isis/citation/CBB762625869/)
Be the first to comment!