Strong reciprocity (SR) has recently been subject to heated debate. In this debate, the “West camp” (West et al. in Evol Hum Behav 32(4):231–262, 2011), which is critical of the case for SR, and the “Laland camp” (Laland et al. in Science, 334(6062):1512–1516, 2011, Biol Philos 28(5):719–745, 2013), which is sympathetic to the case of SR, seem to take diametrically opposed positions. The West camp criticizes advocates of SR for conflating proximate and ultimate causation. SR is said to be a proximate mechanism that is put forward by its advocates as an ultimate explanation of human cooperation. The West camp thus accuses advocates of SR for not heeding Mayr’s original distinction between ultimate and proximate causation. The Laland camp praises advocates of SR for revising Mayr’s distinction. Advocates of SR are said to replace Mayr’s uni-directional view on the relation between ultimate and proximate causes by the bi-directional one of reciprocal causation. The paper argues that both the West camp and the Laland camp misrepresent what advocates of SR are up to. The West camp is right that SR is a proximate cause of human cooperation. But rather than putting forward SR as an ultimate explanation, as the West camp argues, advocates of SR believe that SR itself is in need of ultimate explanation. Advocates of SR tend to take gene-culture co-evolutionary theory as the correct meta-theoretical framework for advancing ultimate explanations of SR. Appearances notwithstanding, gene-culture coevolutionary theory does not imply Laland et al.’s notion of reciprocal causation. “Reciprocal causation” suggests that proximate and ultimate causes interact simultaneously, while advocates of SR assume that they interact sequentially. I end by arguing that the best way to understand the debate is by disambiguating Mayr’s ultimate-proximate distinction. I propose to reserve “ultimate” and “proximate” for different sorts of explanations, and to use other terms for distinguishing different kinds of causes and different parts of the total causal chain producing behavior.
...More
Article
Schönknecht, Peter;
Dening, Tom;
(2012)
Between Phenomenological and Community Psychiatry: The Comprehending Anthropology of Jürg Zutt
(/isis/citation/CBB001232177/)
Article
Jonathan Birch;
(2019)
Altruistic deception
(/isis/citation/CBB810923820/)
Article
Christine Clavien;
Michel Chapuisat;
(2016)
The evolution of utility functions and psychological altruism
(/isis/citation/CBB212304865/)
Book
Dugatkin, Lee Alan;
(2011)
The Prince of Evolution: Peter Kropotkin's Adventures in Science and Politics
(/isis/citation/CBB001220994/)
Article
Grant Ramsey;
(2016)
Can altruism be unified?
(/isis/citation/CBB195978476/)
Article
Justin Garson;
Armin W. Schulz;
(2016)
Introduction: The biology of psychological altruism
(/isis/citation/CBB403816505/)
Article
Ursula Klein;
(2017)
Chemists for the Common Good
(/isis/citation/CBB678855527/)
Article
Stephen Stich;
(2016)
Why there might not be an evolutionary explanation for psychological altruism
(/isis/citation/CBB637438090/)
Article
William T. Lynch;
(2019)
Between Kin Selection and Cultural Relativism: Cultural Evolution and the Origin of Inequality
(/isis/citation/CBB211246459/)
Article
Harman, Oren;
(2011)
Helical Biography and the Historical Craft: The Case of Altruism and George Price
(/isis/citation/CBB001220957/)
Thesis
Whitfield, N;
(cited 2011)
A Genealogy of the Gift: Blood Donation in London, 1921--1946
(/isis/citation/CBB001567342/)
Chapter
Segerstrale, Ullica;
(2008)
Against the Grain: The Science and Life of William D. Hamilton
(/isis/citation/CBB000960103/)
Article
Swenson, Sarah A.;
(2015)
“From Man to Bacteria”: W.D. Hamilton, the Theory of Inclusive Fitness, and the Post-War Social Order
(/isis/citation/CBB001422113/)
Article
Gintis, Herbert;
(2014)
Inclusive Fitness and the Sociobiology of the Genome
(/isis/citation/CBB001421608/)
Book
Jones, Greta;
Peel, Robert A.;
(2004)
Herbert Spencer: The Intellectual Legacy
(/isis/citation/CBB000830543/)
Article
Sean Allen-Hermanson;
(2017)
Kamikazes and cultural evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB172974386/)
Book
Dugatkin, Lee Alan;
(2006)
The Altruism Equation: Seven Scientists Search for the Origins of Goodness
(/isis/citation/CBB000772360/)
Article
Rao, Veena;
Nanjundiah, Vidyanand;
(2011)
J. B. S. Haldane, Ernst Mayr and the Beanbag Genetics Dispute
(/isis/citation/CBB001034558/)
Book
Appleman, Philip;
(2001)
Darwin: Texts Commentary
(/isis/citation/CBB000101919/)
Chapter
Cain, Joe;
(2009)
Ernst Mayr and the “Biology of Birds”
(/isis/citation/CBB001022522/)
Be the first to comment!