Article ID: CBB563139806

Ein Scharnier zwischen Eugenik und Recht – der „medizinisch-juristische“ Kommentar im „Dritten Reich“ (2021)

unapi

Before 1933 commentaries on laws were exclusively juristic texts, written and read only by legal professionals. Beginning in 1934, scholars from different disciplines, especially medical scientists, began writing juristic commentaries. The essay examines the reasons for this development and explores how it changed the genre, using the example of the most important commentary on the Blutschutz- and Ehegesundheitsgesetz, which resulted from the collaboration of two medical professionals and a legal professional. The article argues that the recruitment of non-juristic authors and the corresponding methodological changes were caused by a debate on a possible “reform” of juristic commentaries which took place in law journals. From the perspective of the National Socialist regime, the genre in its traditional form was not compatible with the Third Reich’s philosophy of law. In this new genre, commentaries not only referred to legal problems, but also dealt with issues from other disciplines, such as medical questions. The essay modifies Mitchell G. Ash’s theoretical approach regarding the “entanglement” of jurisprudence and other disciplines. Law and other sciences became, according to Ash, “resources for one another”: Legal scholars could claim that legal decisions were based on scientific facts and therefore “unquestionable.” The affected disciplines also gained greater importance as a result of this process in which their findings becoming legally relevant. This transformation also enabled them to acquire resources for new research projects. Moreover, the essay examines the connection between this development and the change of audience within German courts. Not only did the authors of the commentaries change, but also the recipients: Many laws passed after 1933 introduced new courts using lay judges, professionals with a non-law background. These “experts” came from multiple fields connecting them to the new law, such as medical professionals.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB563139806/

Similar Citations

Article Schweikardt, Christoph; (2014)
Autopsy Issues in German Federal Republic Transplantation Legislation until 1997 (/isis/citation/CBB001202355/)

Article Hecht, David K.; (2011)
Constructing a Scientist: Expert Authority and Public Images of Rachel Carson (/isis/citation/CBB001220826/)

Article Kelly, Brendan D.; (2008)
The Mental Treatment Act 1945 in Ireland: An Historical Enquiry (/isis/citation/CBB000950360/)

Chapter Taline Garibian; Alain Giami; Sharman Levinson; (2021)
Medicine and the Paradox of the Decriminalization of Homosexuality in Switzerland: Toward a New System of Coercion (1940–1960) (/isis/citation/CBB708205724/)

Book Vandendriessche, Joris; Peeters, Evert; Wils, Kaat; (2015)
Scientists' Expertise as Performance: Between State and Society, 1860--1960 (/isis/citation/CBB001422486/)

Thesis Bryant, Michael Scott; (2001)
Confronting Medical Mass Murder: The United States and West German Euthanasia Trials, 1945--1965 (/isis/citation/CBB001562425/)

Thesis Buchanan, Nicholas Seong Chul; (2010)
Negotiating Nature: Expertise and Environment in the Klamath River Basin (/isis/citation/CBB001567197/)

Article Matthew J. Brown; Joyce C. Havstad; (2017)
The Disconnect Problem, Scientific Authority, and Climate Policy (/isis/citation/CBB445794671/)

Article Valérie Leclercq; Joris Vandendriessche; (2018)
Taking Scientists (More) Seriously (/isis/citation/CBB717068435/)

Authors & Contributors
Vandendriessche, Joris
Sharman Levinson
Dorsch, Kate
Joyce C. Havstad
Maayan Sudai
Taline Garibian
Concepts
Authorities; experts
Law and legislation
Authority of science
Medicine and law
Science and society
Science and government
Time Periods
20th century
20th century, late
19th century
21st century
20th century, early
Places
United States
Germany
Great Britain
Oregon (U.S.)
Switzerland
Belgium
Institutions
Carl-Zeiss-Stifftung
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment