Article ID: CBB554093002

Gould on Morton, Redux: What can the debate reveal about the limits of data? (2015)

unapi

Lewis et al. (2011) attempted to restore the reputation of Samuel George Morton, a 19th century physician who reported on the skull sizes of different folk-races. Whereas Gould (1978) claimed that Morton's conclusions were invalid because they reflected unconscious bias, Lewis et al. alleged that Morton's findings were, in fact, supported, and Gould's analysis biased. We take strong exception to Lewis et al.’s thesis that Morton was “right.” We maintain that Gould was right to reject Morton's analysis as inappropriate and misleading, but wrong to believe that a more appropriate analysis was available. Lewis et al. fail to recognize that there is, given the dataset available, no appropriate way to answer any of the plausibly interesting questions about the “populations” in question (which in many cases are not populations in any biologically meaningful sense). We challenge the premise shared by both Gould and Lewis et al. that Morton's confused data can be used to draw any meaningful conclusions. This, we argue, reveals the importance of properly focusing on the questions asked, rather than more narrowly on the data gathered.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB554093002/

Similar Citations

Book Fabian, Ann; (2010)
The Skull Collectors: Race, Science, and America's Unburied Dead (/isis/citation/CBB001033349/)

Article Richard McMahon; (2020)
Resurecting raciology? Genetic ethnology and pre-1945 anthropological race classification (/isis/citation/CBB086533805/)

Book Mullaney, Thomas S.; (2011)
Coming to Terms with the Nation: Ethnic Classification in Modern China (/isis/citation/CBB001220085/)

Thesis Edwards, Barrington Steven; (2001)
W. E. B. Du Bois, empirical social research and the challenge to race, 1868-1910 (/isis/citation/CBB001562601/)

Article Aviles-Galan, Miguel Angel; (2010)
Measuring Skulls: Race and Science in Vicente Riva Palacio's México a través de los Siglos (/isis/citation/CBB001030951/)

Article Emily Klancher Merchant; (2022)
Environmental Malthusianism and demography (/isis/citation/CBB821323495/)

Book Schaffer, Gavin; (2008)
Racial Science and British Society, 1930--62 (/isis/citation/CBB000950305/)

Article Turda, Marius; (2007)
From Craniology to Serology: Racial Anthropology in Interwar Hungary and Romania (/isis/citation/CBB000773071/)

Book Inhorn, Marcia Claire; Wentzell, Emily A.; (2012)
Medical Anthropology at the Intersections: Histories, Activisms, and Futures (/isis/citation/CBB001251701/)

Article Gannett, Lisa; (2014)
Biogeographical Ancestry and Race (/isis/citation/CBB001421076/)

Article Alberto Zanatta; Giuliano Scattolin; Gaetano Thiene; Fabio Zampieri; (2016)
Phrenology between anthropology and neurology in a nineteenth-century collection of skulls (/isis/citation/CBB513838346/)

Chapter Larson, Edward J.; (2010)
Biology and the Emergence of the Anglo-American Eugenics Movement (/isis/citation/CBB001020302/)

Book Marchand, Suzanne L.; (2009)
German Orientalism in the Age of Empire: Religion, Race, and Scholarship (/isis/citation/CBB001022934/)

Book Bashford, Alison; Levine, Philippa; (2010)
The Oxford Handbook of the History of Eugenics (/isis/citation/CBB001022744/)

Book Jackson, John P., Jr.; Weidman, Nadine M.; (2004)
Race, Racism, and Science: Social Impact and Interaction (/isis/citation/CBB000650561/)

Book Troumpeta, Sevaste; (2013)
Physical Anthropology, Race and Eugenics in Greece (1880s--1970s) (/isis/citation/CBB001213992/)

Authors & Contributors
Mullaney, Thomas Shawn
Merchant, Emily Klancher
Scattolin, Giuliano
Zanatta, Alberto
Zampieri, Fabio
Wentzell, Emily A.
Concepts
Science and race
Physical anthropology
Ethnicity
Social sciences
National histories
Human genetics
Time Periods
20th century
19th century
21st century
20th century, early
18th century
Places
United States
China
Great Britain
Padua (Italy)
Romania
Sweden
Institutions
University of Padua
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment