Benedetto Castelli’s Considerations on the Lagoon of Venice: Mathematical expertise and hydro-geomorphological transformations in seventeenth-century Venice (2020)
Omodeo, Pietro Daniel (Author)
Trevisani, Sebastiano (Author)
Babu, Senthil (Author)
Earth Sciences History: Journal of the History of the Earth Sciences Society
Volume: 39
Issue: 2
Pages: 420-446
This paper deals with the geoenvironmental politics of early-modern Venice as a case study of geological agency that enlightens the entanglements of geo-history and human history. It focuses on a controversy that was sparked by Galileo’s pupil Benedetto Castelli, as he claimed that his mathematical treatment of running waters could solve all of the most urgent problems linked to the management of the Lagoon of Venice. From an epistemological viewpoint, the controversy is relevant as a case of clashing ‘styles of thought’, as it constituted a disciplinary conflict that pitted Galileian physico-mathematical abstraction (which resulted from the isolation of a set of quantifiable data) against ‘geological’ concreteness (a form of comprehensive knowledge which aimed to cope with systemic complexity). Castelli was not able to convince the Venetian authorities that his method could solve the main problems relative to the conservation of the lagoon at a time when its depth and navigability were worryingly diminishing. While the Venetian authorities invested in diverting rivers away from the lagoon to reduce sediment supply, Castelli argued, to the contrary, that it was precisely the diversion of the rivers that caused shoaling because of the loss of the great quantity of water discharged by the rivers, which he accurately calculated. His analytical approach was dismissive of the comprehensive knowledge and complex methods that Venetian water experts and engineers had developed towards a systemic understanding of the hydrogeology and the environment of the lagoon with the active involvement of citizens and fishermen in the assessment of the state of the waters.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Cristina Baldacci;
Shaul Bassi;
Lucio De Capitani;
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
(2022)
Venice and the Anthropocene: An Ecocritical Guide
(/isis/citation/CBB968298285/)
Chapter
Marianna Tsionki;
(2022)
Porto Marghera: Working-class Environmentalism
(/isis/citation/CBB886773267/)
Chapter
Stefano Piazza;
(2021)
Come studiare la storia delle politiche pubbliche sulle acque
(/isis/citation/CBB686723309/)
Article
Francesco Luzzini;
(2019)
When the Cannaregio Turned Fresh / Quando il Cannaregio si fece dolce
(/isis/citation/CBB145885650/)
Book
Walter Panciera;
(2021)
«L’acqua giusta». Il sistema portuale veneziano nel XVIII secolo
(/isis/citation/CBB937984123/)
Chapter
Diego Angelucci;
(2016)
La valle dell'Adige: genesi e modificazione di una grande valle alpina come interazione tra dinamiche naturali e fattori antropici
(/isis/citation/CBB123194233/)
Chapter
Carlo Togliani;
(2010)
I Bertazzolo: ingegneri e territorio fra XVI e XVII secolo
(/isis/citation/CBB375137014/)
Book
Franco Cazzola;
(2021)
Uomini e fiumi. Per una storia idraulica ed agraria della bassa pianura del Po (1450-1620)
(/isis/citation/CBB034173063/)
Chapter
Fiorenzo Rossi;
(2021)
Polesine: terra, acqua, persone
(/isis/citation/CBB608409836/)
Chapter
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
Heiner Krellig;
(2022)
Venice's Marriage to the Sea: Ritual, Representation, and Environmental Transformation
(/isis/citation/CBB658606328/)
Chapter
Jennifer Scappettone;
(2022)
Tempo: Time/Weather/Rhythm
(/isis/citation/CBB807620616/)
Article
Luzzini, Francesco;
(2016)
Ad venandam veritatem. Nuove ricerche sulle scienze della terra nel «Giornale de’ letterati d’Italia»
(/isis/citation/CBB959586928/)
Chapter
Lino Tosini;
(2021)
La grande alluvione del novembre 1951. Provvedimenti idraulici e ricostruzione idraulica
(/isis/citation/CBB636195675/)
Chapter
Filiberto Agostini;
(2021)
Qualche nota sulle acque del Polesine
(/isis/citation/CBB596880408/)
Book
Erasmo D'Angelis;
Massimo Gargano;
Elisabetta Novello;
(2021)
La grande storia d'Italia raccontata dall'acqua
(/isis/citation/CBB639703806/)
Chapter
Franco Cazzola;
(2021)
Crisi climatica e dominio veneziano nel delta del Po: Ariano, Loreo, Mesola e i confini ferraresi prima di Porto Viro
(/isis/citation/CBB938970653/)
Chapter
Francesco Vallerani;
(2022)
The Last Vegetable Gardens in the Island of Pellestrina
(/isis/citation/CBB350537327/)
Chapter
Paul R. Merchant;
(2022)
Venice and the "New World"
(/isis/citation/CBB659131310/)
Chapter
Giulia Repetti;
(2022)
Seven Steps: Water Staircases as Proxies for the Anthropocene in Venice
(/isis/citation/CBB396716926/)
Chapter
Elena Longhin;
(2022)
Barene and Petrochemicals: The Landscapes of Porto Marghera
(/isis/citation/CBB013846017/)
Be the first to comment!