Scientific Autonomy, Public Accountability, and the Rise of “Peer Review” in the Cold War United States (2018)
Baldwin, Melinda Clare (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 109
Issue: 3
Pages: 538-558
This essay traces the history of refereeing at specialist scientific journals and at funding bodies and shows that it was only in the late twentieth century that peer review came to be seen as a process central to scientific practice. Throughout the nineteenth century and into much of the twentieth, external referee reports were considered an optional part of journal editing or grant making. The idea that refereeing is a requirement for scientific legitimacy seems to have arisen first in the Cold War United States. In the 1970s, in the wake of a series of attacks on scientific funding, American scientists faced a dilemma: there was increasing pressure for science to be accountable to those who funded it, but scientists wanted to ensure their continuing influence over funding decisions. Scientists and their supporters cast expert refereeing—or “peer review,” as it was increasingly called—as the crucial process that ensured the credibility of science as a whole. Taking funding decisions out of expert hands, they argued, would be a corruption of science itself. This public elevation of peer review both reinforced and spread the belief that only peer-reviewed science was scientifically legitimate.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Thesis
Kasey Marie Sease;
(2021)
Marketing Agencies for Science: Nonprofits, Public Science Education, and Capitalism in Modern America
(/isis/citation/CBB197222725/)
Book
Thurs, Daniel Patrick;
(2007)
Science Talk: Changing Notions of Science in American Popular Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB000773753/)
Book
Munns, David P. D.;
(2013)
A Single Sky: How an International Community Forged the Science of Radio Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320933/)
Article
Kinney, D. J.;
(2013)
Selling Greenland: The Big Picture Television Series and the Army's Bid for Relevance during the Early Cold War
(/isis/citation/CBB001212896/)
Article
Wolfe, Audra J.;
(2010)
What Does It Mean to Go Public? The American Response to Lysenkoism, Reconsidered
(/isis/citation/CBB001022644/)
Article
James Lawrence Powell;
(2016)
The Consensus on Anthropogenic Global Warming Matters
(/isis/citation/CBB862128887/)
Article
Benno Nietzel;
(2016)
Propaganda, Psychological Warfare and Communication Research in the USA and the Soviet Union During the Cold War
(/isis/citation/CBB125113340/)
Book
Laura Ciglioni;
(2020)
Culture atomiche. Gli Stati Uniti, la Francia e l'Italia di fronte alla questione nucleare (1962-68)
(/isis/citation/CBB178026218/)
Chapter
Elisabetta Vezzosi;
(2020)
«International inter-changes for the benefit of all mankind». Scienziati statunitensi allo Scientific Forum di Amburgo (1980)
(/isis/citation/CBB056972908/)
Book
Elisabetta Bini;
Elisabetta Vezzosi;
(2020)
Scienziati e guerra fredda: Tra collaborazione e diritti umani
(/isis/citation/CBB957549150/)
Book
Tietge, David J.;
(2002)
Flash Effect: Science and the Rhetorical Origins of Cold War America
(/isis/citation/CBB000201573/)
Book
Jenkins, Dominick;
(2002)
The Final Frontier: America, Science, and Terror
(/isis/citation/CBB000302210/)
Book
Lavine, Matthew;
(2013)
The First Atomic Age: Scientists, Radiations, and the American Public, 1895--1945
(/isis/citation/CBB001213740/)
Article
Hulme, Mike;
(2010)
Claiming and Adjudicating on Mt. Kilimanjaro's Shrinking Glaciers: Guy Callendar, Al Gore and Extended Peer Communities
(/isis/citation/CBB001034650/)
Article
Davidson, Roei;
(2014)
Financial Markets and Authoritative Proximity in Personal Finance Magazines
(/isis/citation/CBB001420115/)
Thesis
Newell, Catherine Lea;
(2012)
The Wheels of Titan: Faith, the Future, and the American Frontier
(/isis/citation/CBB001560757/)
Article
Rekdal, Ole Bjørn;
(2014)
Academic Urban Legends
(/isis/citation/CBB001421187/)
Article
C.G.M. Paxton;
D. Naish;
(2019)
Did Nineteenth Century marine vertebrate fossil discoveries influence sea serpent reports?
(/isis/citation/CBB528039835/)
Book
Eugenia Tognotti;
(2020)
Vaccinare i bambini tra obbligo e persuasione: Tre secoli di controversie. Il caso dell'Italia
(/isis/citation/CBB142911314/)
Article
Sally Shuttleworth;
Berris Charnley;
(2016)
Science Periodicals in the Nineteenth and Twenty-First Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB797624948/)
Be the first to comment!