How does belief in controversial ideas persist? I study a community of parents and practitioners who contend that autism spectrum disorder is caused by harmful environmental exposures – notably, early childhood vaccinations – and that there are worthwhile alternative or experimental treatments. Despite objections from dominant experts, these actors maintain their disputed ideas. This study identifies a set of strategies that help maintain internal legitimacy. In particular, actors protect internal legitimacy through professional alignment and contrastive boundary work. Professional alignment mobilizes resemblances to conventional counterparts (i.e. mainstream doctors) to defend unorthodox practices. Meanwhile, contrastive boundary-work performances convey the defining values and strengths that actors associate with their knowledge community and concomitantly, the weaknesses they ascribe to competing groups. Through these activities, actors respond to perceived threats and construct a distinct group identity anchored in shared knowledge, ways of knowing and practice.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Giampietro Gobo;
Barbara Sena;
(2022)
Questioning and Disputing Vaccination Policies. Scientists and Experts in the Italian Public Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB026130989/)
Book
John H. Evans;
(2020)
The Human Gene Editing Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB424000521/)
Article
Lawless, Christopher J.;
(April 2013)
The low template DNA profiling controversy: Biolegality and boundary work among forensic scientists
(/isis/citation/CBB670065907/)
Article
Pia Vuolanto;
Marjo Kolehmainen;
(July 2021)
Gendered Boundary-work within the Finnish Skepticism Movement
(/isis/citation/CBB137850505/)
Article
Elina I. Mäkinen;
(March 2018)
Action in the Space Between: From Latent to Active Boundaries
(/isis/citation/CBB718195671/)
Article
Jonas Rüppel;
(2019)
“Now Is a Time for Optimism”: The Politics of Personalized Medicine in Mental Health Research
(/isis/citation/CBB269148677/)
Book
Gary Lee Downey;
Teun Zuiderent-Jerak;
(2021)
Making & Doing: Activating STS through Knowledge Expression and Travel
(/isis/citation/CBB056767531/)
Article
Sleeboom-Faulkner, Margaret;
Kumar Patra, Prasanna;
(October 2011)
Experimental stem cell therapy: Biohierarchies and bionetworking in Japan and India
(/isis/citation/CBB894423626/)
Book
Xinxing Chen;
(2016)
Kanjian bujie zhi wu: Gongye shehui zhong zhishi quanwei de wenhua shizuo [Bad Stuff in Your Food and Other Pressing Matters: Cultural Practices in Institutionalized Epistemic Authorities in Industrial Society]
(/isis/citation/CBB838308082/)
Article
Gökçe Günel;
(2018)
The Backbone: Construction of a Regional Electricity Grid in the Arabian Peninsula
(/isis/citation/CBB043986489/)
Article
Michael Clormann;
Nina Klimburg-Witjes;
(2022)
Troubled Orbits and Earthly Concerns: Space Debris as a Boundary Infrastructure
(/isis/citation/CBB293656345/)
Article
Owen Marshall;
(2020)
Shibboleths in the studio: Informal demarcation practices among audio engineers
(/isis/citation/CBB736386887/)
Thesis
Coopersmith, Jared Scott;
(2012)
Scientific Controversies and Boundary Disputes: The Intelligent Design Movement Network
(/isis/citation/CBB001561017/)
Article
Maja Horst;
(May 2022)
Science Communication as a Boundary Space: An Interactive Installation about the Social Responsibility of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB152974027/)
Article
Guus Dix;
(April 2019)
Microeconomic forecasting: Constructing commensurable futures of educational reforms
(/isis/citation/CBB842460109/)
Article
David Moats;
(2019)
Following the Fukushima Disaster on (and against) Wikipedia: A Methodological Note about STS Research and Online Platforms
(/isis/citation/CBB273132193/)
Article
Durant, Darrin;
(October 2011)
Models of democracy in social studies of science
(/isis/citation/CBB562394056/)
Article
Alina Geampana;
(2019)
Risky Technologies: Systemic Uncertainty in Contraceptive Risk Assessment and Management
(/isis/citation/CBB376759289/)
Article
Maite P. Salazar;
Daniel Valenzuela;
Manuel Tironi;
Rodrigo A. Gutiérrez;
(2019)
The ambivalent regulator: The construction of a regulatory style for genetically modified crops in Chile
(/isis/citation/CBB036000701/)
Article
Woochang Lee;
Hyomin Kim;
(2022)
The Politics and Sub-Politics of Mad Cow Disease in South Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB202228566/)
Be the first to comment!